Dice Question Streamline Icon: https://streamlinehq.com

Characteristic dependence of matrix completion matroids

Determine whether the symmetric matrix completion matroid \mathcal{S}_n(d), the skew-symmetric matrix completion matroid \mathcal{H}_n(d) (via skew-symmetric matrices of rank ≤ 2d), or the rectangular matrix completion matroid \mathcal{B}_{m,n}(d,d) can depend on the characteristic of the base field, by either constructing a characteristic-dependent example or proving that these matroids are characteristic-independent.

Information Square Streamline Icon: https://streamlinehq.com

Background

The paper discusses the relationship between linear-algebraic matroids in positive characteristic and matrix completion matroids, including separability issues in characteristic p. While certain tensor and symmetric power matroids do depend on characteristic, the authors note no known examples of characteristic dependence for the matrix completion matroids themselves.

Clarifying this would solidify the robustness of matrix completion matroids across characteristics and refine connections to rigidity and tropical geometry.

References

We are unaware of any case in which the symmetric matrix completion matroid, the skew-symmetric matrix completion matroid, or the matrix completion matroid depends on the characteristic.

Rigidity matroids and linear algebraic matroids with applications to matrix completion and tensor codes (2405.00778 - Brakensiek et al., 1 May 2024) in Section: Matrix completion in positive characteristic (final remark)