A Performance Study of Horizontally Explicit Vertically Implicit (HEVI) Time-Integrators for Non-Hydrostatic Atmospheric Models (2311.11425v1)

Abstract: We conduct a thorough study of different forms of horizontally explicit and vertically implicit (HEVI) time-integration strategies for the compressible Euler equations on spherical domains typical of nonhydrostatic global atmospheric applications. We compare the computational time and complexity of two nonlinear variants (NHEVI-GMRES and NHEVI-LU) and a linear variant (LHEVI). We report on the performance of these three variants for a number of additive Runge-Kutta Methods ranging in order of accuracy from second through fifth, and confirm the expected order of accuracy of the HEVI methods for each time-integrator. To gauge the maximum usable time-step of each HEVI method, we run simulations of a nonhydrostatic baroclinic instability for 100 days and then use this time-step to compare the time-to-solution of each method. The results show that NHEVI-LU is 2x faster than NHEVI-GMRES, and LHEVI is 5x faster than NHEVI-LU, for the idealized cases tested. The baroclinic instability and inertia-gravity wave simulations indicate that the optimal choice of time-integrator is LHEVI with either second or third order schemes, as both schemes yield similar time to solution and relative L2 error at their maximum usable time-steps. In the future, we will report on whether these results hold for more complex problems using, e.g., real atmospheric data and/or a higher model top typical of space weather applications.