Dice Question Streamline Icon: https://streamlinehq.com

Analytic criterion for the sign-change of Re[Q(μ=0)]

Derive an analytic condition that determines when the real part of the superfluid stiffness Re[Q(μ=0)] changes sign in the isotropic three-dimensional BCS-type non-Hermitian superconductor with constant s-wave pairing mean fields Δ and \bar{Δ} (not constrained to be Hermitian conjugates), where Q is defined as the second derivative of the action with respect to the vector potential evaluated at zero field.

Information Square Streamline Icon: https://streamlinehq.com

Background

The authors analyze an explicit integral expression for Q(μ=0) in the 3D non-Hermitian BCS model and show that Re(\bar{Δ}Δ) > 0 ensures Re[Q(μ=0)] > 0, while negative values are possible for other parameter regimes, indicating a transition to paramagnetic Meissner response.

Despite this, they report that an analytic determination of the precise boundary at which Re[Q(μ=0)] changes sign is not available due to the complexity of the competing terms in the integrand, leaving the analytic criterion for the sign change unresolved.

References

Unfortunately, due to the complexity of interplay with $A|\bar{\Delta}\Delta|2$, we cannot derive analytically, when the transition from $\Re[Q(\mu=0)]>0$ to $\Re[Q(\mu=0)]<0$ occurs.

Meissner effect in non-Hermitian superconductors (2410.07853 - Tamura et al., 10 Oct 2024) in Supplemental Material, Section S3