Papers
Topics
Authors
Recent
Gemini 2.5 Flash
Gemini 2.5 Flash
102 tokens/sec
GPT-4o
59 tokens/sec
Gemini 2.5 Pro Pro
43 tokens/sec
o3 Pro
6 tokens/sec
GPT-4.1 Pro
50 tokens/sec
DeepSeek R1 via Azure Pro
28 tokens/sec
2000 character limit reached

Data-Efficient Hierarchical Reinforcement Learning (1805.08296v4)

Published 21 May 2018 in cs.LG, cs.AI, and stat.ML

Abstract: Hierarchical reinforcement learning (HRL) is a promising approach to extend traditional reinforcement learning (RL) methods to solve more complex tasks. Yet, the majority of current HRL methods require careful task-specific design and on-policy training, making them difficult to apply in real-world scenarios. In this paper, we study how we can develop HRL algorithms that are general, in that they do not make onerous additional assumptions beyond standard RL algorithms, and efficient, in the sense that they can be used with modest numbers of interaction samples, making them suitable for real-world problems such as robotic control. For generality, we develop a scheme where lower-level controllers are supervised with goals that are learned and proposed automatically by the higher-level controllers. To address efficiency, we propose to use off-policy experience for both higher and lower-level training. This poses a considerable challenge, since changes to the lower-level behaviors change the action space for the higher-level policy, and we introduce an off-policy correction to remedy this challenge. This allows us to take advantage of recent advances in off-policy model-free RL to learn both higher- and lower-level policies using substantially fewer environment interactions than on-policy algorithms. We term the resulting HRL agent HIRO and find that it is generally applicable and highly sample-efficient. Our experiments show that HIRO can be used to learn highly complex behaviors for simulated robots, such as pushing objects and utilizing them to reach target locations, learning from only a few million samples, equivalent to a few days of real-time interaction. In comparisons with a number of prior HRL methods, we find that our approach substantially outperforms previous state-of-the-art techniques.

User Edit Pencil Streamline Icon: https://streamlinehq.com
Authors (4)
  1. Ofir Nachum (64 papers)
  2. Shixiang Gu (23 papers)
  3. Honglak Lee (174 papers)
  4. Sergey Levine (531 papers)
Citations (752)

Summary

Data-Efficient Hierarchical Reinforcement Learning

The paper "Data-Efficient Hierarchical Reinforcement Learning" by Ofir Nachum, Shixiang Gu, Honglak Lee, and Sergey Levine presents a novel approach to Hierarchical Reinforcement Learning (HRL) that emphasizes both generality and sample efficiency. The authors introduce HIRO, a hierarchical agent designed to address the limitations of prior HRL methods, particularly regarding the need for task-specific designs and the reliance on on-policy training, which tend to be sample-inefficient.

Overview of HIRO

HIRO employs a two-tier hierarchy of policies—a higher-level policy that sets goals and a lower-level policy that acts to achieve these goals. This structure allows the higher-level policy to operate on a coarser temporal scale by periodically generating goals that the lower-level policy aims to achieve. One of the key innovations of HIRO is the way it handles goal setting and transition:

  • Goal Setting: Goals are specified in raw state space rather than a learned embedding space, simplifying the learning process.
  • Intrinsic Reward: The lower-level policy receives rewards for achieving states close to the goal states set by the higher-level policy.
  • Off-Policy Training: Both policies are trained off-policy, leveraging an off-policy correction mechanism that re-labels past experiences to be consistent with the current low-level policy.

Off-Policy Correction Mechanism

A significant challenge in training hierarchical policies off-policy is the non-stationarity of the higher-level policy's experience due to the evolving lower-level policy. To address this, the authors introduce an off-policy correction mechanism. This mechanism recalibrates past experiences by re-labeling goals to ensure consistency with the current lower-level policy, thereby enabling efficient off-policy training for both policy levels.

Strong Numerical Results

The empirical evaluation of HIRO demonstrates substantial performance gains over previous HRL methods and non-hierarchical methods. Evaluation was performed on several complex tasks involving continuous control, such as:

  • Ant Gather: A simulated ant must navigate to collect apples while avoiding bombs.
  • Ant Maze: Navigation through a \supset-shaped corridor.
  • Ant Push: Involving the movement and manipulation of a block.
  • Ant Fall: A 3D navigation task requiring the use of an object to cross a chasm.

In all tasks, HIRO exhibits superior sample efficiency and achieves higher final performance levels with significantly fewer environment interactions compared to state-of-the-art methods like FeUdal Networks (FuN), Stochastic Neural Networks for HRL (SNN4HRL), and Variational Information Maximizing Exploration (VIME).

Implications and Future Developments

The results from HIRO indicate that hierarchical structures, when coupled with an effective off-policy correction, can indeed generalize well and be sample-efficient enough for real-world applications.

Practical Implications:

  1. Robotic Control: By reducing the sample complexity, HIRO makes it feasible to train policies for intricate robotic tasks using only a few days of real-time interaction.
  2. Autonomous Systems: The efficiency and flexibility of HIRO can be leveraged to develop autonomous agents capable of handling diverse tasks without extensive hand-designed task specifications.

Theoretical Implications:

  1. HRL Research: HIRO's success evidences the viability of utilizing raw state representations for goal setting in HRL, contradicting the conventional emphasis on learned embeddings.
  2. Off-Policy Algorithm Development: The proposed off-policy correction mechanism opens new avenues for enhancing the stability and robustness of off-policy RL algorithms in hierarchical settings.

Future Directions:

Further research could refine the off-policy correction mechanism, potentially exploring more sophisticated techniques for reducing non-stationarity. Additionally, extending HIRO to handle multi-agent environments or multi-task learning scenarios could significantly broaden its applicability.

In summary, the paper makes noteworthy contributions to the field of HRL by proposing a general and data-efficient hierarchical learning framework, validated through rigorous empirical testing on complex continuous control tasks. The HIRO agent not only sets a new benchmark for sample efficiency but also provides a flexible, scalable approach suitable for a wide range of real-world applications.