Kalman Neural Networks: Prediction & Control

• Kalman Neural Networks are architectures that merge Kalman filtering principles with neural circuits to perform online prediction, estimation, and control in noisy environments.
• They employ layered, recurrent models with distinct neural populations and Hebbian updates to learn system dynamics and covariance structures efficiently.
• Their design mirrors cortical microcircuits, providing practical engineering solutions and insights into biological sensory inference and motor control.

Kalman Neural Networks encompass a family of architectures and algorithms that integrate the statistical structure of Kalman filtering and control with neural networks. These approaches, grounded in optimal estimation theory, enable neural circuits and artificial systems to perform online prediction, filtering, system identification, and control in the presence of noise and uncertainty. Kalman Neural Networks achieve this by embodying Kalman equations in learnable, often recurrent, neural architectures employing local learning rules such as Hebbian plasticity, with potential relevance for both engineering and neuroscience.

1. Neural Network Architecture for Kalman Prediction and Control

Kalman Neural Networks for optimal prediction and control are realized as recurrent neural networks composed of linear-response nodes. The core architecture, as formalized for optimal Kalman Prediction and Control (KPC), features either two or four distinct neural layers, determined by the inclusion of estimation or full control functionality.

• Layered Circuitry:
  • Estimation Only: Two layers suffice, denoted R and Z.
  • Full Prediction & Control: Four layers—R, Z, g, and T—each encoding a distinct vector of the measurement space dimension ($D_y$).
  • R: Holds measurement-related signals.
  • Z: Processes estimation errors and covariances.
  • g: Computes control-related cost covariance.
  • T: Manages the covariance of control signals.
• Connections:
  • Lateral Weights within each layer encode key matrices (noise covariances $R$, cost covariance $\tilde{g}$, estimation and control covariances $Z$ and $T$), subject to constraints (e.g., symmetry and positive definiteness).
  • Inter-layer (Feedforward/Feedback) Connections encode plant dynamics ($\tilde{F}$, $\tilde{F}'$), linking measurements and estimation layers.
  • Each operation, such as Kalman update or system identification, is mapped to specific matrix or vector processing through these connections.
• Operational Principles:
  • Only linear summation, matrix-vector multiplication, and Hebbian weight updates are required—operations consistent with both artificial and biological settings.

2. Learning Process: System Identification and Hebbian Updates

Learning in Kalman Neural Networks is governed by sample-driven Hebbian algorithms that align neural computations with the recursive structure of the Kalman filter and control.

• Inputs: The architecture requires only a stream of noisy measurements ($y_t$), with no prior knowledge of plant or noise parameters ($F$, $Q$, $H$, $R$).
• Simultaneous Learning Tasks:
  • System Identification: The plant dynamics ($\tilde{F}$) are learned via gradient descent, minimizing prediction errors between observed and estimated measurements:

  $$\tilde{F}_t = \tilde{F}_{t-1} - \gamma_F\, E\big(\eta_t \hat{y}_{t-1}^\top\big)$$

  where $\eta_t$ is the instantaneous estimation error. - Covariance (Lateral Weight) Estimation: Covariances (e.g., $Z, R, T, \tilde{g}$) are recursively estimated as sample averages:

  $$M_{t+1} = (1-\gamma_M) M_t + \gamma_M \langle v_t v_t' \rangle_p$$

• Matrix Inversion Schemes:

  • Inverting covariances required for Kalman gain computation can be achieved either via iterative recurrent dynamics within layers or by directly learning the matrix inverse using Hebbian principles and ensuring matrix symmetry.
• Approximation of Expectations:
  • Statistical expectations are replaced by empirical (ensemble or temporal) averages, consistent with streaming neural computation.

3. Architectural and Functional Constraints

The computation of optimal Kalman prediction and control imposes stringent and specific constraints on network structure and learning rules.

• Assignment of Variables to Layers: Each variable (measurement, prediction, error, control) is represented by a distinct neural population (layer), enabling simultaneous access required for statistical updates.
• Signal Routing and Timing: The flow of information—between raw measurements, prediction, error computation, and correction—demand carefully orchestrated, layer-specific signal propagation, mirroring the dependency structure of Kalman recursions.
• Hebbian/Anti-Hebbian Locality:
  • All learning rules require only the product of pre- and post-synaptic activities, maintaining locality and biological plausibility.
• Structural Match to Kalman Algorithm: Each layer and weight matrix is justified by a direct computational necessity defined by the Kalman recursion, not algorithmic convenience.

4. Biological Relevance and Cortical Circuit Parallels

A notable feature of the Kalman Neural Network is its architectural resemblance to local cortical microcircuits (the local cortical circuit, LCC).

• Layered/Recurrent Structure: The four-layer KPC neural network matches, in both structure and function, key cortical layers (notably 6, 5, 4, and 2/3).
• Input and Output Mapping: KPC neural circuits, like cortical columns, receive sensory input across multiple layers and produce both optimized estimates (sensory output) and control signals (motor or behavioral output) in others.
• Signal Flow Agreement:
  • The intra- and inter-laminar connectivity observed in cortex is mirrored in the Kalman NN, dictated by the statistical dependencies of optimal filtering and feedback.
• Implications for Neurobiology:
  • These resemblances support the conjecture that prediction, probabilistic inference, and control may underlie core cortical computational primitives, with evolutionary convergence on these circuit architectures.

5. Applications: Engineering and Biological Inference

Kalman Neural Networks, through their optimality and adaptability, have several important implications and applications.

• Engineering:
  • Parallel Hardware Implementation: The architecture can be directly instantiated in hardware neural networks for real-time, high-dimensional adaptive prediction and control, including partially unknown or time-varying systems.
  • Nonlinear Extensions: The NN can be used as a recognition or control model in extended (nonlinear) Kalman frameworks.
• Biological and Cognitive Science:
  • The architecture provides predictions about cortical circuit function and supports unified models of sensory inference and motor control.
• Use Cases:
  • Real-time filtering and prediction in sensory processing.
  • Optimized adaptive control in robotics and motor systems.
  • Inference and planning in cognitive tasks that demand hidden state estimation and dynamic feedback.

6. Mathematical Formulation

Kalman Neural Networks directly map the core equations of Kalman estimation and optimal control onto layered, recurrent neural architectures.

Classical Kalman Filter (for state $x_t$)

• State update: $x_{t+1} = F x_t + B u_t + m_t$
• Observation: $y_t = H x_t + n_t$
• State estimate update:

$$\hat{x}_t = \hat{x}_t^- + K_t (y_t - H \hat{x}_t^- )$$

$K_t = P^-_t H^\top (H P^-_t H^\top + R)^{-1}$

$P^-_{t+1} = F (I - K_t H) P^-_t F' + Q$

NN-based Kalman Estimation (in measurement space)

• Dynamics learning: $$\tilde{F}_t = \tilde{F}_{t-1} - \gamma_F E( \epsilon_{t} y_{t-1}^\top )$$
  • Error: $$\epsilon_t = \tilde{F}_{t-1} y_{t-1} + \tilde{u}_{t-1} - y_t$$
• Covariance learning: $$Z_{t+1} = (1-\gamma_Z) Z_t + \gamma_Z \langle \eta_t \eta_t' \rangle_p$$
• Posterior estimate: $\hat{y}_t = y_t + R Z_t^{-1} \eta_t$, where $\eta_t = \hat{y}_t^- - y_t$

NN-based Kalman Control

• Cost function:

$$J = E \left[ \sum_{t=t_0}^{N-1} (u_t' g u_t + x_t' r x_t) + x_N' r x_N \right]$$

• Control law:

$$\tilde{u}_t = \tilde{L}_t \hat{y}_t = (-I + T_t^{-1} \tilde{g}) \tilde{F} \hat{y}_t$$

• Control covariance update:

$$T_{\tau-1} = (1-\gamma_T) T_\tau + \gamma_T \langle w_\tau w_\tau' \rangle_p$$

Summary Table: Core Mapping of Kalman Structure to Neural Circuit

Component	Kalman Role	NN Implementation
$\tilde{F}, \tilde{F}'$	Plant dynamics / prediction	Inter-layer weights
$R$, $\tilde{g}$	Noise/cost covariance	Lateral (layer) weights
$Z$, $T$ or their inverses	Estimation / control gain	Lateral / recurrent weights, Hebbian updates
$y_t$, $\hat{y}_t$, $\eta_t$	Data / state signals	Node activations

---

Kalman Neural Networks embody the mathematical structure of optimal recursive estimation and control in a layered, recurrent neural substrate. Their architecture and learning principles are dictated by—rather than arbitrarily designed for—the computational requirements of the Kalman filter and Linear Quadratic Regulator, offering a principled bridge between neural computation, optimal control theory, and practical engineering realization. The derived architectures not only advance efficient adaptive prediction and control in artificial systems but also suggest that such mathematical/statistical tasks may be core to the operation of biological cortex.