The aftermath of Big Deal cancellations and their impact on interlibrary loans

Abstract: A "Big Deal" is a bundle of journals that is offered to libraries by publishers as a "one-price, one size fits all package" (Frazier, 2001). There have been several accounts of Big Deals cancellations by academic libraries in the scientific literature. This paper presents the finding of a literature review aimed at documenting the aftermath of Big Deal cancellation in University Libraries, particularly their impacts on interlibrary loan services. We find that many academic libraries have successfully cancelled their Big Deals, realizing budget savings while limiting negative effects on library users. In particular, existing literature reveals that cancellations have a surprisingly small effect on interlibrary loan requests. The reviewed studies further highlight the importance of access to proper usage data and inclusion of community members of the community (staff, faculty members, students, etc.) in the decision-making process.