Critical-collapse behavior beyond spherical symmetry
Clarify the behavior of critical gravitational collapse in axisymmetry and beyond spherical symmetry, including whether the universality properties established for spherically symmetric massless-scalar collapse persist or are modified.
References
Subsequent numerical and semi-analytic studies have confirmed and extended this universality to other matter types in spherical symmetry, but the picture in axisymmetry and beyond remains unclear (see for a review).
The most important extension is to construct a smooth one-loop stress tensor on the Choptuik spacetime . This would determine whether the quantum growth has exponent $\omega_q=2$ and whether regularity throughout the self-similar interior gives rise to echo-periodic structure.
Extending the semiclassical evolution into an asymptotically flat exterior following the approach in would determine whether an event horizon forms and how the local onset radius $r_h$ is related to the final black hole mass. Following the full evolution would also establish whether the finite-radius onset produces a final mass gap and whether the local Type I-like behavior extends to a genuine Type I transition, with a metastable critical solution and an associated lifetime scaling law.