Equitably allocating wildfire resilience investments for power grids: The curse of aggregation and vulnerability indices (2404.11520v4)
Abstract: Social vulnerability indices have increased traction for guiding infrastructure investment decisions to prioritize communities that need these investments most. One such plan is the Biden-Harris Justice40 initiative, which aims to guide equitable infrastructure investments by ensuring that disadvantaged communities defined by the Climate & Economic Justice Screening Tool (CEJST) receive 40% of the total benefit realized by the investment. However, there is limited research on the practicality of applying vulnerability indices like the CEJST to real-world decision-making for policy outcomes. In this paper, we study this gap by examining the effectiveness of vulnerability indices in a case study focused on power shutoff and undergrounding decisions in wildfire-prone regions. Using a mixed-integer program and a high-fidelity synthetic transmission network in Texas, we model resource allocation policies inspired by Justice40 and evaluate their impact on reducing power outages and mitigating wildfire risk for vulnerable groups. Our analysis reveals that the Justice40 framework may fail to protect certain communities facing high wildfire risk. In our case study, we show that indigenous groups are particularly impacted. We posit that this outcome is likely due to information losses from data aggregation and the use of generalized vulnerability indices. Through the use of explicit group-level protections, we are able to bound the best possible outcome for population groups that are proportionally most affected.
- Adam Beam. PG&E’s plan to bury power lines and prevent wildfires faces opposition because of high rates, Oct 2023.
- Julia: A fresh approach to numerical computing. SIAM Review, 59(1):65–98, 2017. URL https://doi.org/10.1137/141000671.
- CDC SVI. Database Texas. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention/ Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry/ Geospatial Research, Analysis, and Services Program, 2010.
- Climate and Economic Justice Screening Tool. Climate and economic justice screening tool, Nov 2022. URL https://screeningtool.geoplatform.gov/en/methodology.
- PowerModels.jl: An open-source framework for exploring power flow formulations. In 19th Power Systems Computation Conference (PSCC 2018), 2018.
- California Public Utility Commision. CPUC undergrounding programs description, 2019.
- Texas Legislative Council. Redistricting process, 2023. URL https://redistricting.capitol.texas.gov/.
- Jump: A modeling language for mathematical optimization. SIAM Review, 59(2):295–320, 2017. doi: 10.1137/15M1020575.
- Federal Energy Regulatory Commision. Critical Energy/Electric Infrastructure Information (CEII) Regulations, June 2020.
- Firststreet.org. Wildfire model methodology, Jul 2023. URL https://firststreet.org/methodology/wildfire/.
- A social vulnerability index for disaster management. Journal of Homeland Security and Emergency Management, 8(1), 2011.
- Thomas Fuller. For the most vulnerable, California blackouts ‘can be life or death’. The New York Times, Oct 2019. URL https://www.nytimes.com/2019/10/10/us/california-power-outage.html.
- Impact of social vulnerability on comorbid cancer and cardiovascular disease mortality in the United States. Cardio Oncology, 4(3):326–337, 2022.
- Socioeconomic vulnerability and differential impact of severe weather-induced power outages. PNAS nexus, 2(10):pgad295, 2023.
- The IEEE Reliability Test System-1996. A Report Prepared by the Reliability Test System Task Force of the Application of Probability Methods Subcommittee. IEEE Transactions on Power Systems, 14(3):1010–1020, 1999.
- Gurobi Optimization, LLC. Gurobi Optimizer Reference Manual, 2023. URL https://www.gurobi.com.
- Kenneth L Hall. Out of sight, out of mind: An updated study on the undergrounding of overhead power lines. Edison Electric Institute, Washington, DC, 2012.
- Behavior analysis of socially vulnerable households responding to planned power shutoffs. Natural Hazards Center Mitigation Matters Grant Report, 2022.
- A review of public safety power shutoffs (PSPS) for wildfire mitigation: Policies, practices, models and data sources. IEEE Transactions on Energy Markets, Policy and Regulation, 2023.
- Sharing the load: Considering fairness in de-energization scheduling to mitigate wildfire ignition risk using rolling optimization. In 2022 IEEE 61st Conference on Decision and Control (CDC), pages 5705–5712. IEEE, 2022.
- Longer, more frequent outages afflict the us power grid as states fail to prepare for climate change. The Washington Post, 2021.
- Joseph W Mitchell. Power line failures and catastrophic wildfires under extreme weather conditions. Engineering Failure Analysis, 35:726–735, 2013.
- Learning to coexist with wildfire. Nature, 515(7525):58–66, 2014.
- Do repeated wildfires change homebuyers’ demand for homes in high-risk areas? A hedonic analysis of the short and long-term effects of repeated wildfires on house prices in Southern California. The Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics, 38:155–172, 2009.
- Patrick Murphy. Preventing wildfires with power outages: The growing impacts of California’s public safety power shutoffs. In Energy and Environment Program. PSE Healthy Energy, 2021.
- High winds create “critical” fire risk in parts of central U.S., Apr 2024. URL https://www.nytimes.com/2024/04/06/us/colorado-power-shutoffs-xcel-wind.html.
- PACE. Partnership for an Advanced Computing Environment (PACE). URL http://www.pace.gatech.edu.
- Ivan Penn. Utility-caused wildfires are becoming a national problem, Mar 2024. URL https://www.nytimes.com/2024/03/22/business/energy-environment/electric-utilities-wildfires-climate-change.html.
- PG&E. Conversion of PG&E electric overhead power lines to underground, May 2023. URL https://www.pge.com/en_US/residential/customer-service/other-services/electric-undergrounding-program/electric-undergrounding-program.page.
- Flooding and emergency department visits: Effect modification by the CDC/ATSDR Social Vulnerability Index. International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction, 76:102986, 2022.
- Utility company says its facilities ‘appear to have been involved’ in start of smokehouse creek fire in texas, Mar 2024. URL https://www.cnn.com/2024/03/07/us/xcel-energy-smokehouse-creek-fire/index.html.
- Poverty and health disparities for american indian and alaska native children: current knowledge and future prospects. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences, 1136(1):126–136, 2008.
- Deb Schweizer. Wildfires in All Seasons? US Department of Agriculture, https://www.usda.gov/media/blog/2019/06/27/wildfires-all-seasons, June 2019. Accessed: 2022-02-18.
- A Framework for Risk Assessment and Optimal Line Upgrade Selection to Mitigate Wildfire Risk. arXiv:2110.07348, December 2021.
- California test system (CATS)—: A geographically accurate test system based on the California grid. IEEE Transactions on Energy Markets, Policy and Regulation, 2023a.
- Managing wildfire risk and promoting equity through optimal configuration of networked microgrids. In Proceedings of the 14th ACM International Conference on Future Energy Systems, e-Energy ’23, page 189–199. Association for Computing Machinery, 2023b. ISBN 9798400700323. doi: 10.1145/3575813.3595196. URL https://doi.org/10.1145/3575813.3595196.
- Texas A&M University System. How do power lines cause wildfires?, July 2014. URL https://wildfiremitigation.tees.tamus.edu/faqs/how-power-lines-cause-wildfires.
- US Census 2010. 2010 Center of Population by Census Tract. US Census Bureau, Mar 2013. URL https://www2.census.gov/geo/docs/reference/cenpop2010/tract/.
- US Census 2019. 2019 Tract Data. US Census Bureau, 2019. URL https://www.census.gov/topics/research/guidance/planning-databases/2019.html.
- US Census Bureau. 2022: ACS 1-year supplemental estimates table K200301, 2022a. URL https://data.census.gov/table/ACSSE2022.K200301?t=Race%20and%20Ethnicity&g=040XX00US48&y=2022&d=ACS%201-Year%20Supplemental%20Estimates.
- US Census Bureau. 2022: ACS 1-year supplemental estimates table S1703, 2022b. URL https://data.census.gov/table/ACSST1Y2022.S1703?q=Texas%20Income%20and%20Poverty.
- US Census Bureau. 2022: ACS 1-year supplemental estimates table K200201, 2022c. URL https://data.census.gov/table/ACSSE2022.K200201?t=Race%20and%20Ethnicity&g=040XX00US48&y=2022&d=ACS%201-Year%20Supplemental%20Estimates.
- US Geological Survey. Wildland Fire Potential Index, 2021.
- Quantifying the Risk of Wildfire Ignition by Power Lines under Extreme Weather Conditions. arXiv:2110.05551, October 2021.
- White House Office. U.S. Executive Order 14008. Number 14008. 2021.
- White House Office. Justice40: A whole-of-government initiative. Apr 2023. URL https://www.whitehouse.gov/environmentaljustice/justice40/.
- Comparison of national vulnerability indices used by the centers for disease control and prevention for the COVID-19 response. Public Health Reports, 137(4):803–812, 2022.
- Creation of synthetic electric grid models for transient stability studies. In The 10th Bulk Power Systems Dynamics and Control Symposium (IREP 2017), pages 1–6, 2017.
- Modeling, tuning, and validating system dynamics in synthetic electric grids. IEEE Transactions on Power Systems, 33(6):6501–6509, 2018. doi: 10.1109/TPWRS.2018.2823702.
- Resilient by design: Preventing wildfires and blackouts with microgrids. Applied Energy, 313:118793, 2022.
- Texas electric power crisis of 2021 warns of a new blackout mechanism. CSEE Journal of Power and Energy Systems, 8(1):1–9, 2022.