Modeling Homophily in Exponential-Family Random Graph Models for Bipartite Networks (2312.05673v1)
Abstract: Homophily, the tendency of individuals who are alike to form ties with one another, is an important concept in the study of social networks. Yet accounting for homophily effects is complicated in the context of bipartite networks where ties connect individuals not with one another but rather with a separate set of nodes, which might also be individuals but which are often an entirely different type of objects. As a result, much work on the effect of homophily in a bipartite network proceeds by first eliminating the bipartite structure, collapsing a two-mode network to a one-mode network and thereby ignoring potentially meaningful structure in the data. We introduce a set of methods to model homophily on bipartite networks without losing information in this way, then we demonstrate that these methods allow for substantively interesting findings in management science not possible using standard techniques. These methods are implemented in the widely-used ergm package for R.
- {barticle}[author] \bauthor\bsnmAgneessens, \bfnmFilip\binitsF., \bauthor\bsnmRoose, \bfnmHenk\binitsH. and \bauthor\bsnmWaege, \bfnmHans\binitsH. (\byear2004). \btitleChoices of Theatre Events: p* Models for Affiliation Networks with Attributes. \bjournalMetodoloski zvezki \bvolume1 \bpages419–439. \endbibitem
- {barticle}[author] \bauthor\bsnmBorgatti, \bfnmS.\binitsS. and \bauthor\bsnmEverett, \bfnmM.\binitsM. (\byear1997). \btitleNetwork Analysis of 2-Mode Data. \bjournalSocial Networks \bvolume19 \bpages243-269. \endbibitem
- {barticle}[author] \bauthor\bsnmChin, \bfnmTee Suan\binitsT. S. and \bauthor\bsnmMd Yusoff, \bfnmRosman\binitsR. (\byear2020). \btitleMediating effects of soft skills to business performance: A study on a manufacturing organization. \bjournalJournal of Critical Reviews \bvolume7 \bpages304–308. \endbibitem
- {barticle}[author] \bauthor\bsnmChu, \bfnmJohan SG\binitsJ. S. and \bauthor\bsnmDavis, \bfnmGerald F\binitsG. F. (\byear2016). \btitleWho killed the inner circle? The decline of the American corporate interlock network. \bjournalAmerican Journal of Sociology \bvolume122 \bpages714–754. \endbibitem
- {barticle}[author] \bauthor\bparticlede \bsnmCarvalho, \bfnmMarly Monteiro\binitsM. M. and \bauthor\bsnmJunior, \bfnmRoque Rabechini\binitsR. R. (\byear2015). \btitleImpact of risk management on project performance: The importance of soft skills. \bjournalInternational Journal of Production Research \bvolume53 \bpages321–340. \bdoi10.1080/00207543.2014.919423 \endbibitem
- {barticle}[author] \bauthor\bsnmEfron, \bfnmB.\binitsB. (\byear1975). \btitleDefining the Curvature of a Statistical Problem (with Applications to Second Order Efficiency). \bjournalAnnals of Statistics \bvolume3 \bpages1189–1242. \endbibitem
- {barticle}[author] \bauthor\bsnmEfron, \bfnmB.\binitsB. (\byear1978). \btitleThe Geometry of Exponential Families. \bjournalThe Annals of Statistics \bvolume6 \bpages362–376. \endbibitem
- {barticle}[author] \bauthor\bsnmErhardt, \bfnmNiclas L\binitsN. L., \bauthor\bsnmWerbel, \bfnmJames D\binitsJ. D. and \bauthor\bsnmShrader, \bfnmCharles B\binitsC. B. (\byear2003). \btitleBoard of director diversity and firm financial performance. \bjournalCorporate governance: An international review \bvolume11 \bpages102–111. \endbibitem
- {bmanual}[author] \bauthor\bsnmHandcock, \bfnmM. S.\binitsM. S. (\byear2003). \btitleAssessing degeneracy in statistical models of social networks \bpublisherCenter for Statistics and the Social Sciences, University of Washington \bnoteWorking paper #39. \endbibitem
- {barticle}[author] \bauthor\bsnmHoward, \bfnmMichael D\binitsM. D., \bauthor\bsnmWithers, \bfnmMichael C\binitsM. C. and \bauthor\bsnmTihanyi, \bfnmLaszlo\binitsL. (\byear2017). \btitleKnowledge dependence and the formation of director interlocks. \bjournalAcademy of Management Journal \bvolume60 \bpages1986–2013. \endbibitem
- {barticle}[author] \bauthor\bsnmHunter, \bfnmDavid R.\binitsD. R. (\byear2007a). \btitleCurved exponential family models for social networks. \bjournalSocial Networks \bvolume29 \bpages216–230. \endbibitem
- {barticle}[author] \bauthor\bsnmHunter, \bfnmD. R.\binitsD. R. (\byear2007b). \btitleCurved exponential family models for social networks. \bjournalSocial Networks \bvolume29 \bpages216–230. \endbibitem
- {barticle}[author] \bauthor\bsnmHunter, \bfnmD. R.\binitsD. R. and \bauthor\bsnmHandcock, \bfnmM. S.\binitsM. S. (\byear2006). \btitleInference in curved exponential family models for networks. \bjournalJournal of Computational and Graphical Statistics \bvolume15 \bpages565–583. \endbibitem
- {barticle}[author] \bauthor\bsnmKevork, \bfnmSevag\binitsS. and \bauthor\bsnmKauermann, \bfnmGöran\binitsG. (\byear2022). \btitleBipartite exponential random graph models with nodal random effects. \bjournalSocial Networks \bvolume70 \bpages90–99. \endbibitem
- {barticle}[author] \bauthor\bsnmKim, \bfnmDaehyun\binitsD. and \bauthor\bsnmStarks, \bfnmLaura T\binitsL. T. (\byear2016). \btitleGender diversity on corporate boards: Do women contribute unique skills? \bjournalAmerican Economic Review \bvolume106 \bpages267–271. \endbibitem
- {barticle}[author] \bauthor\bsnmKirsch, \bfnmAnja\binitsA. (\byear2018). \btitleThe gender composition of corporate boards: A review and research agenda. \bjournalThe Leadership Quarterly \bvolume29 \bpages346–364. \endbibitem
- {barticle}[author] \bauthor\bsnmLaker, \bfnmDennis R\binitsD. R. and \bauthor\bsnmPowell, \bfnmJimmy L\binitsJ. L. (\byear2011). \btitleThe differences between hard and soft skills and their relative impact on training transfer. \bjournalHuman resource development quarterly \bvolume22 \bpages111–122. \endbibitem
- {barticle}[author] \bauthor\bsnmLamb, \bfnmNai H\binitsN. H. and \bauthor\bsnmRoundy, \bfnmPhilip\binitsP. (\byear2016). \btitleThe “ties that bind” board interlocks research: A systematic review. \bjournalManagement Research Review \bvolume39 \bpages1516–1542. \endbibitem
- {barticle}[author] \bauthor\bsnmLatapy, \bfnmMatthieu\binitsM., \bauthor\bsnmMagnien, \bfnmClémence\binitsC. and \bauthor\bsnmVecchio, \bfnmNathalie Del\binitsN. D. (\byear2008). \btitleBasic notions for the analysis of large two-mode networks. \bjournalSocial Networks \bvolume30 \bpages31 - 48. \endbibitem
- {barticle}[author] \bauthor\bsnmMartin, \bfnmGeoffrey\binitsG., \bauthor\bsnmGözübüyük, \bfnmRemzi\binitsR. and \bauthor\bsnmBecerra, \bfnmManuel\binitsM. (\byear2015). \btitleInterlocks and firm performance: The role of uncertainty in the directorate interlock-performance relationship. \bjournalStrategic Management Journal \bvolume36 \bpages235–253. \endbibitem
- {barticle}[author] \bauthor\bsnmMcDonald, \bfnmMichael L\binitsM. L. and \bauthor\bsnmWestphal, \bfnmJames D\binitsJ. D. (\byear2013). \btitleAccess denied: Low mentoring of women and minority first-time directors and its negative effects on appointments to additional boards. \bjournalAcademy of Management Journal \bvolume56 \bpages1169–1198. \endbibitem
- {barticle}[author] \bauthor\bsnmMcPherson, \bfnmMiller\binitsM., \bauthor\bsnmSmith-Lovin, \bfnmLynn\binitsL. and \bauthor\bsnmCook, \bfnmJames M\binitsJ. M. (\byear2001). \btitleBirds of a Feather: Homophily in Social Networks. \bjournalAnnual Review of Sociology \bvolume27 \bpages415–444. \endbibitem
- {barticle}[author] \bauthor\bsnmPark, \bfnmSun Hyun\binitsS. H. and \bauthor\bsnmWestphal, \bfnmJames D\binitsJ. D. (\byear2013). \btitleSocial discrimination in the corporate elite: How status affects the propensity for minority CEOs to receive blame for low firm performance. \bjournalAdministrative Science Quarterly \bvolume58 \bpages542–586. \endbibitem
- {bbook}[author] \bauthor\bsnmPfeffer, \bfnmJeffrey\binitsJ. and \bauthor\bsnmSalancik, \bfnmGerald R\binitsG. R. (\byear2003). \btitleThe external control of organizations: A resource dependence perspective. \bpublisherStanford University Press. \endbibitem
- {barticle}[author] \bauthor\bsnmRobins, \bfnmGarry\binitsG. and \bauthor\bsnmAlexander, \bfnmMalcolm\binitsM. (\byear2004). \btitleSmall Worlds Among Interlocking Directors: Network Structure and Distance in Bipartite Graphs. \bjournalComputational & Mathematical Organization Theory \bvolume10 \bpages69–94. \endbibitem
- {barticle}[author] \bauthor\bsnmRobles, \bfnmMarcel M\binitsM. M. (\byear2012). \btitleExecutive perceptions of the top 10 soft skills needed in today’s workplace. \bjournalBusiness communication quarterly \bvolume75 \bpages453–465. \endbibitem
- {barticle}[author] \bauthor\bsnmSeebeck, \bfnmAndreas\binitsA. and \bauthor\bsnmVetter, \bfnmJulia\binitsJ. (\byear2021). \btitleNot just a gender numbers game: How board gender diversity affects corporate risk disclosure. \bjournalJournal of Business Ethics \bpages1–26. \endbibitem
- {barticle}[author] \bauthor\bsnmShalizi, \bfnmCosma Rohilla\binitsC. R. and \bauthor\bsnmRinaldo, \bfnmAlessandro\binitsA. (\byear2013). \btitleConsistency under sampling of exponential random graph models. \bjournalAnnals of Statistics \bvolume41 \bpages508–535. \endbibitem
- {barticle}[author] \bauthor\bsnmWasserman, \bfnmS.\binitsS. and \bauthor\bsnmPattison, \bfnmP.\binitsP. (\byear1996). \btitleLogit models and logistic regressions for social networks: I. An introduction to Markov graphs and p*. \bjournalPsychometrika \bvolume61 \bpages401–425. \endbibitem
- {barticle}[author] \bauthor\bsnmWithers, \bfnmMichael C\binitsM. C., \bauthor\bsnmHoward, \bfnmMichael D\binitsM. D. and \bauthor\bsnmTihanyi, \bfnmLaszlo\binitsL. (\byear2020). \btitleYou’ve got a friend: Examining board interlock formation after financial restatements. \bjournalOrganization Science \bvolume31 \bpages742–769. \endbibitem
- {barticle}[author] \bauthor\bsnmZhu, \bfnmDavid H\binitsD. H. and \bauthor\bsnmWestphal, \bfnmJames D\binitsJ. D. (\byear2014). \btitleHow directors’ prior experience with other demographically similar CEOs affects their appointments onto corporate boards and the consequences for CEO compensation. \bjournalAcademy of management journal \bvolume57 \bpages791–813. \endbibitem