Determine whether the potential target class is a permanent cycle

Determine whether the class represented by the element u = acybz B^{p-3} is a permanent cycle in the Adams–Novikov spectral sequence converging to the homotopy groups of V(3), or whether it supports a d_{q+1}-differential.

Background

In the Adams–Novikov spectral sequence converging to \pi_* V(3), the element v_4 can potentially support a differential whose target is the class u = acybz B{p-3}. Theorem \ref{t:h14injective} proves that the differential d_{q+1}(v_4) vanishes by analyzing the relation involving h_{1,4}v_4 and showing that either u is eliminated earlier in the May spectral sequence or h_{1,4}u survives to produce a contradiction.

The subsequent remark clarifies that u itself survives the May spectral sequence, but the argument does not determine its behavior in the Adams–Novikov spectral sequence. Thus, u may still support a d_{q+1}-differential, and its permanence remains unresolved.

References

The above class $u$ survives the MSS. We do not know if it is a permanent cycle in the ANSS, as it could potentially support a $d_{q+1}$-differential.

— The Smith-Toda complex V(4) exists for p >= 11  (2610.23215 - Angeltveit, 16 Oct 2026) in Remark immediately following the proof of Theorem \ref{t:h14injective}, Section 2 (Some May spectral sequence calculations)