Sufficiency of the Clebsch transformation for hydrodynamic flows

Determine whether the Clebsch transformation is sufficient to capture all possible solutions of the hydrodynamic equations of motion.

Background

The paper discusses variational formulations of fluid mechanics based on representing the fluid velocity through potential fields. A scalar velocity potential cannot describe flows with nonzero vorticity, so the Clebsch transformation introduces two additional scalar parameters to represent more complex velocity configurations.

The authors note that, unlike the Helmholtz decomposition, the Clebsch transformation has not been shown to provide a general representation of vector fields. Consequently, it remains unresolved whether this transformation can represent every possible solution of the hydrodynamic equations of motion. The question is directly relevant to assessing the completeness of Clebsch-based variational formulations of fluid dynamics.

References

Therefore the question remains open whether the Clebsch transformation is sufficient to capture all possible solutions of the hydrodynamic equations of motion.

— From Action Principle to Stochastic Thermodynamics of Elastic and Viscous Active Matter  (2610.21835 - Barletta et al., 15 Oct 2026) in Section 2, “Hydrodynamic action,” paragraph preceding Section 2.1, “Variational formulation of hydrodynamics”