Dice Question Streamline Icon: https://streamlinehq.com

Incomplete understanding of key kilonova microphysics (opacity, heating, thermalization)

Characterize the wavelength-dependent ejecta opacities, the radioactive nuclear heating rates, and the thermalization efficiencies governing kilonova emission in order to reduce modeling uncertainties and enable reliable inference of ejecta masses and velocities from observed light curves.

Information Square Streamline Icon: https://streamlinehq.com

Background

The authors emphasize that some fundamental ingredients of kilonova modeling are not yet well constrained, which directly affects parameter inference. In particular, degeneracies among ejecta mass, velocity, and opacity, combined with time- and temperature-dependent opacity variations, introduce systematic uncertainties.

They note that even state-of-the-art simulations still lack precise understanding of these microphysical quantities, which limits confident mapping from observational data to physical ejecta properties.

References

In addition, several pieces of kilonova physics are still not well understood even in state-of-the-art simulations, such as the uncertainty in wavelength-dependent opacities, nuclear heating rate, and thermalization efficiencies (Barnes et al. 2021; Bulla 2023; Brethauer et al. 2024; Sarin & Rosswog 2024).

Uniform Modeling of Observed Kilonovae: Implications for Diversity and the Progenitors of Merger-Driven Long Gamma-Ray Bursts (2409.02158 - Rastinejad et al., 3 Sep 2024) in Section 4.5 (Caveats to Kilonova Model)