Subversion via Focal Points: Investigating Collusion in LLM Monitoring (2507.03010v1)

Abstract: We evaluate LLMs' ability to subvert monitoring protocols via collusion. More specifically, we have two instances of a model design prompts for a policy (P) and a monitor (M) in a programming task setting. The models collaboratively aim for M to classify all backdoored programs in an auditing dataset as harmful, but nevertheless classify a backdoored program produced by P as harmless. The models are isolated from each other, requiring them to independently arrive at compatible subversion strategies. We find that while Claude 3.7 Sonnet has low success rate due to poor convergence, it sometimes successfully colludes on non-obvious signals.