Dice Question Streamline Icon: https://streamlinehq.com

Recursion in Hilbert Space Semantics

Determine whether the category Hilb of Hilbert spaces and bounded linear maps supports a denotational interpretation of recursion, i.e., whether recursive definitions can be modeled categorically in Hilb (for example via suitable fixed-point or domain-theoretic structure).

Information Square Streamline Icon: https://streamlinehq.com

Background

The paper contrasts inverse categories, which can model recursion via enrichment in directed complete partial orders, with categories based on Hilbert spaces, which lack the required enrichment (citing Heunen’s result). While inductive types can be interpreted in Hilb (via Barr’s theorem), the authors state that it remains unknown whether recursion itself can be interpreted in Hilbert spaces.

To address recursion for non-cartesian settings, the paper develops a guarded recursion framework using dagger categories rather than resolving the question for Hilbert spaces directly.

References

Even if inductive types can be interpreted in Hilbert spacesTheorem 3.2, it is an open question whether they can interpret recursion. We choose not to tackle this open question in this paper, and we instead suggest a different path, through guarded recursion.

Non-Cartesian Guarded Recursion with Daggers (2409.14591 - Lemonnier, 22 Sep 2024) in Section 1, Introduction