Physical origin of foreshocks

Determine the physical origin of earthquake foreshocks, specifically whether they are ordinary earthquakes produced by bottom-up triggering cascades or manifestations of a distinct top-down preparatory process.

Background

The paper contrasts two principal interpretations of foreshocks. In bottom-up triggering models such as ETAS, foreshocks are ordinary earthquakes within stochastic triggering cascades and are not physically distinct from other events. In top-down models, foreshocks arise from a preparatory process associated with the approach to a larger instability and may therefore contain predictive information about impending rupture.

The authors use ETAS and ETAFS as controlled limiting cases to study how declustering symmetry affects foreshock detection. However, the synthetic comparisons do not resolve the broader physical question of whether natural foreshocks are fundamentally generated by cascade triggering, by preparatory dynamics, or by an interaction of both mechanisms.

References

The physical origin of foreshocks remains a major unresolved problem in statistical seismology.

— Is the Number of Foreshocks Underestimated? The Role of Declustering Symmetry  (2610.13147 - Prabowo et al., 9 Oct 2026) in Abstract; Section 1, Introduction