Existence of additional conservation laws for the Kambapalli and Magan cylindrical shear-wave models

Determine whether the cylindrical PDE systems for shear-wave propagation admit any additional local conservation laws beyond the three presented. Specifically, for the Kambapalli model given by σ_r + (2σ)/r = δ u_tt and u_r − (u/r) = (1/δ) σ (β + σ^2)^n, and for the Magan model given by σ_r + (σ)/r = δ u_tt and u_r = (1/δ) σ (β + σ^2)^n, ascertain the existence and form of any further conserved densities and associated fluxes for arbitrary exponent n and constants δ and β.

Background

The paper computes three conservation laws for each of two cylindrical-coordinate models of shear-wave propagation in elastic media: the Kambapalli model and the Magan model. Using a scaling-homogeneity approach implemented in ConservationLawsMD.m, the authors searched for densities with coefficients up to third degree in r and t and did not find any beyond the ones listed.

This lack of additional conservation laws contrasts with a related Cartesian-coordinate model where seven conservation laws were found and the system is conjectured to have infinitely many conservation laws. The explicit statement of non-discovery for the cylindrical models suggests an unresolved question about whether more conservation laws exist and, if so, how to characterize them.

References

No additional conservation laws for either model could be found. This is in stark contrast with the successful computation of seven conservation laws for a similar model in Cartesian coordinates which is conjectured to have infinitely many conservation laws.

Conservation laws of nonlinear PDEs arising in elasticity and acoustics in Cartesian, cylindrical, and spherical geometries  (2512.13062 - Hereman et al., 15 Dec 2025) in End of Section 3 (Computation of conservation laws using scaling homogeneity)