Sharp bounds on the relative treatment effect for ordinal outcomes (1907.10287v2)

Abstract: For ordinal outcomes, the average treatment effect is often ill-defined and hard to interpret. Echoing Agresti and Kateri (2017), we argue that the relative treatment effect can be a useful measure especially for ordinal outcomes, which is defined as $\gamma = \mathrm{pr}{ Y_i(1) > Y_i(0) } - \mathrm{pr}{ Y_i(1) < Y_i(0) }$, with $Y_i(1)$ and $Y_i(0)$ being the potential outcomes of unit $i$ under treatment and control, respectively. Given the marginal distributions of the potential outcomes, we derive the sharp bounds on $\gamma,$ which are identifiable parameters based on the observed data. Agresti and Kateri (2017) focused on modeling strategies under the assumption of independent potential outcomes, but we allow for arbitrary dependence.