Macroscopic loops in the loop O(n) model via the XOR trick (2001.11977v2)

Abstract: The loop $O(n)$ model is a family of probability measures on collections of non-intersecting loops on the hexagonal lattice, parameterized by a loop-weight $n$ and an edge-weight $x$. Nienhuis predicts that, for $0 \leq n \leq 2$, the model exhibits two regimes separated by $x_c(n) = 1/\sqrt{2 + \sqrt{2-n}}$: when $x < x_c(n)$, the loop lengths have exponential tails, while, when $x \geq x_c(n)$, the loops are macroscopic. In this paper, we prove three results regarding the existence of long loops in the loop $O(n)$ model: - In the regime $(n,x) \in [1,1+\delta) \times (1- \delta, 1]$ with $\delta >0$ small, a configuration sampled from a translation-invariant Gibbs measure will either contain an infinite path or have infinitely many loops surrounding every face. In the subregime $n \in [1,1+\delta)$ and $x \in (1-\delta,1/\sqrt{n}]$ our results further imply Russo--Seymour--Welsh theory. This is the first proof of the existence of macroscopic loops in a positive area subset of the phase diagram. - Existence of loops whose diameter is comparable to that of a finite domain whenever $n=1, x \in (1,\sqrt{3}]$; this regime is equivalent to part of the antiferromagnetic regime of the Ising model on the triangular lattice. - Existence of non-contractible loops on a torus when $n \in [1,2], x=1$. The main ingredients of the proof are: (i) the `XOR trick': if $\omega$ is a collection of short loops and $\Gamma$ is a long loop, then the symmetric difference of $\omega$ and $\Gamma$ necessarily includes a long loop as well; (ii) a reduction of the problem of finding long loops to proving that a percolation process on an auxiliary planar graph, built using the Chayes--Machta and Edwards--Sokal geometric expansions, has no infinite connected components; and (iii) a recent result on the percolation threshold of Benjamini--Schramm limits of planar graphs.