Classification and isomorphism of affine-plane gain functions

Determine all gain functions on an affine plane over a field that produce a generalized quadrangle via Construction \mathfrak{M} as in Theorem 7, and determine whether two distinct such gain functions on the same affine plane produce isomorphic generalized quadrangles.

Background

The paper constructs a gain function on the incidence graph of an affine plane over an arbitrary field and proves that the resulting incidence structure is a generalized quadrangle. For finite fields of order q, the construction produces a generalized quadrangle denoted GQ(q+1,q-1), which computational checks indicate is isomorphic to the dual of the Payne generalized quadrangle P(W(q),x) for q up to 16.

The problem asks for a complete classification of all gain functions on an affine plane that satisfy the bijectivity condition required by Theorem 5, as well as a determination of whether different qualifying gain functions can yield nonisomorphic or necessarily isomorphic generalized quadrangles. Both questions are explicitly left unresolved.

References

We end with two open problems for further study.

Determine all of the gain functions on an affine plane over a field that yield a generalized quadrangle as in Theorem 7. Do two different such gain functions (on the same affine plane) yield isomorphic generalized quadrangles?

Incidence Gain Graphs and Generalized Quadrangles  (2502.01805 - McCulloch, 3 Feb 2025) in Section 4, 'Affine Plane Examples and Further Inquiry,' immediately following Theorem 7