Full characterization of the bulk spectrum in the Multi-Scale Model

Characterize the bulk spectrum of the realized adjacency matrix A of the annealed Multi-Scale Model with node weights x_i drawn independently from a Pareto(α) distribution (0<α<1) and edge probabilities p_{ij}=1−exp(−ε_n x_i x_j) with ε_n=n^{−1/α}. Specifically, determine the eigenvalue density and the precise location of the bulk edge as functions of α and n, refining the current crude upper bound on the spectral norm of the fluctuation matrix H=A−P to include its dependence on α.

Background

The paper decomposes the adjacency matrix A into an expected component P and a fluctuation component H=A−P. The leading (outlier) eigenvalues and eigenvectors of P are analyzed and shown to scale as √n and to exhibit log-periodicity, accurately describing outliers in A up to a growing index on the order of ln n.

Beyond these outliers, the spectrum of A contains a bulk primarily generated by H. The authors derive a crude upper bound for the spectral norm of H that scales as √n, indicating that the bulk edge lies on the same scale as the structural outliers. However, this bound does not yet capture the dependence on the stability index α and the full spectral density of the bulk remains analytically unsettled.

The authors state that a complete analytic characterization of this bulk regime is highly non-trivial and leave it for future work, motivating a precise determination of the bulk spectral density and edge as functions of model parameters to fully understand the competition between structure and randomness in this infinite-mean regime.

References

Nonetheless this crude bound needs refinement, at least to include the dependence on α. This calls for the full characterization of the bulk spectrum, which we leave to future work.

Spectra of random graphs with discrete scale invariance (2509.12407 - Catanzaro et al., 15 Sep 2025) in Main text, Bulk of the spectrum paragraph (following Eq. (eq:upperbound))