TMF-Modules in Algebraic Topology

• TMF-modules are spectra equipped with a module structure over the TMF ring, encapsulating deep chromatic, modular, and arithmetic information.
• Their structure is defined via graded homotopy groups over π_*TMF, reflecting periodicity, torsion, and level-structured variations that aid in precise classification.
• Applications span obstruction theory, Euler class constructions, and the development of refined invariants in both algebraic topology and quantum field theory.

A TMF-module is, fundamentally, a spectrum with a module structure over the (periodic or connective) spectrum of topological modular forms (TMF or tmf), and forms a critical object of paper at the interface of stable homotopy theory, algebraic geometry, and modular forms. TMF-modules encode not only deep chromatic and arithmetic information—via the connection of their homotopy with the moduli of elliptic curves—but also embody a powerful algebraic framework for distinguishing objects, structures, and invariants in topology, field theory, and derived algebraic geometry.

1. Definition, Structure, and Algebraic Properties

A TMF-module is a spectrum equipped with an action of the $E_\infty$-ring spectrum TMF (or tmf, or its level-structured variants such as TMF$_1(3)$, etc.), making the category of such modules symmetric monoidal and stable. The foundational construction is as a module object over TMF in the category of spectra:

• The homotopy groups of a TMF-module are naturally graded modules over the graded ring $\pi_* \textrm{TMF}$ (or $\pi_* \textrm{tmf}$).
• The algebraic complexity of $\pi_* \textrm{TMF}$, including torsion, periodicity (notably 576-periodicity in the periodic case), and relations among modular forms, is mirrored in the complexity and richness of TMF-modules; this shapes both their structure and their classification (Konter, 2012, Mathew et al., 2014).

TMF-modules support various structures:

TMF-Type	Module Category	Periodicity	Characterization
TMF	Perf(TMF)	576	Invertibles all suspensions
tmf	Perf(tmf)	No full per.	More torsion, not all suspensions
TMF$_1(n)$, TMF$_0(n)$	Level-structured	Various	Localized over moduli with level

Invertible TMF-modules—elements of the Picard group—are classified for both periodic and connective cases, revealing strong algebraicity for TMF (cyclic of order 576, generated by the suspension) but with exotic classes for Tmf (an infinite cyclic part plus a 24-torsion element not corresponding to a suspension) (Mathew et al., 2014).

2. Geometric and Derived Foundations

The construction of TMF-modules rests on the derived algebraic geometry of the moduli stack of elliptic curves $\mathcal{M}_{ell}$, realized via the Goerss–Hopkins–Miller–Lurie theory:

• TMF is the spectrum of global sections of a sheaf of $E_\infty$-ring spectra $\mathcal{O}^{top}$ over $\mathcal{M}_{ell}$, with variants at different compactifications and with level structures (Mathew, 2013, Behrens, 2019, Laures, 2013).
• The category of perfect TMF-modules is equivalent (under derived descent) to $$\operatorname{QCoh}(\mathcal{M}_{ell}, \mathcal{O}^{top})$$ (Mathew, 2013).

This geometric perspective governs both local and global properties:

• Thick subcategories of perfect TMF-modules correspond bijectively to specialization-closed subsets of $|\mathcal{M}_{ell}|$, as established using methods from both stable and derived homotopy theory (Mathew, 2013).
• The support theory for TMF-modules enables analogs of the Hopkins–Smith thick theorem within the TMF context, reflecting the correspondence between arithmetic stratifications (loci of different heights, singularities, etc.) and chromatic complexity in module theory.

3. Connective and Level-Structured TMF-Modules

A pivotal advance comes from the construction of connective models of TMF with level structure, notably TMF(3) and its connective covers:

• X $\wedge$ tmf model: The smash product of the connective TMF spectrum tmf with a specific 10-cell complex $X$ yields a model for tmf(3), which is itself a ring spectrum. The carefully engineered cell structure ensures a manageable Steenrod module structure and makes $X \wedge \mathrm{tmf}$ a robust starting point for obstruction theory and for replacing periodic TMF(3) in contexts where full periodicity is not required (Davis et al., 2010).
• Other connective models (such as $Z \wedge \textrm{tmf}$ and tmf$\wedge$tmf) illustrate the role of spectrum extensions and inform the non-existence of certain Brown–Gitler type splittings at higher chromatic levels, reflecting a deep difference between tmf-based resolutions and their bo-based analogs.

These connective models define important classes of TMF-modules, crucial for calculations of tmf(3)-homology of spaces like $\mathbb{RP}^\infty$, and for understanding associated Adams spectral sequences, where the structure of associated graded groups is built from towers and periodicities in generators like $a$ and $v_2$ (Davis et al., 2010, Behrens et al., 2015). These calculations directly inform the module structure, observable extension phenomena, and applications to obstruction theory.

4. Homotopy Groups, Module Comparisons, and Torsion

Any TMF-module inherently reflects the structure of the coefficient ring $\pi_*\textrm{TMF}$ (periodic or connective):

• Spectral sequences (such as the elliptic spectral sequence, Adams–Novikov, or descent spectral sequences) compute $\pi_*$ of TMF, tmf, and their modules, with E$_2$-pages directly related to (co-)homology of modular stacks and the line bundle $\omega$ (Konter, 2012, Mathew, 2013, Behrens, 2019).
• For TMF or Tmf, localization at 2 or 3 reveals elaborate torsion structures, periodicities, and extension classes (e.g., hidden extensions involving $h_1$, $h_2$), all of which are inherited or mirrored in the homotopy of TMF-modules.

Explicitly, for TMF$_1(3)$, the homotopy groups and module structures reflect level structures (at prime 3) in Weierstrass coordinates, making such modules particularly sensitive to congruence phenomena (Laures, 2013). The construction of characteristic classes (generalized Pontryagin classes) in the TMF$_1(3)$-cohomology of $BSpin$ and $BString$ provide refined generators, establishing a bridge from representation theory (e.g., of loop groups) to explicit elements in these module categories.

5. Obstructions, Orientations, and Picard Groups

TMF-modules are critical in the paper of orientations and obstructions:

• The existence and classification of $\mathbb{E}_\infty$ String orientations from $MString$ to tmf are parameterized arithmetically via sequences of modular forms (moments) satisfying generalized Kummer congruences (Sprang et al., 2014). This arithmetic parametrization governs obstruction theory for such orientations, with implications for the existence of exotic or non-liftable orientations.
• TMF-modules are essential in constructing Euler classes, cobordism invariants, and objects in derived geometry, with precise analogies to KO-theory but at a far richer chromatic and arithmetic level (Douglas et al., 2011).
• The Picard group calculation for TMF-modules shows that for periodic TMF, invertible modules are all suspensions (cyclic of order 576), while for Tmf, a 24-torsion "exotic" invertible module exists not representing a suspension (Mathew et al., 2014). This dichotomy has notable implications for duality and symmetry operations on TMF-modules.

6. Applications: Computations, Obstruction Theory, and Physical Invariants

The robust algebraic and geometric data residing in TMF-modules drives a variety of applications:

• Extensive calculations of the homology of tmf, the structure of tmf–Hurewicz images, and the construction of tmf-modules from finite spectra like $A_1$ (with controlled v$_2$-periodic self-maps) all proceed via the formalism of modules over TMF and relevant spectral sequences (Pham, 2019, Behrens et al., 2020).
• The non-realizability of tmf as a ring quotient of string bordism, and as a Thom spectrum, emphasizes the intrinsic complexity and distinctive algebraic structure at play in TMF-modules (McTague, 2013, Chatham, 2019).
• Connective covers of TMF with level structures (e.g., tmf$_0(3)$) can be obtained via splitings with appropriate finite complexes, facilitating new computational possibilities in constructing explicit TMF-modules (Carrick et al., 2023).
• In mathematical physics, TMF-modules arise as targets for topological invariants of manifolds (e.g., in invariants valued in $\pi_*(\mathrm{TMF})$ associated to symmetric bilinear forms or linking pairings of 3-manifolds), providing new directions in the paper of topological quantum field theories and distinguishing phases of field theories (Gukov et al., 15 Sep 2025).
• Further, TMF-modules associated with conformal nets and field theoretical models (such as bundles of boundary conditions for free fermion nets) align TMF-cohomology with categories arising in quantum physics and topology (Douglas et al., 2011).

7. Classification, Support, and Chromatic Implications

TMF-modules and their thick subcategories are classified via geometric methods:

• Every thick subcategory of perfect TMF-modules is determined by specialization-closed subsets of the topological space of the moduli stack of elliptic curves (Mathew, 2013). This endows the category with a geometry-driven stratification mirroring chromatic level, formal group height, and associated arithmetic geometry.
• The methods and support theory for TMF-modules serve as a robust framework for the paper of nilpotence, detection functors, and local-to-global principles within chromatic homotopy theory.
• These classification results connect directly with advances in motivic and equivariant spectral algebra, tying the structure of TMF-modules to more general objects in derived algebraic geometry, Real and motivic bordism, and Shapovalov-type pairings in 3- and 4-manifold invariants (Carrick et al., 2023, Gukov et al., 15 Sep 2025).

---

TMF-modules thus provide the architecture upon which refined computational, geometric, and physical invariants are built within modern algebraic topology. Their properties reflect the deep interplay between stable homotopy theory and the arithmetic geometry of modular forms, with direct implications for the understanding of chromatic phenomena, geometric orientations, and applications to field theory and manifold invariants.