Characterize the mode-frequency dependence of the break-even coupling

Characterize how the break-even collective coupling \(\lambda_{\rm be}=g_0N\) depends on the mode frequency \(\nu\), and determine why it does not collapse onto the static Dicke superradiant threshold when \(\nu\) is varied.

Background

At fixed mode frequency ν=5\nu=5, the authors find that the break-even ion number is governed by the collective coupling and corresponds to λbe2.17\lambda_{\rm be}\simeq2.17. They test the conjecture that this break-even coupling should scale with the static Dicke threshold λc\lambda_c.

Scanning ν\nu from 3 to 10 produces 29% scatter in λbe\lambda_{\rm be}, and rescaling by λc\lambda_c does not improve the collapse. The frequency dependence therefore remains unresolved.

References

The g_{0} law is verified at fixed \nu; the \nu dependence is open.

One Bit of Collective Information Is Worth N ln 2 Bits of Local Information in a Many-Body Quantum Battery  (2609.04730 - B et al., 4 Sep 2026) in Section 6, subsection “Two cautionary results”