Coprimality of subset sizes attaining the n−1 extension bound

Prove that, for every synchronizing Eulerian binary automaton on n states, any proper nonempty subset S satisfying minext(S)=n−1 has cardinality coprime to n.

Background

Theorem 5.2 constructs, for every n≥4 and every subset size m coprime to n, a synchronizing Eulerian binary automaton possessing a subset of size m whose shortest extending word has length n−1. Exhaustive computations indicate that subset sizes not coprime to n attain at most n−2 on the Eulerian binary fibres examined.

The unresolved converse concerns composite n and binary automata with sufficiently many collisions. The paper proves a partial restriction: every prime divisor of gcd(|S|,n) is at most the maximum collision number of a letter. The conjecture is specifically binary, since the paper gives a ternary four-state counterexample.

References

The converse is open. On every fibre swept, a subset size $m$ with $\gcd(m,n)>1$ stops at $n-2$; we conjecture that this holds at every $n$: that a subset $S$ with $\mathrm{minext}(S)=n-1$ of a synchronizing Eulerian binary automaton has $|S|$ coprime to $n$.

— Certificates for short extending words in a finite automaton  (2609.21603 - Miccinesi, 18 Sep 2026) in Section 5.2, Section 5.2 subsection “The Eulerian fibre”; Theorem 5.2 and the discussion following it