Low-Threshold Rare-Event Searches

• Low-threshold rare-event searches are experiments focused on detecting extremely rare interactions with minimal energy depositions (keV and below) in neutrino and dark matter physics.
• They utilize advanced detector technologies such as scintillating bolometers, cryogenic calorimeters, and dual-phase Xe-TPCs to achieve exceptional sensitivity and discrimination.
• Innovative background suppression techniques and sophisticated signal processing, supported by materials science advances, enable exploration of parameter spaces beyond conventional methods.

A low-threshold rare-event search is the endeavor—primarily in neutrino and dark matter physics—to detect interactions with exceptionally low probability and correspondingly small energy deposition in a target. These searches rely on specialized detectors with optimized sensitivity at, or below, the keV scale. Achieving both a low energy threshold and a background rate approaching the physical irreducible limit is essential for maximizing discovery potential, ruling out or confirming theoretical models, and exploring parameter space inaccessible to conventional detection techniques.

1. Principles and Motivations of Low-Threshold Searches

Rare-event searches are motivated by the quest to detect processes with expected rates as low as a few counts per tonne-year, such as the scattering of weakly interacting massive particles (WIMPs), the detection of coherent neutrino-nucleus scattering (CEνNS), and the search for neutrinoless double-beta decay. The requirement to detect faint energy depositions from these interactions drives the energy threshold of detectors as low as technologically possible.

Lowering the energy threshold allows access to signals with softer recoil spectra, critical for probing light dark matter candidates or new neutrino phenomena. For example, in direct WIMP detection—such as the DAMA modulation search—recoils from light WIMPs may fall just below previously attainable thresholds (Kelso et al., 2013). In neutrino physics, detectable recoil energies for CEνNS are also constrained to the keV and sub-keV regimes.

The detection rate, signal-to-noise ratio, and statistical inference in these studies are all highly sensitive to the effective energy threshold, making threshold optimization a central concern of both detector hardware and analysis methodology.

2. Detector Technologies and Threshold Optimization

A multitude of detector technologies have been advanced to lower energy thresholds:

• Scintillating Bolometers: CaWO₄ crystals, cooled to cryogenic temperatures, display enhanced light yield and unique long decay components below 40 K, which allow for lower detection thresholds and improved discrimination between α and γ events (Sivers et al., 2015).
• Gram-Scale Cryogenic Calorimeters: Reducing detector absorber size lowers heat capacity and the thermal conductance–volume scaling, thus decreasing energy threshold, as quantified by the scaling law $E_{th} = (\mathrm{const}.) \cdot M^{2/3}$, demonstrated for a 0.5 g Al₂O₃ calorimeter achieving a 19.7 eV threshold (Strauss et al., 2017).
• Dual-Phase Xenon Time Projection Chambers (Xe-TPCs): Large, multi-tonne Xe-TPCs routinely reach electronic recoil thresholds near 1 keV. These exploit simultaneous measurement of primary scintillation (S1) and delayed electroluminescence (S2), with threshold and calibration formula $E_0 = (S_1/g_1 + S_2/g_2) \cdot W$, where $g_1, g_2$ are gain factors and $W$ is the work function (Baudis, 2023).
• Cryogenic Pure CsI Crystals: These exhibit high light yields (≈29 PE/keVₑₑ at 95 K) and uniform response, directly lowering energy threshold and enabling large-scale rare-event searches (Su et al., 22 Sep 2025).
• Phonon-Mediated Hybrid and Voltage-Assisted Detectors: Innovative geometries and operation modes using Neganov-Trofimov-Luke (NTL) amplification achieve sub-10 eV noise (RMS) and unambiguous electron/nuclear recoil discrimination for threshold values as low as 500 eVₑₑ (Novati et al., 2019, Maludze et al., 31 Mar 2024).

Optimization of the energy threshold is performed through both hardware means (e.g., low-noise front-end electronics, improved sensor quantum efficiency, and advanced TES/SQUID electronics) and data processing techniques (matched/optimal filters, event-by-event or trigger-window noise modeling). The OT (optimal trigger) approach, for instance, achieves $\sim$10 keV thresholds in tonne-scale bolometric arrays by filtering the data stream in the frequency domain and adaptively defining triggers in terms of the baseline-noise RMS (Collaboration et al., 2017).

3. Background Suppression, Material Selection, and Assay

Background suppression is a cornerstone of any rare-event search:

• Site Selection: Operation deep underground—typically in facilities with overburdens of >1000 m.w.e.—dramatically reduces the cosmic-ray muon flux and associated secondary neutron backgrounds (Cebrian, 26 Mar 2024).
• Material Radiopurity: Construction materials are rigorously screened for radioactivity using $\gamma$-spectroscopy (HPGe), mass spectrometry (ICP-MS, GDMS), and neutron activation analysis. For instance, the LZ experiment uses radiopure titanium with activities as low as $^{238}$U$_e < 1.6$ mBq/kg, $^{232}$Th$_e = 0.28 \pm 0.03$ mBq/kg (Akerib et al., 2017). Electroformed copper and copper-chromium(-titanium) alloys are synthesized to maximize mechanical strength while maintaining $\lesssim$ mBq/kg backgrounds (Spathara, 29 Jun 2025, Spathara et al., 1 Jul 2025).
• Low-Background Mass Spectrometry: U/Th content in candidate materials is measured to levels below $\sim$10 ppt via spike-recovery-corrected ICP-MS. The limit of detection (LOD) is determined by the formula $\mathrm{LOD} \approx 3 \sigma / D$ after blank subtraction and dilution (Dobson et al., 2017).
• Suppression of Surface and Radiogenic Backgrounds: Active veto systems, fiducial cuts, and combined measurements of disparate signals (phonon and ionization, light and charge) help reject events from radon progeny, surface interactions, or instrument-induced backgrounds (Cebrian, 26 Mar 2024).
• Mitigation of Quartz Fluorescence: UV-induced fluorescence of quartz photosensor windows can create power-law delayed photon noise ($d_p(t) = \alpha \bar{a} t^k$ with $k \sim -1.3$), dominating accidental coincidence backgrounds below $\sim$10 GeV in liquid xenon detectors. Material alternatives such as windowless SiPMs or ultra-pure quartz are being explored to alleviate this bottleneck (Sorensen et al., 12 May 2025).

4. Data Analysis, Threshold Definition, and Discrimination Techniques

Sophisticated signal processing and event selection pipelines are required to exploit low thresholds:

• Matched and Optimal Filtering: Waveforms are filtered to maximize signal-to-noise, with thresholds set not at fixed $n\sigma$ multiples but through explicit modeling of the noise trigger rate (NTR) as a function of acceptance. The probability distribution $P_d(x_\text{max})$ for the noise maximum in a window of $d$ samples allows calculation of $NTR(x_\text{th})$ for any threshold $x_\text{th}$ (Mancuso et al., 2017).
• Pulse-Shape and Event Topology Discrimination: Timing, pulse profile, and signal ratios (e.g., $S2/S1$ or NTL-amplified phonon ratios) are employed to distinguish nuclear recoils (signal) from electron recoils (background). In Majorana PPC detectors, slow-pulse discrimination leverages exponentially modified Gaussian fits to waveform shapes, with training sets from low-energy Compton events used for cut-efficiency calibration (Collaboration et al., 2019).
• Fiducialization and 3D Event Localization: In TPCs and cryogenic crystals, event localization enables exclusion of surface interactions and external backgrounds by geometric cuts; for a sphere or cylinder, events within $r < r_{max}$ and $z_{min} < z < z_{max}$ can be selected (Cebrian, 26 Mar 2024).
• Threshold Determination in the Presence of Excess: In detectors with observed low-energy excesses, such as diamond-based phonon detectors, the spectrum can show features from the abrupt onset of nuclear recoil–induced crystal defect formation. The fitting function $f(x) = A e^{-\alpha x} + Bx^{\beta} + C$ models such components, with the defect-induced peak acting as a marker for true nuclear recoils (Heikinheimo et al., 2021).

5. Impact of Materials Science, Simulation, and Detector Design

Low-threshold rare-event searches benefit greatly from advances in materials science and predictive simulation:

• Alloy Development: High-strength, radiopure copper-chromium and copper-chromium-titanium alloys combine the radiopurity of EFCu with significantly improved hardness/yield strength (up to 429 MPa for Cu–0.5Cr) (Spathara, 29 Jun 2025, Spathara et al., 1 Jul 2025). The mechanical design constraints for pressure vessels and cryostats follow $\sigma = (p r) / (2 t)$, linking alloy development directly to detector scalability.
• Process Modeling: CALPHAD-based modeling and DICTRA simulations of solution heat treatment and TC-PRISMA precipitation hardening allow for predictive process optimization. Fick’s law, $$\partial C/\partial t = \nabla \cdot (D(T) \nabla C)$$, is used to model element diffusion through layered electroformed structures.
• Optical and Geant4 Simulations: Detector uniformity, photon transport, and optimization of signal collection geometries are guided by Geant4-based optical simulations, with formulas for light yield, energy resolution, and photoelectron production directly linked to the measured and simulated parameters (Su et al., 22 Sep 2025).

6. Experimental Results and Milestones

The impact of these developments is evident across a range of experimental results:

Detector/Material	Achievable Threshold / Performance	Key Feature
DAMA/LIBRA (NaI(Tl))	$\sim$1 keV$_{ee}$ (after PMT upgrade)	Extended modulation sensitivity, WIMP mass testing
CaWO₄ Bolometers	$<$1 keV, with ms-scale decay component at $<40$K	Enhanced $\alpha$/$\gamma$ discrimination
Gram-scale cryo-calorimeter (Al₂O₃)	$19.7\,$eV	Scaling law $E_{th} \sim M^{2/3}$
Majorana Demonstrator (HPGe)	$<1$ keV / $5$ keV analysis threshold	High-resolution, PSA with low backgrounds
Cryogenic CsI	$18\,$eV baseline resolution, $\simeq$29 PE/keV$_{ee}$	Uniform light yield, large mass
Sapphire (Al₂O₃)	$18$ eV baseline per channel	Quenching-free phonon detection
LZ Xe-TPC	$\sim 1$ keV with $0.16 \pm 0.03$ counts background	Radiopure Ti, thorough MC background estimation

This evidence underscores how decreased thresholds—supported by advances in materials, assay methods, analysis algorithms, and background control—sharply expand the parameter space accessible to rare-event searches.

7. Challenges, Limitations, and Future Developments

Despite major milestones, several persistent challenges remain:

• Backgrounds Limiting Sensitivity: Instrumental backgrounds, notably quartz fluorescence (power-law photon tails), Cherenkov light from non-signal sources, and radiogenic emissions, can dominate at low thresholds and must be continually suppressed and understood (Sorensen et al., 12 May 2025, Du et al., 2020).
• Material Processing Trade-offs: Increasing mechanical strength can conflict with radiopurity. Alloying elements beyond controlled limits (e.g., Ti in CuCrTi at $>0.032$ wt%) risk phase instability or diffusion barriers, potentially complicating both manufacturing and radioassay (Spathara et al., 1 Jul 2025).
• Analysis Systematics: As thresholds approach $\mathcal{O}($eV$)$, detector response non-linearities, noise correlations, and the accurate modeling of nuclear and electron recoil yields become increasingly nontrivial, demanding continual innovation in calibration and pulse-processing (Mancuso et al., 2017, Collaboration et al., 2017).

Future directions include development of even larger, lower-background detector masses (multi-tonne TPCs, modular low-noise arrays), integration of novel sensor technologies (windowless SiPMs, high surface area cryogenic sensors), and advanced background modeling incorporating MC simulations and data-driven noise modeling. Scaling up low-threshold designs, in both mass and exposure, is anticipated to yield decisive inputs on the nature of dark matter, physics beyond the Standard Model, and potentially the detection of astrophysical neutrinos at unprecedented sensitivity.

---

Low-threshold rare-event searches represent an intersection of condensed matter physics, nuclear engineering, materials science, and signal processing, wherein the continual reduction of threshold and background rates is directly coupled to both detector mass scalability and the careful engineering of experiment-specific solutions—ranging from alloy composition to data selection pipelines. This synergistic progress is essential to advancing the frontiers of rare-event discovery.