Katalan-function $k$-Schur positivity for iterated removable-root reduction

Determine whether, for every root ideal $\Psi\subseteq\Delta^+_\ell$, every $k$-bounded partition $\lambda\in\mathrm{Par}^k_\ell$ satisfying $\operatorname{maxband}(\Psi,\lambda)\le k$, and every integer $a\ge0$, the Katalan function $K(\Psi;\mathrm{RC}^a(\Psi);\lambda)$ is a nonnegative integer linear combination of $k$-Schur functions.

Background

The paper considers a proposed extension of the kk-Schur positivity theorem for KK-kk-Schur functions. For a root ideal Ψ\Psi, the operator RC\mathrm{RC} removes all removable roots, and RCa(Ψ)\mathrm{RC}^a(\Psi) denotes its aa-fold iteration. The conjecture asserts that the associated Katalan function remains kk-Schur positive whenever the root ideal and partition satisfy the stated maxband condition.

The paper explains that taking Ψ=Δk(λ)\Psi=\Delta^k(\lambda) and a=1a=1 specializes this proposed extension to the already established positivity theorem for KK-kk-Schur functions. However, the paper then constructs an explicit example with ℓ=8\ell=8, λ=(18)\lambda=(1^8), k=3k=3, and a=1a=1 for which the Katalan-function expansion has negative kk-Schur coefficients. Thus, the stated conjecture is explicitly refuted in the paper rather than left unresolved.

References

As mentioned in Remark \ref{rek-0-k}, Blasiak, Morse and Seelinger Conjecture 2.19 proposed an extension of Theorem \ref{thm:LSS}. In this section, we shall construct a counterexample to this conjectured extension.

— $K$-$k$-Schur functions are $k$-Schur positive  (2610.01708 - Bai et al., 1 Oct 2026) in Section 4, Conjecture 4.1 (labeled Conjecture 2.19(2.17) from BMS)