Cross-Validation, Risk Estimation, and Model Selection

Abstract: Cross-validation is a popular non-parametric method for evaluating the accuracy of a predictive rule. The usefulness of cross-validation depends on the task we want to employ it for. In this note, I discuss a simple non-parametric setting, and find that cross-validation is asymptotically uninformative about the expected test error of any given predictive rule, but allows for asymptotically consistent model selection. The reason for this phenomenon is that the leading-order error term of cross-validation doesn't depend on the model being evaluated, and so cancels out when we compare two models.