Thermodynamic uncertainty relation in thermal transport

Abstract: We use the fundamental nonequilibrium steady-state fluctuation symmetry and derive a condition on the validity of the thermodynamic uncertainty relation (TUR) in thermal transport problems, classical or quantum alike. We test this condition and study the breakdown of the TUR in different thermal transport junctions of bosonic and electronic degrees of freedom. First, we prove that the TUR is valid in harmonic oscillator junctions. In contrast, in the nonequilibrium spin-boson model, which realizes many-body effects, it is satisfied in the Markovian limit, but violations arise as we tune (reduce) the cutoff frequency of the thermal baths, thus observing non-Markovian dynamics. Finally, we consider heat transport by noninteracting electrons in a tight-binding chain model. Here we show that the TUR is feasibly violated by tuning e.g. the hybridization energy of the chain to the metal leads. These results manifest that the validity of the TUR relies on the statistics of the participating carriers, their interaction, and the nature of their couplings to the macroscopic contacts (metal electrodes, phonon baths).