Papers
Topics
Authors
Recent
Gemini 2.5 Flash
Gemini 2.5 Flash
102 tokens/sec
GPT-4o
59 tokens/sec
Gemini 2.5 Pro Pro
43 tokens/sec
o3 Pro
6 tokens/sec
GPT-4.1 Pro
50 tokens/sec
DeepSeek R1 via Azure Pro
28 tokens/sec
2000 character limit reached

Bi-directional Domain Adaptation for Sim2Real Transfer of Embodied Navigation Agents (2011.12421v2)

Published 24 Nov 2020 in cs.RO

Abstract: Deep reinforcement learning models are notoriously data hungry, yet real-world data is expensive and time consuming to obtain. The solution that many have turned to is to use simulation for training before deploying the robot in a real environment. Simulation offers the ability to train large numbers of robots in parallel, and offers an abundance of data. However, no simulation is perfect, and robots trained solely in simulation fail to generalize to the real-world, resulting in a "sim-vs-real gap". How can we overcome the trade-off between the abundance of less accurate, artificial data from simulators and the scarcity of reliable, real-world data? In this paper, we propose Bi-directional Domain Adaptation (BDA), a novel approach to bridge the sim-vs-real gap in both directions -- real2sim to bridge the visual domain gap, and sim2real to bridge the dynamics domain gap. We demonstrate the benefits of BDA on the task of PointGoal Navigation. BDA with only 5k real-world (state, action, next-state) samples matches the performance of a policy fine-tuned with ~600k samples, resulting in a speed-up of ~120x.

User Edit Pencil Streamline Icon: https://streamlinehq.com
Authors (3)
  1. Joanne Truong (12 papers)
  2. Sonia Chernova (60 papers)
  3. Dhruv Batra (160 papers)
Citations (50)

Summary

Bi-directional Domain Adaptation for Sim2Real Transfer of Embodied Navigation Agents

The paper "Bi-directional Domain Adaptation for Sim2Real Transfer of Embodied Navigation Agents" addresses a critical challenge in deploying reinforcement learning (RL) robots in real-world environments: the sim2real gap. This gap emerges because simulators, while cost-effective and abundant in data, inherently lack the complexity of real-world dynamics and visual noise, which often results in highly optimized algorithms in simulation underperforming in reality. The authors propose a novel approach termed Bi-directional Domain Adaptation (BDA) to efficiently bridge this gap.

Insights from BDA Methodology

The BDA framework consists of two complementary modules: real2sim observation adaptation and sim2real dynamics adaptation. This bi-directional approach uniquely addresses both the visual and dynamic disparities between simulated and real environments:

  1. Real2Sim Observation Adaptation: The authors employ CycleGAN to transform real-world visuals to resemble those observed in simulation. This mitigates the visual noise by enabling the robot's sensors to perceive real-world environments through a "simulated lens." This transformation is computationally efficient as it decouples the learning of visual modifications from action-oriented policy learning, allowing seamless updates to visual models without retraining policies from scratch.
  2. Sim2Real Dynamics Adaptation: Here, a residual dynamics model compensates for the simulator’s imperfections by predicting discrepancies between simulated and real-state transitions. The neural network-based dynamics module adjusts the simulator's outputs, enabling the policy to learn trajectories more representative of real-world experiences. The approach cleverly exploits the ability to reset simulators, an opportunity not available in static real environments, allowing for experiential breadth without the reality's constraints and unpredictability.

Experimental Validation

The paper validates BDA on the task of PointGoal Navigation using both Sim2Sim (as a proxy for Sim2Real experiments) and real scenarios, given restrictions such as COVID-19. The experiments carried out in simulated photo-realistic environments with added synthetic noise accurately mirror real-world conditions, such as sensor and actuation noises. Policies using BDA match the performance of fine-tuned yet inefficient policies across these environments but do so with a substantial reduction in real-world data requirements (up to 117 times more efficient in data usage).

Theoretical and Practical Implications

BDA's implications are multifaceted, impacting both future research agendas and practical deployments. Theoretically, BDA presents a methodologically distinct strategy for domain adaptation that balances perception and action in RL models, paving the way for more robust policy generalization across domains. Practically, the technique drastically improves the feasibility of deploying RL agents in real-world settings by minimizing expensive real-world data collection. The sample efficiency gains are particularly valuable in constrained environments where real-world experimentation is limited or infeasible.

Future Directions

This research opens several avenues for future exploration. Building upon BDA, further work could explore adaptive learning mechanisms that allow real-time domain adaptation beyond pre-training paradigms. Moreover, integrating BDA with other domain randomization strategies or hybrid learning models could provide even more resilient solutions across varying complex tasks and environments.

In conclusion, the paper's proposed BDA framework represents a significant advance in sim2real transfer strategies by effectively exploiting bi-directional domain adaptation techniques catered to both visual and dynamic challenges of real-world robotics. It paves the way for scalable, efficient, and more resilient deployment of robotic agents equipped with deep RL capabilities. The achieved balance between simulation and reality highlights an important milestone towards robust and intelligent robotic navigation systems in practical applications.

Youtube Logo Streamline Icon: https://streamlinehq.com