Incompressibility of H-free edge modification problems: Towards a dichotomy

Abstract: Given a graph $G$ and an integer $k$, the $H$-free Edge Editing problem is to find whether there exists at most $k$ pairs of vertices in $G$ such that changing the adjacency of the pairs in $G$ results in a graph without any induced copy of $H$. The existence of polynomial kernels for $H$-free Edge Editing received significant attention in the parameterized complexity literature. Nontrivial polynomial kernels are known to exist for some graphs $H$ with at most 4 vertices, but starting from 5 vertices, polynomial kernels are known only if $H$ is either complete or empty. This suggests the conjecture that there is no other $H$ with at least 5 vertices were $H$-free Edge Editing admits a polynomial kernel. Towards this goal, we obtain a set $\mathcal{H}$ of nine 5-vertex graphs such that if for every $H\in\mathcal{H}$, $H$-free Edge Editing is incompressible and the complexity assumption $NP \not\subseteq coNP/poly$ holds, then $H$-free Edge Editing is incompressible for every graph $H$ with at least five vertices that is neither complete nor empty. That is, proving incompressibility for these nine graphs would give a complete classification of the kernelization complexity of $H$-free Edge Editing for every $H$ with at least 5 vertices. We obtain similar result also for $H$-free Edge Deletion. Here the picture is more complicated due to the existence of another infinite family of graphs $H$ where the problem is trivial (graphs with exactly one edge). We obtain a larger set $\mathcal{H}$ of nineteen graphs whose incompressibility would give a complete classification of the kernelization complexity of $H$-free Edge Deletion for every graph $H$ with at least 5 vertices. Analogous results follow also for the $H$-free Edge Completion problem by simple complementation.