Papers
Topics
Authors
Recent
Gemini 2.5 Flash
Gemini 2.5 Flash
184 tokens/sec
GPT-4o
7 tokens/sec
Gemini 2.5 Pro Pro
45 tokens/sec
o3 Pro
4 tokens/sec
GPT-4.1 Pro
38 tokens/sec
DeepSeek R1 via Azure Pro
28 tokens/sec
2000 character limit reached

TDR-OBCA: A Reliable Planner for Autonomous Driving in Free-Space Environment (2009.11345v2)

Published 23 Sep 2020 in cs.RO

Abstract: This paper presents an optimization-based collision avoidance trajectory generation method for autonomous driving in free-space environments, with enhanced robustness, driving comfort and efficiency. Starting from the hybrid optimization-based framework, we introduces two warm start methods, temporal and dual variable warm starts, to improve the efficiency. We also reformulate the problem to improve the robustness and efficiency. We name this new algorithm TDR-OBCA. With these changes, compared with original hybrid optimization we achieve a 96.67% failure rate decrease with respect to initial conditions, 13.53% increase in driving comforts and 3.33% to 44.82% increase in planner efficiency as obstacles number scales. We validate our results in hundreds of simulation scenarios and hundreds of hours of public road tests in both U.S. and China. Our source code is available at https://github.com/ApolloAuto/apollo.

Citations (20)

Summary

  • The paper presents TDR-OBCA, an optimization-based method that reduces failure rates by 96.67% and improves driving comfort by 13.53% in autonomous driving.
  • It employs temporal and dual variable warm start strategies to accelerate convergence and efficiently navigate the complex trajectory optimization landscape.
  • Extensive simulations and road tests validate efficiency improvements ranging from 3.33% to 44.82%, underscoring the method's practical reliability in real-world scenarios.

Overview of TDR-OBCA: A Reliable Planner for Autonomous Driving in Free-Space Environments

The paper presents TDR-OBCA, an optimization-based collision avoidance trajectory generation method designed for autonomous driving in free-space environments. The method claims improvements in robustness, driving comfort, and efficiency over existing hybrid optimization-based frameworks.

Key Contributions

The authors introduce two warm start methods—temporal and dual variable warm starts—alongside a reformulation strategy aimed at enhancing the efficiency and robustness of collision avoidance planning. These components are integrated into the TDR-OBCA algorithm, significantly reducing the failure rate, enhancing driving comfort, and increasing computational efficiency as the complexity of obstacle environments increases.

Numerical Results

TDR-OBCA demonstrates impressive numerical results. The algorithm yields a failure rate decrease of 96.67% compared to original methods, a 13.53% improvement in driving comfort metrics, and a substantial increase in planner efficiency ranging from 3.33% to 44.82% as the number of obstacles grows. This level of performance is validated through extensive simulation scenarios as well as practical road tests in the United States and China.

Technical Insights

  1. Warm Start Techniques: The temporal and dual variable warm starts are designed to accelerate convergence by providing better initial guesses for trajectory optimization. By leveraging prior solutions, these methods effectively navigate the solution space, thus reducing computational overhead.
  2. Problem Reformulation: By reformulating the optimization problem, particularly addressing the nonlinear and non-differentiable nature of collision constraints, the authors attempt to balance safety requirements with computational feasibility.
  3. Simulation and Real-World Validations: The approach is not only validated through hundreds of simulations but also through real-world testing, lending credibility to its robustness and applicability in diverse scenarios, including valet parking and vehicular hailing.

Implications and Future Directions

TDR-OBCA's demonstrated robustness and efficiency suggest potential practical applications in real-world autonomous driving scenarios, notably in environments demanding precise maneuvering like parking and pull-over situations. The integration of TDR-OBCA with Apollo's Autonomous Driving Platform underscores its readiness for deployment at scale.

Looking forward, further exploration could focus on optimizing computational efficiency even further and accommodating a broader array of driving comfort criteria. Additionally, advanced solver integration, such as GRAMPC, might offer further improvements in solving large-scale MPC problems within stringent real-time constraints.

TDR-OBCA represents a notable advance in autonomous vehicle trajectory planning by addressing key challenges in collision avoidance and trajectory smoothness, paving the way for more reliable fully autonomous systems in complex and dynamic free-space environments.

Github Logo Streamline Icon: https://streamlinehq.com