Emergent Mind

A Comprehensive Study of Knowledge Editing for Large Language Models

(2401.01286)

Published Jan 2, 2024 in cs.CL , cs.AI , cs.CV , cs.HC , and cs.LG

Abstract

Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown extraordinary capabilities in understanding and generating text that closely mirrors human communication. However, a primary limitation lies in the significant computational demands during training, arising from their extensive parameterization. This challenge is further intensified by the dynamic nature of the world, necessitating frequent updates to LLMs to correct outdated information or integrate new knowledge, thereby ensuring their continued relevance. Note that many applications demand continual model adjustments post-training to address deficiencies or undesirable behaviors. There is an increasing interest in efficient, lightweight methods for on-the-fly model modifications. To this end, recent years have seen a burgeoning in the techniques of knowledge editing for LLMs, which aim to efficiently modify LLMs' behaviors within specific domains while preserving overall performance across various inputs. In this paper, we first define the knowledge editing problem and then provide a comprehensive review of cutting-edge approaches. Drawing inspiration from educational and cognitive research theories, we propose a unified categorization criterion that classifies knowledge editing methods into three groups: resorting to external knowledge, merging knowledge into the model, and editing intrinsic knowledge. Furthermore, we introduce a new benchmark, KnowEdit, for a comprehensive empirical evaluation of representative knowledge editing approaches. Additionally, we provide an in-depth analysis of knowledge location, which can give a deeper understanding of the knowledge structures inherent within LLMs. Finally, we discuss several potential applications of knowledge editing, outlining its broad and impactful implications.

Comparison of Knowledge Graphs' successful structure restoration vs. LLMs' failure after edits and recovery.

Overview

LLMs require frequent updates; knowledge editing provides efficient finetuning without compromising performance.
Transformers and their self-attention mechanisms are key to LLMs, enabling advanced NLP tasks and understanding knowledge storage.
Knowledge editing is categorized by linking to external knowledge, integrating knowledge, and editing intrinsic knowledge.
KnowEdit is introduced as a benchmark for evaluating different knowledge editing strategies in LLMs.
Knowledge editing has vast applications and informs understanding of AI knowledge mechanisms, impacting efficiency and AI-human interaction.

Introduction to Knowledge Editing

LLMs have become a cornerstone in the field of NLP, capable of storing and manipulating vast amounts of data and closely imitating intricate human communication. Despite these successes, LLMs need to be continually updated with new knowledge due to the fluid nature of information. Frequent, computationally expensive retraining presents a challenge. Therefore, the field has seen a growing interest in efficient, lightweight modifications through knowledge editing, which aims to finetune LLMs in specific aspects without disturbing their general performance.

Transformative Architecture

The Transformer, a model intrinsic to LLMs, employs self-attention mechanisms and fully connected feed-forward networks within an encoder-decoder framework. This design enables effective sequence processing and integration of contextual information. The Transformer has vastly improved the performance of NLP tasks and inspired numerous research endeavors to probe the potentials of LLMs. Studies have suggested frameworks such as the existence of "Knowledge Neurons" and methods like "causal tracing" to decode how knowledge is stored within the layers of LLMs, contributing to the advancements in understanding these complex machine learning architectures.

Categorizing Knowledge Editing Techniques

Knowledge editing is classified into three avenues, drawing parallels to human cognitive processes: resorting to external knowledge, merging knowledge into the model, and editing intrinsic knowledge. Each method aims to align new knowledge with the LLM's existing structure; from initial recognition to deeper integration where the model parameters themselves are modified. The paper proposes KnowEdit, a benchmark to evaluate these knowledge editing strategies. Additionally, the research explores knowledge location analysis, emphasizing the importance of understanding the specific aspects of LLMs that contribute to their knowledge structures and behavior when processing information.

Applications and Broad Impacts

The practical applications of knowledge editing are vast, impacting areas such as efficient machine learning, AI-generated content, trustworthiness in AI systems, and enhanced human-computer interaction. The paper discusses broader impacts like energy consumption and interpretability, critical for future advancements in AI efficiency and adoption. In a broader sense, knowledge editing does not only solve immediate practical problems but also provides insights into the fundamental mechanisms of knowledge storage and retrieval within AI models, with the potential to inform future AI systems more reflective of nuanced human cognition.