Papers
Topics
Authors
Recent
Search
2000 character limit reached

Turbulent Magnetic Prandtl Number in MHD

Updated 28 April 2026
  • Turbulent magnetic Prandtl number is defined as the ratio of kinematic viscosity to magnetic diffusivity, distinguishing the viscous and resistive cutoff scales in MHD turbulence.
  • It governs the efficiency and scaling of dynamo processes, with different regimes (low, high, and near unity) directly affecting growth rates and energy dissipation.
  • Variations in turbulent Prandtl number impact spectral intermittency, energy partition, and angular momentum transport in simulations of astrophysical and laboratory MHD flows.

The turbulent magnetic Prandtl number (Pm\mathrm{Pm}) is a central dimensionless quantity that regulates the relative strength and scale-separation of viscous and resistive dissipation in magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) turbulence. Defined as the ratio of kinematic viscosity (ν\nu) to magnetic diffusivity (η\eta), Pm≡ν/η\mathrm{Pm} \equiv \nu/\eta, it plays a critical role in determining the morphology, efficiency, and nonlinear saturation of both small-scale and large-scale dynamo processes, as well as the universality and intermittency of MHD turbulence across astrophysical and laboratory regimes.

1. Fundamental Definitions and Phenomenological Role

The magnetic Prandtl number, Pm=ν/η\mathrm{Pm}=\nu/\eta, directly measures the separation of the viscous cutoff scale (ℓν∼L Re−1/(1+θ)\ell_\nu\sim L\,\mathrm{Re}^{-1/(1+\theta)}) from the resistive cutoff scale (ℓη∼L Rm−1/(1+θ)\ell_\eta\sim L\,\mathrm{Rm}^{-1/(1+\theta)}), with Reynolds number Re=UL/ν\mathrm{Re} = UL/\nu and magnetic Reynolds number Rm=UL/η\mathrm{Rm} = UL/\eta for characteristic velocity UU and integral scale LL (Bovino et al., 2012, Buchlin, 2011). Physically, Pm≪1\mathrm{Pm}\ll1 characterizes environments (liquid metals, planetary or solar interiors) where magnetic fields are dissipated at scales much larger than velocity features, while Pm≫1\mathrm{Pm}\gg1 pertains to hot, diffuse plasmas (galaxy clusters, ISM) where viscosity dominates at much larger scales than resistivity, enabling the magnetic field to develop much finer structure than the velocity field.

Astrophysical and experimental systems can thereby span Pm\mathrm{Pm} from ∼10−7\sim 10^{-7} (liquid sodium) to ∼1014\sim10^{14} (interstellar medium), with crucial implications for the efficiency and regime of dynamo operation, spectral locality of nonlinear energy transfer, and turbulent transport coefficients.

2. Scaling Laws for Dynamo Growth and Critical Thresholds

In the small-scale turbulent dynamo regime, the value of Pm\mathrm{Pm} selects the principal stretching eddies that foster exponential amplification of magnetic fluctuations, as captured in the Kazantsev framework.

  • For Pm≪1\mathrm{Pm} \ll 1 ("inertial-range dynamo"), the fastest-growing modes are at the resistive scale in the velocity inertial range, leading to a kinematic growth rate γ∝Rmα\gamma \propto \mathrm{Rm}^\alpha.
  • For Pm≫1\mathrm{Pm} \gg 1 ("viscous-range dynamo"), growth localizes to the viscous scale, giving γ∝Reα\gamma \propto \mathrm{Re}^\alpha with α=(1−θ)/(1+θ)\alpha = (1-\theta)/(1+\theta) for a velocity spectrum v(ℓ)∝ℓθv(\ell)\propto\ell^\theta (Bovino et al., 2012, Schober et al., 2011). In Kolmogorov turbulence (θ=1/3\theta=1/3), this yields α=1/2\alpha=1/2; in Burgers turbulence (θ=1/2\theta=1/2), α=1/3\alpha=1/3. Empirical and shell-model studies commonly find slightly reduced exponents, e.g., β≈0.4\beta\approx0.4 (Buchlin, 2011).

The critical magnetic Reynolds number for dynamo sustained growth, Rmc\mathrm{Rm}_c, is itself a function of the turbulence spectrum. E.g., Rmc∼110\mathrm{Rm}_c\sim110 for Kolmogorov, ∼2700\sim2700 for Burgers (Schober et al., 2011). At very large Re\mathrm{Re} (fixed Pm\mathrm{Pm}), Rmc\mathrm{Rm}_c saturates to a constant O(10210^2–10310^3), allowing even low-Pm flows at high Re\mathrm{Re} to support dynamo action (Buchlin, 2011, Bovino et al., 2012).

Notably, for Pm\mathrm{Pm} near unity, there is a rapid crossover between regimes, with the dynamo growth rate rising sharply as Pm\mathrm{Pm} increases past order-unity values (Bovino et al., 2012).

3. Turbulent Magnetic Prandtl Number and Effective Transport

The "turbulent magnetic Prandtl number" (Pmt\mathrm{Pm}_t), defined as the ratio of turbulent viscosity to turbulent resistivity (νt/ηt\nu_t/\eta_t), is an essential large-eddy parameter in mean-field and subgrid MHD models. Measurements from DNS using test-field and imposed-shear methods show that for isotropic, homogeneous turbulence at sufficiently large Re\mathrm{Re} and scale separation, Pmt≈0.9\mathrm{Pm}_t\approx0.9–$0.95$ (Käpylä et al., 2019). This is systematically higher than analytic/FOSA predictions (Pmt∼0.4\mathrm{Pm}_t\sim0.4–$0.8$) and moderately scale-dependent: at large scales, Pmt\mathrm{Pm}_t can take values up to 4–6, decreasing to ∼1\sim1–2 at the dissipation scale (Bian et al., 2021).

Coarse-graining and cascade analysis demonstrate that the scale-dependent Pmt\mathrm{Pm}_t follows a power law with wavenumber, typically Pmt(k)∼k−(α−β)\mathrm{Pm}_t(k)\sim k^{-(\alpha-\beta)} with α=2(1−σu)\alpha=2(1-\sigma_u), β=2(1−σb)\beta=2(1-\sigma_b) for spectral exponents σu\sigma_u and σb\sigma_b; however, at asymptotically high Re\mathrm{Re} both cascades converge and Pmt\mathrm{Pm}_t becomes O(1) and scale-independent (Bian et al., 2021).

4. Dissipation, Intermittency, and Spectral Energy Partition

The partition of dissipation between viscous heating (ϵK\epsilon_K) and Ohmic heating (ϵM\epsilon_M) is a monotonic function of Pm\mathrm{Pm}, empirically following a power law ϵK/ϵM∝Pmq\epsilon_K/\epsilon_M\propto \mathrm{Pm}^q, with qq ranging from $0.3$–$0.6$ for non-helical (small-scale dynamo) turbulence to as high as $2/3$ for helical (large-scale dynamo) conditions (Brandenburg, 2010, Brandenburg, 2014, McKay et al., 2018). DNS shows that for Pm≪1\mathrm{Pm}\ll1, magnetic energy dissipation dominates; for Pm≫1\mathrm{Pm}\gg1, kinetic dissipation dominates and most turbulent energy is removed viscously.

This scaling underpins the structure of energy spectra and the nature of intermittency: at high Pm\mathrm{Pm}, magnetic fields become highly intermittent with small-scale current sheets dominating dissipation; at low Pm\mathrm{Pm}, vorticity becomes comparatively more intermittent, and current structures are smoother (Sahoo et al., 2010). There is a clear crossover in the relative intermittency of kinetic and magnetic fields as Pm\mathrm{Pm} is varied, implying that phenomenological and closure models must explicitly incorporate Pm\mathrm{Pm}-dependent corrections (Sahoo et al., 2010).

5. MRI-Driven Turbulence and Transport: Pm\mathrm{Pm} Dependence and Saturation

MRI-driven dynamos in accretion disc shearing-box simulations exhibit a strong dependence of the turbulent angular momentum transport parameter (α\alpha), magnetic energy, and stress on Pm\mathrm{Pm} (Guilet et al., 2022, Held et al., 2022, Käpylä et al., 2010, Potter et al., 2017, Mamatsashvili et al., 2020). Empirical findings are:

  • For moderate Pm\mathrm{Pm}, α∝Pmq\alpha\propto\mathrm{Pm}^q, with q∼0.5q\sim0.5–$0.8$ when Reynolds number is fixed.
  • At sufficiently large Pm\mathrm{Pm} (≳100\gtrsim 100), a transition to a Pm\mathrm{Pm}-independent plateau is observed: further increases in Pm\mathrm{Pm} do not raise α\alpha or EmagE_{\rm mag}, indicating decoupling from microphysical dissipation (Guilet et al., 2022, Held et al., 2022).

Zero-net-flux MRI turbulence is unsustainable below a system- and setup-dependent critical Pmc∼1\mathrm{Pm}_c\sim1–$3$ for canonical boxes; tall boxes or vertical field allow sustenance at much lower Pm\mathrm{Pm} via the development of strong mean-field dynamo modes (Käpylä et al., 2010, Mamatsashvili et al., 2020). The underlying process is controlled by the competition between nonlinear transverse (angle-dependent) and direct (modulus) energy cascades in Fourier space, with the weakening of the transverse cascade at low Pm\mathrm{Pm} leading to turbulent decay.

Rotational and vertical aspect ratio, net magnetic flux, and boundary conditions further modulate the Pm\mathrm{Pm}-sensitivity and the critical thresholds for turbulence and mean-field generation (Held et al., 2022, Potter et al., 2017).

6. Asymptotic Behavior and Astrophysical Implications

High-resolution simulations of supernova-driven galactic dynamos and isothermal compressible turbulence demonstrate that the saturated level of the small-scale dynamo is not a monotonic function of Pm\mathrm{Pm} but reaches an asymptote for surprisingly modest values (Pm≳10\mathrm{Pm}\gtrsim 10–$100$) (Gent et al., 19 Dec 2025, Bovino et al., 2012, Buchlin, 2011). Typical results show the magnetic energy fraction at saturation approaches a limiting value ε∞≈0.05\varepsilon_\infty\approx 0.05 (i.e., Brms≈0.3 BeqB_{\mathrm{rms}}\approx0.3\,B_{\mathrm{eq}} for Pm≫1\mathrm{Pm}\gg1), with little further dependence on Pm\mathrm{Pm} at higher values. This supports the universality of small-scale dynamo saturation at astrophysically relevant Pm\mathrm{Pm}, though observed galactic fields frequently reach higher equipartition fractions—suggesting additional large-scale mechanisms or missing physics.

For accretion discs, the α\alpha–Pm\mathrm{Pm} dependence can generate a thermal-viscous instability if q>0.5q>0.5, giving rise to limit-cycle behavior and natural "S-curve" state transitions analogous to those observed in black hole X-ray binaries, directly seeded by the variation of Pm\mathrm{Pm} with local thermodynamic conditions (Potter et al., 2017).

Turbulent Pm\mathrm{Pm} is key in setting the efficiency of large-scale flux advection versus diffusion in discs, with Pmt(R/H)>1\mathrm{Pm}_t(R/H)>1 required for flux to be advected faster than it is diffused (Bian et al., 2021).

7. Summary Table: Key Regime-Dependent Scaling Laws

Regime Growth Rate Scaling Dissipation Ratio (DNS) Key Reference
Pm≪1\mathrm{Pm}\ll1 γ∝Rmα\gamma \propto \mathrm{Rm}^\alpha; α=1−θ1+θ\alpha=\frac{1-\theta}{1+\theta} ϵK/ϵM∼Pm0.3−0.6\epsilon_K/\epsilon_M \sim \mathrm{Pm}^{0.3-0.6} (Bovino et al., 2012, McKay et al., 2018)
Pm≫1\mathrm{Pm}\gg1 γ∝Reα\gamma \propto \mathrm{Re}^\alpha ϵK/ϵM∼Pm0.6\epsilon_K/\epsilon_M \sim \mathrm{Pm}^{0.6} (Bovino et al., 2012, Brandenburg, 2010)
Pm∼1\mathrm{Pm}\sim1 Rapid growth-rate enhancement; crossover Inflection in dissipation ratio (Bovino et al., 2012)
MRI saturation α∼Pm0.5−0.8\alpha \sim \mathrm{Pm}^{0.5-0.8} up to plateaus Plateau above Pm∼100\mathrm{Pm}\sim100 (Guilet et al., 2022, Held et al., 2022)
Turbulent Pmt\mathrm{Pm}_t ≈1\approx1 at smallest inertial scale, $4-6$ at largest scales -- (Käpylä et al., 2019, Bian et al., 2021)

References

  • (Buchlin, 2011) Buchlin, "Intermittent turbulent dynamo at very low and high magnetic Prandtl numbers"
  • (Bovino et al., 2012) Schober et al., "Turbulent magnetic field amplification from the smallest to the largest magnetic Prandtl numbers"
  • (Schober et al., 2011) Schober et al., "Magnetic Field Amplification by Small-Scale Dynamo Action: Dependence on Turbulence Models and Reynolds and Prandtl Numbers"
  • (Guilet et al., 2022) Riols et al., "MRI-driven dynamo at very high magnetic Prandtl numbers"
  • (Held et al., 2022) Held & Mamatsashvili, "MRI turbulence in accretion discs at large magnetic Prandtl numbers"
  • (Käpylä et al., 2010) Käpylä & Korpi, "Magnetorotational instability driven dynamos at low magnetic Prandtl numbers"
  • (Brandenburg, 2010) Brandenburg, "Dissipation in dynamos at low and high magnetic Prandtl numbers"
  • (Käpylä et al., 2019) Käpylä et al., "Turbulent viscosity and effective magnetic Prandtl number from simulations of isotropically forced turbulence"
  • (Brandenburg, 2014) Brandenburg, "Magnetic Prandtl number dependence of kinetic to magnetic dissipation ratio"
  • (McKay et al., 2018) Linkmann et al., "Fully resolved array of simulations investigating the influence of the magnetic Prandtl number on magnetohydrodynamic turbulence"
  • (Sahoo et al., 2010) Kumar et al., "Systematics of the magnetic-Prandtl-number dependence of homogeneous, isotropic magnetohydrodynamic turbulence"
  • (Gent et al., 19 Dec 2025) Gent et al., "Asymptotic behaviour of galactic small-scale dynamos at modest magnetic Prandtl number"
  • (Bian et al., 2021) Alexakis & Aluie, "Scaling of Turbulent Viscosity and Resistivity: Extracting a Scale-dependent Turbulent Magnetic Prandtl Number"
  • (Mamatsashvili et al., 2020) Mamatsashvili et al., "Zero net flux MRI-turbulence in disks −- sustenance scheme and magnetic Prandtl number dependence"
  • (Potter et al., 2017) Potter & Balbus, "Demonstration of a magnetic Prandtl number disc instability from first principles"
Definition Search Book Streamline Icon: https://streamlinehq.com
References (15)

Topic to Video (Beta)

No one has generated a video about this topic yet.

Whiteboard

No one has generated a whiteboard explanation for this topic yet.

Follow Topic

Get notified by email when new papers are published related to Turbulent Magnetic Prandtl Number.