Papers
Topics
Authors
Recent
2000 character limit reached

Calculating black hole shadows: Review of analytical studies (2105.07101v2)

Published 15 May 2021 in gr-qc

Abstract: In this article, we provide a review of the current state of the research of the black hole shadow, focusing on analytical (as opposed to numerical and observational) studies. We start with particular attention to the definition of the shadow and its relation to the often used concepts of escape cone, critical impact parameter and particle cross-section. For methodological purposes, we present the derivation of the angular size of the shadow for an arbitrary spherically symmetric and static space-time, which allows one to calculate the shadow for an observer at arbitrary distance from the center. Then we discuss the calculation of the shadow of a Kerr black hole, for an observer anywhere outside of the black hole. For observers at large distances we present and compare two methods used in the literature. Special attention is given to calculating the shadow in space-times which are not asymptotically flat. Shadows of wormholes and other black-hole impostors are reviewed. Then we discuss the calculation of the black hole shadow in an expanding universe as seen by a comoving observer. The influence of a plasma on the shadow of a black hole is also considered.

Citations (287)

Summary

  • The paper derives analytical expressions for black hole shadows in spherical and Kerr metrics, highlighting the role of escape cones and critical impact parameters.
  • It demonstrates the integration of plasma and cosmological constant effects into shadow calculations, expanding classical vacuum models.
  • The review lays a foundation for future observational calibration and enhanced simulations of both traditional black holes and exotic compact objects.

Analytical Studies on Black Hole Shadows

The paper by Volker Perlick and Oleg Yu. Tsupko provides a comprehensive review of the current state of analytical research on black hole shadows. It serves as a critical reference for understanding the mathematical and theoretical foundation of these phenomena in various space-time configurations, primarily focusing on spherically symmetric and Kerr (rotating) black holes. The authors meticulously derive and compile essential results on the depiction of shadows in different gravitational settings, analyzing both the classical vacuum case and extensions to more complex environments such as those with a cosmological constant or a plasma.

Structure and Challenges in Calculating Black Hole Shadows

The review begins with a discussion on the foundational concepts related to black hole shadows, including escape cones and critical impact parameters. The distinction between these and the Euclidean representation of black holes highlights the non-trivial influence of strong gravitational lensing on light propagation, an effect that has been experimentally validated by observations such as those from the Event Horizon Telescope.

A key part of the paper details the derivation of shadow sizes in spherically symmetric space-times. By examining the Schwarzschild, Reissner-Nordström, and Kottler metrics, the authors derive the angular size of shadows as viewed by a distant observer. These calculations are extended to the Kerr metric, providing insights into the more complex shadows cast by rotating black holes. The integrability of the geodesic equations, thanks to the Carter constant, plays a crucial role in allowing analytical solutions for the shadows in these stationary and axisymmetric space-times.

Additionally, the authors explore shadows in non-asymptotically flat scenarios, such as in the presence of a cosmological constant. They employ an analytical approach to derive properties of the shadows for observers in an expanding universe, which is instrumental in considering cosmological effects on light propagation.

Analytical Generalization and Implications

The review progresses to address generalized space-times, such as Kerr-Newman black holes and axisymmetric extensions with NUT charge and cosmological constants. By leveraging the separability of the Hamilton-Jacobi equation, the shadow boundaries in such geometries are analytically characterized.

A notable extension is the treatment of black hole shadows in the presence of a plasma. This consideration accounts for dispersive media effects that significantly alter the propagation paths of light rays, and thus the observable shadow, especially in the radio wavelength spectrum.

Beyond classical black hole metrics, the authors also investigate shadows for compact objects like wormholes and other hypothetical ultracompact stars. Here, the distinction between theoretical predictions and observational capabilities becomes evident, suggesting the need for further study to differentiate these from traditional black holes.

Concluding Remarks and Future Prospects

In conclusion, the paper underscores analytical approaches' utility in elucidating core properties of black hole shadows, contributing to a deeper understanding of underlying gravitational phenomena. The theoretical predictions outlined can guide observational efforts and inform the calibration of numerical simulations required for interpreting astronomical data.

Looking forward, potential directions for research identified include further investigation of rotating wormhole shadows and the integration of more complex plasma models. These advancements could enhance our comprehension of not only black holes but also exotic objects that may mimic their signatures.

Whiteboard

Paper to Video (Beta)

Open Problems

We haven't generated a list of open problems mentioned in this paper yet.

Continue Learning

We haven't generated follow-up questions for this paper yet.

Collections

Sign up for free to add this paper to one or more collections.