Dice Question Streamline Icon: https://streamlinehq.com

Existence of environments yielding large medium-dependent effects on gravitational-wave propagation via cancellation

Determine whether there exist physical environments in which a cancellation analogous to the atomic polarizability cancellation in electromagnetism occurs for gravitational interactions, thereby making medium-dependent effects on gravitational-wave propagation surprisingly large.

Information Square Streamline Icon: https://streamlinehq.com

Background

The essay discusses the 2019 calculation by Flauger and Weinberg of gravitational-wave absorption in hot interstellar gas, highlighting that although low-frequency absorption scales strongly with frequency, it is largely cancelled by stimulated emission, rendering the Universe transparent to gravitational waves at observable scales.

Drawing an analogy with electromagnetism, where medium-dependent propagation effects can be large due to a cancellation in atomic polarizability that removes explicit dependence on the electromagnetic coupling, the author speculates about the gravitational counterpart. The explicit unresolved question asks whether a similar cancellation could occur for gravity, leading to unexpectedly large medium-dependent effects on gravitational-wave propagation.

References

It remains to be seen whether or not environments exist for which a similar cancellation happens for gravity, making medium-dependent effects for gravitational waves surprisingly large.

Reminiscences about Steven Weinberg (This Time it's Personal) (2504.01118 - Burgess, 1 Apr 2025) in Section “A bit of physics”, final paragraph