Papers
Topics
Authors
Recent
Search
2000 character limit reached

Infinite-Order Filtered Stabilizer Renyi Entropy

Updated 5 July 2026
  • The topic defines infinite-order filtered stabilizer Renyi entropy as a measure that isolates the largest nonidentity Pauli expectation to quantify magic.
  • Different filtering prescriptions—including omitting the identity, state preprocessing, or subtracting local contributions—yield nontrivial yet variant entropy constructions.
  • Operational strategies like purity encoding and swap tests enable estimation, while the infinite-order limit highlights dominant contributions and raises open research challenges.

Infinite-order filtered stabilizer Rényi entropy is the α→∞\alpha\to\infty limit of a stabilizer Rényi-entropy construction after a filtering prescription has been imposed on the Pauli-overlap data or on the state itself. In the stabilizer Rényi framework, an nn-qubit pure state ∣ψ⟩\lvert\psi\rangle is assigned a probability distribution built from squared Pauli expectation values, and the corresponding Rényi entropies quantify nonstabilizerness, or magic. The infinite-order limit isolates the largest weight in that distribution. Across the recent literature, however, “filtered” is not a single standardized operation: it may mean excluding the identity Pauli, minimizing over stabilizer-preserving preprocessing, or subtracting local short-range contributions in a mixed-state setting. As a result, infinite-order filtered stabilizer Rényi entropy is best understood as a family of closely related, but not identical, constructions rather than a unique invariant (Leone et al., 2021, Stratton, 3 Jul 2025).

1. Stabilizer Rényi entropy and the competing meanings of filtering

For an nn-qubit Hilbert space of dimension d=2nd=2^n, with Pauli strings Pn={Pj}j=0d2−1\mathcal P_n=\{P_j\}_{j=0}^{d^2-1}, the characteristic distribution of a pure state ∣ψ⟩\lvert\psi\rangle is

ΞP(∣ψ⟩)=d−1⟨ψ∣P∣ψ⟩2,\Xi_P(\lvert\psi\rangle)=d^{-1}\langle\psi|P|\psi\rangle^2,

which satisfies ∑P∈PnΞP=1\sum_{P\in\mathcal P_n}\Xi_P=1. The stabilizer Rényi entropy used as a magic measure is

Mα(∣ψ⟩)=(1−α)−1ln⁡(1d∑j=0d2−1⟨ψ∣Pj∣ψ⟩2α),M_{\alpha}(\ket{\psi})=(1-\alpha)^{-1}\ln\bigg(\frac{1}{d}\sum_{j=0}^{d^2-1}\bra{\psi}P_j\ket{\psi}^{2\alpha}\bigg),

or equivalently the Rényi entropy of the distribution {ΞP}\{\Xi_P\} shifted by −ln⁡d-\ln d. The standard properties stated in the literature are faithfulness, Clifford invariance, and additivity, with monotonicity under allowed operations established for α≥2\alpha\ge 2 in the formulation used for the purity-encoding algorithm (Stratton, 3 Jul 2025).

The phrase “filtered stabilizer Rényi entropy” appears in several distinct senses. One construction restricts attention to a subset F⊆PnF\subseteq\mathcal P_n of Pauli strings and renormalizes the surviving probabilities, for example by removing the identity operator. In that case,

pP(F)(∣ψ⟩)=ΞP(∣ψ⟩)ZF(∣ψ⟩),ZF(∣ψ⟩)=∑Q∈FΞQ(∣ψ⟩),p_P^{(F)}(\lvert\psi\rangle)=\frac{\Xi_P(\lvert\psi\rangle)}{Z_F(\lvert\psi\rangle)},\qquad Z_F(\lvert\psi\rangle)=\sum_{Q\in F}\Xi_Q(\lvert\psi\rangle),

and one computes a Rényi entropy from the filtered distribution {pP(F)}P∈F\{p_P^{(F)}\}_{P\in F} (Leone et al., 2021).

A second construction defines filtered SRE by preprocessing the state with stabilizer-preserving filters and minimizing:

Mαfilt(∣ψ⟩)=min⁡F∈CMα(F(∣ψ⟩)),M_{\alpha}^{\mathrm{filt}}(\lvert\psi\rangle)=\min_{\mathfrak F\in\mathcal C} M_{\alpha}(\mathfrak F(\lvert\psi\rangle)),

where C\mathcal C may include local Clifford unitaries, Pauli measurements with classical feedforward, and stabilizer-preserving CPTP maps. In this usage, filtering acts on the state rather than on the Pauli-indexed probability distribution (Hoshino et al., 14 Jul 2025).

A third usage arises in mixed-state many-body settings, where long-range SRE is defined by subtracting local subsystem contributions,

L(ρAB)=M~2(ρAB)−M~2(ρA)−M~2(ρB),L(\rho_{AB})=\tilde M_2(\rho_{AB})-\tilde M_2(\rho_A)-\tilde M_2(\rho_B),

so that strictly local magic is filtered out and only the nonstabilizerness linking AA and BB remains. This is a filtered component of magic rather than a filtered pure-state SRE in the Pauli-subset sense (López et al., 2024).

2. Infinite-order limit and the nontrivial role of filtering

For a fixed probability distribution, the Rényi-∞\infty entropy is the min-entropy,

S∞=−ln⁡max⁡ipi.S_\infty=-\ln\max_i p_i.

Applied to the stabilizer distribution, this gives

S∞stab(∣ψ⟩)=−ln⁡(max⁡P∈PnΞP(∣ψ⟩)).S_\infty^{\mathrm{stab}}(\lvert\psi\rangle)=-\ln\Big(\max_{P\in\mathcal P_n}\Xi_P(\lvert\psi\rangle)\Big).

Because the identity Pauli is included in the standard definition, ΞI=d−1\Xi_I=d^{-1} for every pure state, and since ∣⟨ψ∣P∣ψ⟩∣≤1\lvert\langle\psi|P|\psi\rangle\rvert\le 1 for every Pauli PP, one has ΞP≤d−1\Xi_P\le d^{-1} for all PP. Hence

S∞stab(∣ψ⟩)=ln⁡d,M∞(∣ψ⟩)=0S_\infty^{\mathrm{stab}}(\lvert\psi\rangle)=\ln d,\qquad M_\infty(\lvert\psi\rangle)=0

for every pure state. In the unfiltered formulation, the infinite-order magic measure therefore trivializes completely (Leone et al., 2021).

This trivialization is the main reason filtered variants become important at α=∞\alpha=\infty. If one chooses

F=Pn∖{I},F=\mathcal P_n\setminus\{I\},

then

ZF(∣ψ⟩)=1−ΞI(∣ψ⟩)=1−1d=d−1d.Z_F(\lvert\psi\rangle)=1-\Xi_I(\lvert\psi\rangle)=1-\frac1d=\frac{d-1}{d}.

For a stabilizer state ∣ϕ⟩\lvert\phi\rangle, the non-identity elements of its stabilizer group contribute ΞP(∣ϕ⟩)=1/d\Xi_P(\lvert\phi\rangle)=1/d, while all other non-identity Paulis contribute $0$. The filtered distribution is therefore uniform on d−1d-1 outcomes, so

S∞stab,F(∣ϕ⟩)=ln⁡(d−1).S_\infty^{\mathrm{stab},F}(\lvert\phi\rangle)=\ln(d-1).

A filtered infinite-order magic measure can then be shifted to vanish on stabilizer states:

M∞(F)(∣ψ⟩)=S∞stab,F(∣ψ⟩)−ln⁡(d−1).M_\infty^{(F)}(\lvert\psi\rangle)=S_\infty^{\mathrm{stab},F}(\lvert\psi\rangle)-\ln(d-1).

This produces a nontrivial quantity that directly probes the largest non-identity Pauli overlap (Leone et al., 2021).

Resource-theoretic properties depend strongly on the filtering prescription. For Pauli-subset filtering, Clifford invariance survives if the subset FF is invariant under Clifford conjugation; F=Pn∖{I}F=\mathcal P_n\setminus\{I\} has this property. The literature explicitly cautions, however, that additivity generally fails for filtered entropies because the normalization factor ZFZ_F need not factorize under tensor products. By contrast, in the preprocessing/minimization definition, monotonicity under stabilizer protocols is part of the construction for α≥2\alpha\ge 2, and the α→∞\alpha\to\infty limit is interpreted through the survival of universal terms rather than through Pauli-subset renormalization (Hoshino et al., 14 Jul 2025).

From the purity-based formulation,

Mα(∣ψ⟩)=(1−α)−1ln⁡Aα(∣ψ⟩),Aα(∣ψ⟩)=d−1∑j⟨ψ∣Pj∣ψ⟩2α,M_\alpha(\ket{\psi})=(1-\alpha)^{-1}\ln A_\alpha(\ket{\psi}),\qquad A_\alpha(\ket{\psi})=d^{-1}\sum_j\bra\psi P_j\ket\psi^{2\alpha},

one also obtains the inferred pure-state infinite-order expression

S∞(∣ψ⟩)=lim⁡α→∞Mα(∣ψ⟩)=−ln⁡(max⁡j⟨ψ∣Pj∣ψ⟩2),S_{\infty}(\ket{\psi})=\lim_{\alpha\to\infty}M_\alpha(\ket{\psi}) =-\ln\Big(\max_j \bra{\psi}P_j\ket{\psi}^2\Big),

which is the standard Rényi-∞\infty limit for the characteristic distribution. This inference is explicitly identified as such in the purity-encoding work (Stratton, 3 Jul 2025).

3. Estimation through purity encoding

An operational route to finite-order stabilizer Rényi entropies is provided by a mixed-unitary channel acting on α\alpha copies of an unknown pure state:

E(ψ⊗α)=d−2∑j=0d2−1(PjψPj)⊗α.E\big(\psi^{\otimes\alpha}\big)=d^{-2}\sum_{j=0}^{d^2-1}\big(P_j\psi P_j\big)^{\otimes\alpha}.

Its central property is

tr⁡[E(ψ⊗α)2]=d−1Aα(∣ψ⟩),\operatorname{tr}\Big[E\big(\psi^{\otimes\alpha}\big)^2\Big]=d^{-1}A_\alpha(\ket\psi),

so the purity of the engineered state directly yields the moment Aα(∣ψ⟩)A_\alpha(\ket\psi) and therefore Mα(∣ψ⟩)M_\alpha(\ket\psi) after classical post-processing. A coherent implementation uses $2n$ ancilla qubits prepared by H⊗2nH^{\otimes 2n} and a controlled Pauli-string unitary

cUP=∑j=0d2−1∣j⟩ ⁣⟨j∣A⊗Pj⊗α,cU_{\mathcal P}=\sum_{j=0}^{d^2-1}\ket j\!\bra j_A\otimes P_j^{\otimes\alpha},

after which tracing out the ancilla realizes the channel EE. The same channel can also be implemented incoherently by uniformly sampling a Pauli string, applying it to all α\alpha copies, and then forgetting which string was applied (Stratton, 3 Jul 2025).

The paper focuses on purity estimation by the swap test. Two copies of the output state yield the purity to additive error τ\tau using O(τ−2)O(\tau^{-2}) repetitions. Because each output copy consumes α\alpha copies of ∣ψ⟩\lvert\psi\rangle, the total copy complexity is O(ατ−2)O(\alpha\tau^{-2}). To estimate Aα(∣ψ⟩)A_\alpha(\lvert\psi\rangle) to additive error ϵ\epsilon, one needs τ=ϵ/d\tau=\epsilon/d, which gives O(αd2ϵ−2)O(\alpha d^2\epsilon^{-2}) copies, refined in the stated failure-probability form to ⌈αd2ϵ−2δ−1⌉\lceil \alpha d^2\epsilon^{-2}\delta^{-1}\rceil copies. The swap-test realization requires two output states simultaneously, hence 2α2\alpha copies of ∣ψ⟩\lvert\psi\rangle in flight and an at least 2n(α+1)+12n(\alpha+1)+1 qubit device including ancilla. Randomized measurements can estimate the same purity using a single output copy, reducing concurrency to α\alpha copies on an n(α+2)n(\alpha+2)-qubit device (Stratton, 3 Jul 2025).

Relative to alternative algorithms, the purity-encoding protocol is reported to scale worse than quantum-state-tomography estimation of Γα⊗n\Gamma_\alpha^{\otimes n} for odd α\alpha, but better for even α\alpha. It matches the scaling of direct 2α2\alpha-copy estimation of all Pauli terms, and it is outperformed in both copy complexity and concurrency by the algorithm of Phys. Rev. Lett. 132, 240602, which estimates Aα(∣ψ⟩)A_\alpha(\lvert\psi\rangle) with O(αϵ−2)O(\alpha\epsilon^{-2}) copies for odd α\alpha and O(αdϵ−2)O(\alpha d\epsilon^{-2}) for even α\alpha using only two-copy measurements (Stratton, 3 Jul 2025).

For the infinite-order problem, the purity-encoding paper does not define a filtered SRE. It instead suggests, by implication, a practical strategy of estimating MαM_\alpha for increasing integers α>1\alpha>1 and extrapolating α→∞\alpha\to\infty. The paper benchmarks the qubit family

∣ψθ⟩=12(∣0⟩+eiθ∣1⟩),\ket{\psi_\theta}=\frac{1}{\sqrt2}\big(\ket0+e^{i\theta}\ket1\big),

for which

Aα(∣ψθ⟩)=12(1+cos⁡(θ)2α+sin⁡(θ)2α).A_\alpha(\ket{\psi_\theta})=\frac12\big(1+\cos(\theta)^{2\alpha}+\sin(\theta)^{2\alpha}\big).

In simulations of Algorithm 1 for α∈{2,3,5,7}\alpha\in\{2,3,5,7\}, additive error ϵ=0.05\epsilon=0.05, and failure probability δ=0.1\delta=0.1, the measured values match theoretical predictions within the plotted error bars, and “the accuracy of the algorithm appears to have no dependence on α\alpha” over that tested range. No general finite-α\alpha error bound to S∞S_\infty is given (Stratton, 3 Jul 2025).

The same work notes an inferred filtered adaptation: replacing the uniform Pauli mixture by a non-uniform distribution {pj}\{p_j\} over a subset or weighted family of Pauli strings. The resulting purity becomes

tr⁡[EF(ρ⊗α)2]=∑j,kpjpk tr⁡[PjρPjPkρPk]α,\operatorname{tr}\big[E_F(\rho^{\otimes\alpha})^2\big] =\sum_{j,k}p_jp_k\,\operatorname{tr}\big[P_j\rho P_jP_k\rho P_k\big]^\alpha,

which reduces to a weighted sum of ⟨ψ∣Pℓ∣ψ⟩2α\langle\psi|P_\ell|\psi\rangle^{2\alpha} only under suitable symmetry conditions. The paper gives no formal guarantees, normalization, or monotonicity theory for such filtered purity encodings, and treats this as an open question (Stratton, 3 Jul 2025).

4. Universal terms in critical systems: boundaries, defects, and filtered α→∞\alpha\to\infty

In one-dimensional critical spin chains, the stabilizer Rényi entropy admits a boundary-conformal-field-theory and replica formulation in which open boundaries and topological defects contribute universal corrections. For a chain of LL qubits, the global SRE is written as

Mα(ψ)=11−αln⁡ ⁣[∑m⃗(Tr⁡[σm⃗ψ])2α]−(ln⁡2)L,M_\alpha(\psi)=\frac{1}{1-\alpha}\ln\!\Big[\sum_{\vec m}\big(\operatorname{Tr}[\sigma^{\vec m}\psi]\big)^{2\alpha}\Big]-(\ln 2)L,

equivalently as a Bell-basis participation entropy computed from a replica partition function Z2αZ_{2\alpha}. For factorising defects, or open boundaries, the replica free energy has the form

−ln⁡(Z2α/Z2α)=bαL+γαln⁡L+O(1),-\ln(Z_{2\alpha}/Z^{2\alpha})=b_\alpha L+\gamma_\alpha\ln L+O(1),

which implies

Mα(L)=Mαbulk(L)+cb(α)ln⁡L+O(1),cb(α)=γαα−1.M_\alpha(L)=M_\alpha^{\mathrm{bulk}}(L)+c_b(\alpha)\ln L+O(1),\qquad c_b(\alpha)=\frac{\gamma_\alpha}{\alpha-1}.

For topological defects A\mathfrak A,

−ln⁡(Z2α/Z2α)=bαL−ln⁡gαA+o(1),-\ln(Z_{2\alpha}/Z^{2\alpha})=b_\alpha L-\ln g_\alpha^{\mathfrak A}+o(1),

so that

Mα(L;A)=Mαbulk(L)−Cdefect(α;A)+o(1),Cdefect(α;A)=1α−1ln⁡gαA.M_\alpha(L;\mathfrak A)=M_\alpha^{\mathrm{bulk}}(L)-C_{\mathrm{defect}}(\alpha;\mathfrak A)+o(1),\qquad C_{\mathrm{defect}}(\alpha;\mathfrak A)=\frac{1}{\alpha-1}\ln g_\alpha^{\mathfrak A}.

With multiple defects obeying fusion algebra A⊗B=⨁cC\mathfrak A\otimes\mathfrak B=\bigoplus_c \mathfrak C, the universal constant is set by the dominant fusion channel in the ground-state limit (Hoshino et al., 14 Jul 2025).

In this setting, filtered SRE is defined by minimizing over stabilizer-preserving filters. The crucial statement is that the universal BCFT terms are unchanged by such filtering. Finite-depth local Clifford circuits cannot change the replicated central charge or the boundary-condition changing dimensions, so the boundary logarithm is unaffected; likewise, moving or fusing topological defects by Clifford circuits does not alter the universal defect constants. For the infinite-order filtered case, the universal form is stated as

S∞filt(L;defects,boundaries)=S∞bulk(L)+cb(∞)ln⁡L−Cdefect(∞),S_\infty^{\mathrm{filt}}(L;\text{defects,boundaries}) = S_\infty^{\mathrm{bulk}}(L)+c_b(\infty)\ln L-C_{\mathrm{defect}}(\infty),

with

cb(∞)=lim⁡α→∞γαα−1,Cdefect(∞)=lim⁡α→∞ln⁡gαAα.c_b(\infty)=\lim_{\alpha\to\infty}\frac{\gamma_\alpha}{\alpha-1},\qquad C_{\mathrm{defect}}(\infty)=\lim_{\alpha\to\infty}\frac{\ln g_\alpha^{\mathfrak A}}{\alpha}.

For multiple defects,

Cdefect(∞;a⊗b)=max⁡c:Nabc≠0lim⁡α→∞ln⁡gαcα,C_{\mathrm{defect}}(\infty;a\otimes b) = \max_{c:N_{ab}^c\neq 0}\lim_{\alpha\to\infty}\frac{\ln g_\alpha^c}{\alpha},

so the infinite-order limit selects the dominant channel, in direct analogy with min-entropy behavior (Hoshino et al., 14 Jul 2025).

The Ising universality class supplies explicit values. For all nine elementary factorising defects, the paper finds

Mα(L;open)=mαL−14ln⁡L+O(1)M_\alpha(L;\mathrm{open})=m_\alpha L-\frac14\ln L+O(1)

for any α≥2\alpha\ge 2, so cb(∞)=−1/4c_b(\infty)=-1/4. For closed chains, the reported M2M_2 defect constants are c21=ln⁡2c_2^{1}=\ln\sqrt2, c2η=0.755(1)c_2^\eta=0.755(1), and c2D=0.020(3)c_2^{\mathfrak D}=0.020(3). For two duality defects, the fusion rule D⊗D=1⊕η\mathfrak D\otimes\mathfrak D=1\oplus\eta leads the ground state to select the identity channel, and the corresponding SRE constant becomes c2D⊗D=ln⁡2c_2^{\mathfrak D\otimes\mathfrak D}=\ln\sqrt2. The infinite-order filtered interpretation is that these universal constants survive stabilizer-preserving filtering, while the nonuniversal bulk term may change (Hoshino et al., 14 Jul 2025).

5. Long-range filtered magic in the dual-unitary XXZ circuit

A different filtered construction appears in the exactly solvable dual-unitary XXZ Floquet circuit. The system is a chain of NN qubits evolved by a brick-wall circuit with two-qubit gates

Ue,o=exp⁡(−iJe,o σz⊗σz)⋅SWAP,U_{e,o}=\exp(-iJ_{e,o}\,\sigma_z\otimes\sigma_z)\cdot\mathrm{SWAP},

starting from a product of Bell pairs,

∣ψ(0)⟩=∣ϕ+⟩⊗N/2,∣ϕ+⟩=12∑i=01∣i i⟩.\ket{\psi(0)}=\ket{\phi^+}^{\otimes N/2},\qquad \ket{\phi^+}=\frac{1}{\sqrt2}\sum_{i=0}^1\ket{i\,i}.

For pure states, the stabilizer moments are

ζn(∣ψ⟩)=12N∑P∈PN⟨ψ∣P∣ψ⟩2n,Mn(∣ψ⟩)=11−nlog⁡ζn(∣ψ⟩).\zeta_n(\ket\psi)=\frac{1}{2^N}\sum_{P\in\mathcal P_N}\langle\psi|P|\psi\rangle^{2n}, \qquad M_n(\ket\psi)=\frac{1}{1-n}\log\zeta_n(\ket\psi).

For mixed states, the paper uses

M~2(ρ)=−log⁡ ⁣(ζ2(ρ)ζ1(ρ)),ζn(ρ)=12N∑P∈PN(tr⁡(Pρ))2n.\tilde M_2(\rho)=-\log\!\Big(\frac{\zeta_2(\rho)}{\zeta_1(\rho)}\Big), \qquad \zeta_n(\rho)=\frac{1}{2^N}\sum_{P\in\mathcal P_N}\big(\operatorname{tr}(P\rho)\big)^{2n}.

The long-range SRE,

L(ρAB)=M~2(ρAB)−M~2(ρA)−M~2(ρB),L(\rho_{AB})=\tilde M_2(\rho_{AB})-\tilde M_2(\rho_A)-\tilde M_2(\rho_B),

is interpreted as the amount of magic that cannot be removed by short-depth local quantum circuits (López et al., 2024).

The paper derives exact formulas by ZX-calculus. After a half time step, the thermodynamic-limit SRE density is

mn(∣ψ(J,0,12)⟩)=12(1−n)log⁡ ⁣(1+cos⁡2n(2J)+sin⁡2n(2J)2).m_n\big(\ket{\psi(J,0,\tfrac12)}\big) = \frac{1}{2(1-n)} \log\!\bigg(\frac{1+\cos^{2n}(2J)+\sin^{2n}(2J)}{2}\bigg).

As n→∞n\to\infty, both trigonometric terms vanish for generic JJ, and the limit gives

m∞=0.m_\infty=0.

At the Clifford points J=0J=0 and J=π/4J=\pi/4, the limit is also $0$ (López et al., 2024).

For the specific partition

B0:NA=NB=2T,d=2(T−1),N=8T−4,B_0:\qquad N_A=N_B=2T,\quad d=2(T-1),\quad N=8T-4,

the reduced states ρA\rho_A and ρB\rho_B are maximally mixed, so the filtering subtraction is trivial and

LB0(Jo,Je,T)=M~2(ρAB).L_{B_0}(J_o,J_e,T)=\tilde M_2(\rho_{AB}).

The exact moments are

ζn(ρAB)=124T−2(1+2(fn(Jo)fn(Je))T+gn(Jo,Je)(fn(Jo)fn(Je))2T−4),\zeta_n(\rho_{AB}) = \frac{1}{ 2^{4T-2}\Big(1+2\big(f_n(J_o)f_n(J_e)\big)^T +g_n(J_o,J_e)\big(f_n(J_o)f_n(J_e)\big)^{2T-4}\Big)},

with

fn(J)=cos⁡2n(2J)+sin⁡2n(2J),f_n(J)=\cos^{2n}(2J)+\sin^{2n}(2J),

and an explicit closed form for gn(Jo,Je)g_n(J_o,J_e) given in the paper. At finite order n=2n=2, the long-range SRE is nonzero and, for large TT, saturates around 2log⁡22\log 2 for generic parameters, while vanishing at the Clifford points (López et al., 2024).

The infinite-order statement for this mixed-state construction is more delicate because the paper defines long-range SRE only at n=2n=2. It does, however, provide ζn(ρAB)\zeta_n(\rho_{AB}) for all integer nn. A natural extension is

M~n(ρ)=11−nlog⁡ ⁣(ζn(ρ)ζ1(ρ)),Ln(ρAB)=M~n(ρAB)−M~n(ρA)−M~n(ρB),\tilde M_n(\rho)=\frac{1}{1-n}\log\!\Big(\frac{\zeta_n(\rho)}{\zeta_1(\rho)}\Big), \qquad L_n(\rho_{AB})=\tilde M_n(\rho_{AB})-\tilde M_n(\rho_A)-\tilde M_n(\rho_B),

but this extension is explicitly not adopted in the paper. Under that inferred extension, one finds for generic Jo,JeJ_o,J_e that fn(Je,o)→0f_n(J_{e,o})\to 0 and gn(Jo,Je)→0g_n(J_o,J_e)\to 0 as n→∞n\to\infty, so

lim⁡n→∞ζn(ρAB)=2−(4T−2),\lim_{n\to\infty}\zeta_n(\rho_{AB})=2^{-(4T-2)},

which implies M~∞(ρAB)=0\tilde M_\infty(\rho_{AB})=0 and therefore L∞=0L_\infty=0 in partition B0B_0. The paper presents this as an extrapolative conclusion rather than an explicit theorem. The significance is that finite-order long-range filtered magic can be nonzero and even saturating, while the infinite-order extension suppresses it entirely in this solvable setting (López et al., 2024).

6. Conceptual status, misconceptions, and open problems

A recurrent misconception is that infinite-order filtered stabilizer Rényi entropy denotes a single canonical quantity. The literature does not support that reading. One line of work shows that the unfiltered α→∞\alpha\to\infty stabilizer Rényi entropy is trivial on all pure states because the identity Pauli fixes the largest probability weight. Another introduces a nontrivial infinite-order quantity by filtering out the identity or another Clifford-invariant subset. A third studies filtering as minimization over stabilizer-preserving operations and emphasizes the preservation of universal BCFT data under α→∞\alpha\to\infty. A fourth isolates a filtered long-range component in mixed states by subtracting local contributions, and in an exactly solvable partition its inferred infinite-order extension vanishes. This suggests that “infinite-order filtered SRE” is a family resemblance term rather than a unique invariant (Leone et al., 2021, Hoshino et al., 14 Jul 2025, López et al., 2024).

Several points are firmly established. The pure-state infinite-order limit of the standard, identity-inclusive SRE gives M∞≡0M_\infty\equiv 0. Excluding the identity yields a nontrivial filtered min-entropy that measures the inverse of the largest non-identity Pauli overlap. In critical Ising chains, the infinite-order filtered SRE preserves the universal −(1/4)ln⁡L-(1/4)\ln L boundary term and the defect constants determined by gg-factors and dominant fusion channels. In the dual-unitary XXZ circuit, finite-order long-range filtered magic is exactly solvable and nonzero, yet the natural α→∞\alpha\to\infty extension collapses to zero in partition B0B_0. The purity-encoding algorithm gives an explicit operational procedure for estimating MαM_\alpha at finite integer α>1\alpha>1 and therefore suggests, but does not rigorously provide, an estimation strategy for approaching the infinite-order regime (Stratton, 3 Jul 2025).

The open problems are correspondingly structural rather than merely technical. The purity-encoding work explicitly leaves open how to choose a non-uniform Pauli filter so that purity remains a simple linear functional of a filtered stabilizer moment, what resource-theoretic meaning and monotonicity such a filtered SRE would have, and how to control the bias introduced by filtering in the α→∞\alpha\to\infty limit. The same paper does not provide a detailed noise analysis or explicit finite-α\alpha bounds to S∞S_\infty. The filtered Pauli-subset construction does not inherit additivity in general, and the long-range construction is rigorously defined only for n=2n=2 in the exactly solvable circuit setting. These limitations are not incidental: they indicate that the infinite-order limit is exceptionally sensitive to the exact choice of filtration, because it depends only on the single dominant contribution that survives the filter (Leone et al., 2021, Stratton, 3 Jul 2025, López et al., 2024).

Taken together, the current literature supports a precise but plural picture. Infinite-order filtered stabilizer Rényi entropy can mean a nonidentity-filtered min-entropy of the Pauli-overlap distribution, a stabilizer-protocol-minimized α→∞\alpha\to\infty entropy retaining universal boundary and defect signatures, or an inferred infinite-order limit of a long-range filtered mixed-state construction. What unifies these variants is that α→∞\alpha\to\infty always amplifies the dominant surviving contribution after filtering. What differentiates them is the object being filtered: Pauli strings, states under free operations, or local subsystem contributions.

Topic to Video (Beta)

No one has generated a video about this topic yet.

Whiteboard

No one has generated a whiteboard explanation for this topic yet.

Follow Topic

Get notified by email when new papers are published related to Infinite-Order Filtered Stabilizer Rényi Entropy.