Tailgating quantum circuits for high-order energy derivatives

Abstract: To understand the chemical properties of molecules, it is often important to study derivatives of energies with respect to nuclear coordinates or external fields. Quantum algorithms for computing energy derivatives have been proposed, but only limited work has been done to address the specific challenges that arise in this context, where calculations are more complicated and involve more stringent requirements on accuracy compared to single-point energy calculations. In this work, we introduce a technique to improve the performance of variational quantum circuits calculating energy derivatives. The method, which we refer to as tailgating, is an adaptive procedure that selects gates based on their gradient with respect to the expectation value of Hamiltonian derivatives. These gates are then added at the end of a quantum circuit originally designed to calculate ground- or excited-state energies. A distinguishing feature of this approach is that the appended gates do not need to be optimized: their parameters can be set to zero and varied only for the purpose of computing energy derivatives, via calculating derivatives with respect to circuit parameters. We support the validity of this method by establishing sufficient conditions for a circuit to compute accurate energy gradients. This is achieved through a connection between energy derivatives and eigenstates of Taylor approximations of the Hamiltonian. We illustrate the advantages of the tailgating approach by performing simulations calculating the vibrational modes of beryllium hydride and water: quantities that depend on second-order energy derivatives.