Video-Bench: A Comprehensive Benchmark and Toolkit for Evaluating Video-based Large Language Models (2311.16103v2)

Abstract: Video-based LLMs (Video-LLMs) have been recently introduced, targeting both fundamental improvements in perception and comprehension, and a diverse range of user inquiries. In pursuit of the ultimate goal of achieving artificial general intelligence, a truly intelligent Video-LLM model should not only see and understand the surroundings, but also possess human-level commonsense, and make well-informed decisions for the users. To guide the development of such a model, the establishment of a robust and comprehensive evaluation system becomes crucial. To this end, this paper proposes \textit{Video-Bench}, a new comprehensive benchmark along with a toolkit specifically designed for evaluating Video-LLMs. The benchmark comprises 10 meticulously crafted tasks, evaluating the capabilities of Video-LLMs across three distinct levels: Video-exclusive Understanding, Prior Knowledge-based Question-Answering, and Comprehension and Decision-making. In addition, we introduce an automatic toolkit tailored to process model outputs for various tasks, facilitating the calculation of metrics and generating convenient final scores. We evaluate 8 representative Video-LLMs using \textit{Video-Bench}. The findings reveal that current Video-LLMs still fall considerably short of achieving human-like comprehension and analysis of real-world videos, offering valuable insights for future research directions. The benchmark and toolkit are available at: \url{https://github.com/PKU-YuanGroup/Video-Bench}.

Evaluating Video-based LLMs with Video-Bench

The research paper entitled "Video-Bench: A Comprehensive Benchmark and Toolkit for Evaluating Video-based LLMs" introduces an innovative benchmark suite for assessing Video-LLMs (Video-LLMs). The paper underscores the need for a structured evaluation metric that can accurately measure the capabilities of Video-LLMs across various dimensions, thus guiding their development towards achieving a more comprehensive form of artificial general intelligence (AGI) in video understanding.

Overview of Video-Bench

Video-Bench is designed to assess three critical competencies of Video-LLMs:

1. Video-exclusive Understanding: This competency evaluates a model's ability to interpret and summarize video content without relying on external knowledge. Tasks include traditional video question answering (QA) datasets and more complex tasks such as video summarization, anomaly detection, and crowd counting.
2. Prior Knowledge-based Question-Answering: This level examines whether a model can answer questions requiring external knowledge beyond what is immediately observable in the video. The paper employs TV series, music videos, and sports events (like the NBA) to test this capability.
3. Comprehension and Decision-making: Here, the focus is on understanding 3D scenes and making decisions, tasks that require integrating comprehension and prediction, particularly relevant in domains such as autonomous driving.

Evaluation and Findings

The paper evaluates eight prominent Video-LLMs using Video-Bench, revealing several insights:

• Video-LLMs show reasonable performance in basic comprehension tasks but fall short in tasks requiring detailed understanding and temporal awareness.
• Most models struggle with tasks that depend heavily on prior domain knowledge, highlighting a significant gap in integrating stored knowledge with perceptual inputs.
• In complex decision-making tasks, models show limited proficiency, suggesting that current architectures and training methodologies might be insufficient for real-world applications that require nuanced understanding and predictive capabilities.

The paper provides a detailed breakdown of the performance across datasets, emphasizing discrepancies across different task types. Video-LLMs like Video-ChatGPT and PandaGPT, which utilize extensive video instruction data, perform relatively better, indicating the importance of large-scale diverse data exposure during training.

Implications and Future Directions

The findings from Video-Bench suggest several directions for future research and development:

• Temporal Sensitivity and Sequencing: Improvement in temporal awareness is crucial for applications needing sequence-sensitive comprehension, such as summarization or anomaly detection.
• Integrating Domain-specific Knowledge: Pre-training on diverse multimedia content and fine-tuning on domain-specific data could enhance a model's ability to incorporate external knowledge effectively.
• Advanced Memory and Attention Mechanisms: Developing architectures that can handle long sequences effectively and maintain context over extended video content could be pivotal in improving comprehension and decision-making.

Conclusion

Video-Bench provides a comprehensive framework to challenge and evaluate the capabilities of Video-LLMs. The paper contributes significantly to the landscape of video-based AI by outlining the current limitations and offering a detailed, systematic approach to measuring progress towards AGI in video understanding. This benchmark not only aids in assessing current models but also serves as a guidepost for future advancements in the field of video comprehension by AI.