Generalize and assess the EBC Proportionality Law beyond the studied corpus

Determine whether the EBC Proportionality Law identified from classifier-derived file-level proportions in open-source Java projects recurs in other programming languages and software collections, remains stable across successive project releases, and is related to defects or maintenance effort.

Background

The study defines the EBC Proportionality Law as the dominant classifier-derived composition of approximately 13.25% Entity, 42.65% Boundary, and 44.10% Control files among the largest cluster of functional categories. Although this pattern covers many categories and projects, it was identified only in the analyzed open-source Java corpus and is explicitly characterized as an empirical regularity rather than a universal architectural rule.

The paper identifies several unresolved extensions: testing whether the pattern generalizes to other programming languages or software collections, examining whether project proportions remain near the Law or change over time across multiple releases, and determining whether distance from the Law is associated with defects or maintenance effort while accounting for project differences and classifier uncertainty.

References

The scope and effects of the Law remain open questions. The pattern was identified in open-source Java projects and may differ in other languages or software collections. Studying several releases could show whether projects remain near the Law or change over time; earlier work has examined changes in architectural-role distributions across versions. The present study also does not test whether distance from the Law is related to defects or maintenance effort. Those relationships require separate studies that account for project differences and classifier uncertainty.

— The EBC Proportionality Law: A Recurring Architectural-Role Pattern Across Java Software  (2610.26392 - Fudholi et al., 19 Oct 2026) in Section 5, Discussion and Implications, subsection 5.1.2, “RQ2: Scope of the EBC Proportionality Law”