On idealized models of turbulent condensation in clouds (2501.08968v1)

Abstract: Various microphysical models attempt to explain the occurrence of broad droplet size distributions (DSD) in clouds through approximate representations of the stochastic droplet growth by condensation in a turbulent environment. This work analyzes specific idealized models, where the variability of droplet growth conditions arises primarily from variability in the turbulent vertical velocity of the air carrying these droplets. Examples are the stochastic eddy hopping model operating in adiabatic parcels and certain types of DNS-like models. We show that such models produce droplet size statistics that are spatially inhomogeneous along the vertical direction, causing the predicted DSD to depend on the DSD spatial sampling scale $\Delta$. In these models, $\Delta$ is implicitly related to the spatial extent of the droplets turbulent diffusion (approximated by Brownian-like excursions) and thus grows like $t^{1/2}$. This leads to spurious continuous DSD broadening, as the growth in time (also like $t^{1/2}$) of the standard deviation of droplet squared radius arises essentially from the growth of the sampling scale $\Delta$. Also, the DSDs predicted by the models discussed here are not necessarily locally broad (in the sense that large and small droplets might not be well-mixed in sufficiently small volumes) and thus do not necessarily indicate enhanced probabilities of gravity-induced droplet coagulation. In the effort to build a firm physical basis for subgrid parametrizations, this study presents a framework to explain the merits and limitations of idealized models, indicating how to assess and use them wisely as a subgrid representation of turbulent condensation in large-eddy simulations of clouds.