Dice Question Streamline Icon: https://streamlinehq.com

Chronology of the modern reappearance of the ‘sagging horizontals’ myth

Ascertain when, in modern architectural discourse, the claim that straight horizontal elements appear to sag re-emerged and how it became acknowledged, including its transmission through Penrose’s work.

Information Square Streamline Icon: https://streamlinehq.com

Background

The paper traces the ‘sagging horizontals’ explanation to Vitruvius but notes uncertainty about when this idea re-entered modern scholarship.

It highlights Penrose’s influential acceptance of a Vitruvian rationale as a pivotal moment, yet states that the precise timing of the myth’s reappearance remains unclear.

References

It is not clear when this myth reappeared in modern times as it was only acknowledged indirectly by Penrose citing Vitruvius that "If the line of the stylobate were perfectly horizontal, it would appear like the bed of a channel" and concluding that "we need have no further hesitation in accepting the reason given by Vitruvius".

The illusion of illusions: There are no optical corrections in the Parthenon (2510.16831 - Goriely, 19 Oct 2025) in Section 2.2 (Myth #1: Curved Horizontal Elements — The myth)