Partially Pinned Solids Overview
- Partially pinned solids are many-body states in which a subset of degrees of freedom is fixed, while a complementary sector remains mobile and reconfigurable.
- In systems like amorphous glasses, pinning stiffens materials, shifts yield strains, and transforms system-spanning avalanches into localized rearrangements.
- This concept spans diverse applications—from dusty plasmas to quantum systems—introducing characteristic scales that govern transport and collective dynamics.
“Partially pinned solid” is a field-dependent term for a state in which pinning constrains only part of the relevant degrees of freedom, leaving a complementary sector mobile, deformable, or dynamically reconfigurable. In atomistic glasses it usually denotes an amorphous solid with a fraction of particles immobilized during nonaffine relaxation; in driven dusty plasmas it denotes the disordered plastic-flow regime between fully pinned and fully moving states; in semi-solid membrane models it denotes coexistence of finite shear rigidity and finite lateral diffusivity; in droplet evaporation it denotes a sessile droplet with a mobile contact line; and in dislocation and Wigner-solid problems it denotes solids where only part of the defect or electronic structure is pinned by obstacles or disorder (Bhowmik et al., 2019, Huang et al., 2022, Pandey et al., 2024, Govindha et al., 10 Nov 2025, Bhattacharya et al., 2010, Xiang et al., 2024).
1. Definitions and scope
Across the literature, the phrase does not identify a single microscopic object. It instead labels a family of constrained many-body states in which pinning introduces an additional quenched length, force, or time scale while preserving some mobile response. The corresponding control parameters vary by system: the pinned-particle fraction in amorphous solids, the mismatch ratio and substrate depth in driven dusty plasmas, the solid-node area fraction in semi-solid membranes, the pinning fraction in partly pinned fluids, and defect density or carrier density in dislocation and Wigner-solid problems (Bhowmik et al., 2019, Huang et al., 2022, Pandey et al., 2024, Krakoviack, 2010, Xiang et al., 2024).
| Domain | Meaning of “partially pinned” | Main control variable(s) |
|---|---|---|
| Amorphous solids | Random fraction of particles pinned during relaxation | , , |
| Dusty plasma | Mixed plastic-flow state with pinned and flowing particles | , 0, 1 |
| Semi-solid membrane | 2 and 3 coexist | 4, 5 |
| Sessile droplets | Contact line recedes during evaporation | 6, 7, 8 |
| Partly pinned fluids | Frozen subset of an equilibrium parent fluid | 9 |
| Dislocations / Wigner solids | Pinned defect or electronic substructures coexist with mobile ones | 0, carrier density |
A recurrent distinction is between complete pinning, where the relevant coordinate is fixed for most of the process, and partial pinning, where only a subset is immobilized or where pinning competes with mobility. In several settings this competition yields mixed states: localized and extended plasticity in glasses, trapped wells and flowing channels in dusty plasmas, solid-like and fluid-like modes in membranes, or pinned crystalline domains embedded in a liquid background in Wigner systems. This suggests a unifying operational definition: partial pinning is a constrained state in which quenched anchors modify collective organization without completely eliminating motion.
2. Amorphous solids under shear and tension
In model glasses, a partially pinned solid is constructed by randomly selecting a fraction 1 of particles and allowing them to undergo the imposed affine deformation while keeping them fixed during the subsequent energy minimization. This protocol was studied in two-dimensional and three-dimensional Kob–Andersen binary Lennard-Jones glasses under athermal quasistatic loading, with typical strain increments 2 or 3, and with pinned particles chosen so that close contacts are avoided under affine shear (Bhowmik et al., 2019, Bhowmik et al., 2018).
The yielding problem was recast as a disorder-influenced spinodal for an overlap-based order parameter. For replicas 4, the local overlap is
5
with 6. The relevant correlator is
7
and near yielding it is assumed to take the critical form
8
Its susceptibility obeys
9
Without pinning, the correlation length grows up to the system size, so 0. With pinning, the growth of 1 is cut off by the mean pinned-particle spacing
2
and the peak susceptibility saturates rather than diverging: 3 This is the central argument that particle pinning suppresses the critical spinodal associated with shear-banding instability (Bhowmik et al., 2019).
At the macroscopic level, random pinning stiffens the glass, shifts the yield strain to larger values, reduces configurational fluctuations, and replaces system-spanning avalanches with localized rearrangements. In steady flow, the unpinned system recovers the benchmark scaling 4, whereas increasing 5 drives the exponent 6 toward 7 in 8 and to somewhat below 9 in 0, consistent with a crossover from sub-extensive avalanches to nearly intensive events. Around 1 in 2, the large-3 hump in the cluster-size distribution disappears, finite-size dependence becomes negligible, and local-overlap maps show homogeneous proliferation of localized relaxation without shear bands (Bhowmik et al., 2018).
The same logic extends to cavitation-driven fracture under athermal quasistatic expansion. There, pinning fractions 4–5 increase the sustainable hydrostatic tension, shift cavitation to lower density, flatten susceptibility peaks, and transform a dominant cavity into many small cavities. The lowest nonzero Hessian eigenvalue still vanishes with saddle-node form,
6
but the associated plastic eigenmode becomes screened: 7 with 8 tracking the inclusion spacing 9. The resulting intrinsic plasticity length removes strong system-size effects and homogenizes damage (Dattani et al., 2023).
Under oscillatory AQS shear, random pinning also changes the glass-forming character. In the three-dimensional Kob–Andersen model, the kinetic fragility 0 decreases from 1 at 2 to 3 at 4; in two dimensions it decreases from 5 to 6 at 7. The yielding amplitude rises from 8 in poorly annealed unpinned 9 samples to 0 at 1, while large-2 visualizations show that shear bands present in unpinned systems disappear in pinned ones. The transient cycle count to steady state diverges near yield and scales as 3, with 4 in 5 and 6 in 7 (Chatterjee et al., 2024).
3. Driven periodic media and depinning
In periodically modulated driven media, “partially pinned solid” can refer either to an intermediate dynamical state or to a symmetry-broken ordered phase. For a two-dimensional Yukawa dusty plasma driven across a triangular substrate, the partially pinned state is the disordered plastic-flow regime between the fully pinned and moving ordered limits. The dynamics obey the underdamped Langevin equation
8
with Yukawa interparticle interactions and a triangular periodic substrate of depth 9. The state is identified by intermediate mobility
0
nonzero but sublinear transport, reduced sixfold coordination 1, and a broadened 2. Using the criterion 3 for pinning, the underdense system at 4 has an Aubry threshold 5: for 6, 7 and superlubricity holds; for 8, a pinned 9 plastic 0 moving-ordered sequence appears. At 1, 2 at small drive, rises sharply to 3 at 4, and approaches 5 for 6 (Huang et al., 2022).
A different usage appears in a vortex lattice on a square pinning array at filling ratio 7. There the partially pinned solid is an equilibrium low-temperature crystal that breaks the substrate’s fourfold symmetry: vortices sit off-center within each pin square so that only one of the substrate reciprocal vectors is retained. Its defining structural signature is the absence of the pure 8-component Bragg peak 9, while 0 and 1 remain present. This state exhibits strong transport anisotropy, with depinning thresholds 2 along the easy direction, 3 along the diagonal, and 4 perpendicular to the easy direction. For drives well above threshold, the average velocity shows a minimum near melting, at 5 for easy-axis drive and 6 for diagonal drive, an analogue of the peak effect (Joseph, 2020).
These two usages are related but not identical. In the dusty-plasma problem, partial pinning is a heterogeneous transport regime with trapped and mobile particles. In the vortex problem, it is a symmetry-broken solid phase whose anisotropic motion emerges from the missing reciprocal vector. The shared feature is that pinning does not simply arrest all motion; it selectively reorganizes collective pathways.
4. Soft-matter, statistical-mechanical, and interfacial realizations
A semi-solid membrane provides a distinct realization of partial pinning. The membrane is modeled as a fluctuating randomly triangulated mesh with solid nodes of fixed connectivity and fluid nodes that can undergo bond flips. All solid nodes are then pinned to their initial in-plane positions by
7
with 8. Transport is characterized by the mean-squared displacement 9, which evolves from diffusion to subdiffusion and then localization as the solid-node area fraction 00 increases; the localization threshold is 01–02. Pinning shifts the onset of rigidity to much lower 03: 04 already for 05, while the long-time diffusivity 06 is unchanged within error bars. The resulting coexistence window 07 defines a partially pinned solid with non-zero shear modulus and non-zero lateral diffusivity. By contrast, the bending modulus extracted from
08
remains unchanged (Pandey et al., 2024).
In jammed particulate matter, pins act as fixed force centers that scaffold contact networks. For bidisperse frictionless soft discs with harmonic repulsion, the low-density shift of the jamming threshold is universal: 09 with slope 10 from random pins, while standard near-jamming scalings remain intact: 11 At higher pin density, bond-orientational order appears, force distributions broaden toward heavier tails, and square pin lattices develop cubic elastic anisotropy through a Zener ratio 12 that tracks the growth of 13 (Zhang et al., 2022).
In homogeneous partly pinned fluids, the matrix is created by freezing a random fraction 14 of an equilibrium parent fluid or one component of an equilibrium binary mixture. Because the matrix is prepared in equilibrium with the adsorbed fluid, a complementarity identity holds: 15 For disconnected averages,
16
so fluid-template correlations replace difficult quenched products. In random pinning,
17
exactly, and the small-18 disconnected correlations obey
19
The corresponding homogeneous lattice gas maps directly onto a random-field Ising model with a strongly asymmetric bimodal field (Krakoviack, 2010, Krakoviack, 2014).
An interfacial usage appears in sessile droplet evaporation. There, partial pinning means that the contact line is mobile: on PTFE, pure-water droplets show an initial constant-contact-radius stage up to roughly 20, then a constant-contact-angle stage, and finally a mixed mode in which both 21 and 22 decrease. In multi-droplet arrays with spacing ratio 23, central-droplet lifetime increases from 24 s for an isolated partially pinned droplet to 25 s in a five-droplet configuration, a relative increase of 26. The coupled diffusion-cooling model uses
27
together with a suppression matrix
28
and predicts central-droplet lifetimes with maximum deviation 29 by Method 1 and 30 by Method 2 (Govindha et al., 10 Nov 2025).
5. Crystalline defects, partial pinning of dislocations, and elastic-wave transport
In crystalline plasticity, a partially pinned solid is one in which some dislocations are pinned at obstacles while others remain mobile. A pinned segment between obstacles behaves as a damped string under static shear load. The governing equation is
31
Molecular-dynamics simulations for an edge dislocation in b.c.c. molybdenum pinned by a nanovoid showed free inertial oscillations after pinning, rather than forced oscillations. The extracted effective mass per unit length is
32
and the dominant oscillation frequency decreases from 33 GHz at 34 nm to 35 GHz at 36 nm. The anomalous frequency-length relation is resolved by replacing rigid ends with flexible boundary conditions,
37
with fitted stiffness 38 (Bhattacharya et al., 2010).
For extended dislocations split into two partials, partial pinning requires comparing the pinning stress of each partial with the stress scale associated with the stacking fault. The equilibrium separation is
39
and the associated coupling stress is
40
The elastic-manifold pinning stress of a partial is
41
If 42, the two partials pin largely independently and the stacking-fault width evolves as
43
If 44, the extended dislocation is pinned and depins coherently as a whole. In equiatomic FeNiCr, atomistic analysis gives 45 MPa, while constrained pinning yields a Larkin length 46 nm and can increase the effective pinning stress by about a factor of five at 47 nm (Vaid et al., 2021).
Pinned dislocations also control wave transport. In a continuum with a random distribution of pinned edge-dislocation segments, each segment acts as a dynamical scatterer with fundamental frequency
48
The single-segment Born series is geometric, so the all-orders T-matrix takes the closed form 49, and in the independent scattering approximation the coherent self-energy is 50. At low frequency the divergent real part is renormalizable to zero; at higher frequency a cutoff 51 tied to the segment length is required (Churochkin et al., 2015). At the level of intensity transport, the Bethe–Salpeter equation and Ward–Takahashi identity yield a diffusion pole
52
with a diffusion constant that depends on the bare 53, the renormalized coherent velocities and attenuation lengths, the segment density 54, and the resonance structure of the string. The low-density limit recovers equipartition,
55
but equipartition does not generally survive when resonant dislocation dynamics is important (Churochkin et al., 2022).
6. Quantum and electronic solids
In lowest-Landau-level electron systems near 56 and 57, partial pinning refers to weak-disorder-induced mixing of nearby many-body states with different total angular momentum. In the rotating-and-vibrating electron-molecule formulation,
58
with allowed magic angular momenta
59
Weak pinning mixes symmetry-conserving eigenstates,
60
so that the density acquires an interference term and develops molecular-crystallite peaks. For 61, the superposition 62 produces a 63 crystallite, while 64 produces a 65 crystallite. At exact 66, the gap to neighboring states is larger and suppresses pinning; away from exact filling, weak disorder can overcome the reduced gap and stabilize pinned Wigner crystallites (Yannouleas et al., 2011).
A direct experimental realization of a partially pinned Wigner solid was reported in bilayer MoSe67 at 68 K using non-invasive STM imaging. At low hole density, the system forms a triangular Wigner solid fragmented into nanocrystalline domains pinned by charged defects. A Voronoi analysis of 69 holes found 70 hexagonal, 71 pentagonal, and 72 heptagonal cells, with pentagon-heptagon pairs forming defect lines. As the density increases, holes are added in discrete local densification steps, and above
73
the solid begins to melt locally, producing a mixed state of pinned solid domains and liquid bubbles. By
74
the liquid regions form an apparent percolation network, while the average local densities in liquid and solid regions agree within 75 experimental uncertainty. The data are therefore consistent with a disorder-pinned microemulsion rather than simple long-range density inhomogeneity (Xiang et al., 2024).
Taken together, these usages show that partial pinning is best understood not as a unique phase but as a constrained-state concept. The pinned sector may be particles, contact lines, membrane nodes, defects, dislocation segments, or electronic domains; the mobile sector may remain diffusive, plastic, liquid-like, or weakly crystalline. What pinning adds, in every case represented here, is an externally imposed scale—76, 77, 78, 79, 80, or a coexistence window in density or strain—that limits collective organization, reshapes transport and failure, and often replaces system-spanning rearrangements by localized or mixed-state dynamics.