---
title: Scalarized AdS Black Holes
url: https://www.emergentmind.com/topics/scalarized-ads-black-holes
type: topic
---

# Scalarized AdS Black Holes

Scalarized AdS black holes are asymptotically Anti-de Sitter black-hole solutions with nontrivial scalar configurations supported by the bulk dynamics rather than by externally imposed scalar sources. In the literature this label covers several distinct mechanisms: curvature-induced scalarization in scalar-tensor and Gauss–Bonnet models, Maxwell-induced scalarization in Einstein–Maxwell-scalar theories, superradiant condensation of charged scalars in global AdS, and scalar-supported warped AdS\(_3\) geometries. An important limiting case is provided by Schwarzschild–AdS solutions in \(\mathcal N=2\) gauged supergravity with a scalar sector that is present but covariantly frozen; these are AdS black holes with scalars in the theory, but not scalarized black holes in the usual sense [1911.01950, 2102.04015, 2302.04654, 2301.04784, 2606.08507, 1506.05336, 1003.3232, 1108.1113].

## 1. Conceptual scope and defining distinction

In the spontaneous-scalarization setting, one begins from a bald AdS black hole—typically RNAdS-, Schwarzschild-AdS-, or topological-AdS-like—and finds that the trivial scalar configuration becomes unstable. A new branch with nonzero scalar profile then bifurcates from the bald branch. This pattern appears in asymptotically AdS models with spherical, planar, and hyperbolic horizons, and it is also realized at zero temperature for certain extremal near-horizon geometries [2511.18074, 2203.14388].

The central distinction is between genuine scalar hair and a frozen scalar sector. In the flux-compactification construction of four-dimensional \(\mathcal N=2\) abelian gauged supergravity with one vector multiplet and the universal hypermultiplet, the black-hole analysis imposes the covariantly constant conditions
\[
D_\mu t=0,\qquad D_\mu \xi^0=0,\qquad D_\mu \tilde\xi_0=0,\qquad D_\mu \phi=0,
\]
together with \(dB=0\). The resulting solutions are Schwarzschild–AdS with
\[
q_0=q_1=p^0=p^1=0,
\]
so the electromagnetic invariant \(I_1\) vanishes and no spacetime-dependent scalar profile survives. The solution is therefore an AdS black hole with frozen scalars rather than a scalarized one [1108.1113].

A related but distinct case is the warped-AdS\(_3\) black hole with a “scalar halo.” There the scalar is regular outside and on the non-extremal horizon, but its amplitude is not a freely tunable hair parameter; instead it is fixed by the black-hole parameters and couplings. The term “scalar halo” marks that restricted status [1506.05336].

## 2. Instability mechanisms in AdS

A recurring mechanism is curvature-induced effective mass generation. In the scalar-tensor model with action
\[
S=\int d^4x\,\sqrt{-g}\left[\frac{\mathcal R}{2}-\Lambda+\phi^2(\alpha\mathcal R+\gamma\mathcal G)-\partial_\mu\phi\,\partial^\mu\phi-\frac14 F_{\mu\nu}F^{\mu\nu}\right],
\]
the scalar equation
\[
\square \phi + (\alpha\mathcal R+\gamma\mathcal G)\phi=0
\]
implies an effective mass
\[
m_{\rm eff}^2=-(\alpha\mathcal R+\gamma\mathcal G).
\]
Scalarization requires that \(-(\alpha\mathcal R+\gamma\mathcal G)\) drop below the Breitenlohner–Freedman bound near the horizon while remaining above the bound asymptotically. The same AdS logic appears in Gauss–Bonnet models, where the curvature invariant itself generates the effective tachyonic channel [1911.01950, 2301.04784, 2606.08507].

In Einstein–Maxwell-scalar models, the driving term comes from the Maxwell sector. For the nonminimal coupling \(f(\phi)=e^{\alpha\phi^2}\) or \(\mathcal G(\varphi)=e^{\alpha\varphi^2}\), the linearized scalar equation around RNAdS yields
\[
\mu_{\rm eff}^2=-\frac{\alpha Q^2}{r^4}.
\]
Near the horizon, where \(r\) is smallest, this becomes sufficiently negative to trigger a tachyonic instability when it crosses the AdS\(_4\) BF bound
\[
\mu_{\rm BF}^2=-\frac{9}{4L^2}.
\]
This is the basic onset mechanism for both spherical and planar scalarized charged AdS black holes [2102.04015, 2302.04654].

A different route is superradiant condensation in global AdS\(_5\). For a charged scalar mode of energy \(\omega\), superradiance occurs when
\[
\omega < e\mu.
\]
With a massless scalar, the lowest normal mode has \(\Delta_0=4\), so the instability condition becomes
\[
e\mu \ge 4.
\]
The end point is a hairy black hole consisting, at leading order, of a small RNAdS core immersed in a charged scalar condensate filling the AdS “box” [1003.3232].

These mechanisms all share one AdS-specific feature: a negative local effective mass is not sufficient by itself. The asymptotic AdS region imposes BF stability and normalizability constraints, so the scalarized branch must interpolate between a destabilized near-horizon region and a stable asymptotic vacuum [1911.01950, 2606.08507].

## 3. Theoretical realizations and representative solution families

One major class consists of four-dimensional EMS models with a real scalar nonminimally coupled to the Maxwell invariant. For spherical symmetry, a standard ansatz is
\[
ds^2=-N(r)e^{-2\delta(r)}dt^2+\frac{dr^2}{N(r)}+r^2 d\Omega_2^2,\qquad A_\mu dx^\mu=V(r)\,dt,\qquad \phi=\phi(r),
\]
with RNAdS recovered at \(\phi=0\). The scalarized branch then deforms \(N(r)\), \(\delta(r)\), \(V(r)\), and \(\phi(r)\) self-consistently [2102.04015].

The planar EMS construction uses
\[
ds^2=-N(r)e^{-2\delta(r)}dt^2+N(r)^{-1}dr^2+\frac{r^2}{L^2}(dx^2+dy^2),
\]
together with \(A_\mu=\{V(r),0,0,0\}\) and \(\varphi=\phi(r)\). The scalarized planar solutions exist only in a bounded region of the \((\alpha,q)\) plane, where \(q=Q/M\), and bifurcate from a planar RN-AdS-like background [2302.04654].

Another major class is Einstein-scalar-Gauss–Bonnet and Einstein-Maxwell-scalar-Gauss–Bonnet gravity. In the ESGB model, the action
\[
S_{\rm ESGBC}=\frac{1}{16 \pi}\int d^4 x\sqrt{-g}\left( R-2\Lambda-2\partial_\mu \phi \partial^\mu \phi + \frac{\lambda^2\phi^2}{2} R^2_{\rm GB}\right)
\]
supports scalarized Schwarzschild-AdS solutions. In the EMsGB model with
\[
f(\phi)=\frac{\eta}{2}\phi^2,
\]
charged RN-AdS black holes can scalarize through the Gauss–Bonnet invariant \(\mathcal G\), with the sign and magnitude of \(\eta\) selecting the GB\(^+\) or GB\(^-\) channel [2301.04784, 2606.08507].

At zero temperature, extremal electrically charged black holes in \(D\ge 4\) can scalarize in Einstein–Maxwell theory coupled to a complex scalar written in Stueckelberg form,
\[
\mathcal L_S=-\frac12(\partial\Psi)^2-\frac12 P(\Psi)(\partial\sigma-A)^2 - V(\Psi),
\]
with
\[
P(\Psi)=\Psi^2+\frac{a}{4}\Psi^4,\qquad V(\Psi)=\frac12 m^2\Psi^2+\frac{b}{4}\Psi^4.
\]
Near criticality, the horizon physics depends only on the effective interaction
\[
\mathbf c := a m^2 - 2b.
\]
This identifies a zero-temperature scalarization channel tied to the entropy-function and attractor framework [2203.14388].

Lower- and higher-dimensional realizations broaden the scope. In three dimensions, warped-AdS\(_3\) black holes with scalar halo arise in Einstein gravity with a real scalar and Horndeski-type derivative coupling
\[
I=\int d^3x\,\sqrt{-g}\left[ \frac{1}{2}\left(R-2\Lambda\right) -\frac{\eta}{2}\,g^{\mu\nu}\partial_\mu\phi\,\partial_\nu\phi +\frac{\beta}{2}\,G^{\mu\nu}\partial_\mu\phi\,\partial_\nu\phi \right].
\]
In global AdS\(_5\), small charged hairy black holes arise in Einstein–Maxwell theory with a charged, massless, minimally coupled scalar and are constructed perturbatively in the black-hole radius and hair amplitude [1506.05336, 1003.3232].

## 4. AdS asymptotics, normalizability, and holographic data

Because the scalarized solutions live in AdS, asymptotic falloffs are part of the definition of the branch. In the scalar-tensor model with \(\phi^2(\alpha\mathcal R+\gamma\mathcal G)\), the scalar behaves near the boundary as
\[
\phi(r\to\infty)\to \phi_+\, r^{-\lambda_+}+\phi_-\, r^{-\lambda_-},
\]
with the exponents controlled by
\[
\Delta=9+48\alpha+32\gamma\Lambda.
\]
The dual operator dimension is \(\lambda_+\), and setting \(\phi_-=0\) identifies \(\phi_+\) as the expectation value of the dual operator. The condition \(\Delta\ge 0\) is simultaneously the condition that the asymptotic scalar falloff be real and that the AdS vacuum remain stable [1911.01950].

In the spherical and planar EMS models, the scalar is also imposed to be source free at infinity. The asymptotic expansions take the form
\[
\phi=\frac{\phi_+}{r^3}+\cdots
\]
for the spherical case and
\[
\phi=\frac{\phi_f}{r^3}+\cdots
\]
for the planar case, with the corresponding gauge potential approaching
\[
V=\Phi+\frac{Q}{r}+\cdots.
\]
These falloffs are consistent with normalizable AdS behavior and permit direct thermodynamic comparison with the bald branch at fixed charge or fixed potential [2102.04015, 2302.04654].

In EMsGB gravity, the asymptotic scalar behaves as
\[
\phi(r)\sim \phi_{1\infty}r^{-\Delta_-}+\phi_{2\infty}r^{-\Delta_+},
\]
with
\[
\Delta_\pm=\frac12\pm\frac12\sqrt{9+8\eta\Lambda}.
\]
Imposing the source-free condition \(\phi_{1\infty}=0\) makes the hair secondary. The BF condition
\[
9+8\eta\Lambda\ge 0
\]
then bounds the allowed coupling region; for \(\Lambda=-0.5\), this requires \(\eta\le 2.25\) [2606.08507].

The holographic interpretation is most explicit in models where the condensate is read directly from the AdS falloff. In the planar EMS setting, the radial direction is interpreted as RG flow from UV to IR, and the scalar condensate develops in the deep interior at low temperature while vanishing at the boundary. In the scalar-tensor model, the condensate \(\phi_+\) plays the role of a real-valued order parameter in the boundary theory [2302.04654, 1911.01950].

## 5. Topology, extremality, and branch structure

Topology strongly affects scalarization. In the extremal Stueckelberg-Higgs model, the near-horizon geometry is
\[
AdS_2\times \Sigma_k,
\]
and scalarization occurs only for non-planar horizons,
\[
k=\pm 1,
\]
with AdS mass windows
\[
1<\varkappa m^2 < \frac{D-2}{D-3}\qquad (k=1,\ \Lambda<0),
\]
and
\[
0<\varkappa m^2<1\qquad (k=-1,\ \Lambda<0).
\]
The hairy branch appears at a critical charge \(Q_c\) when the effective interaction satisfies \(\mathbf c>\mathbf c_0>0\), and the order parameter scales as
\[
u\sim |Q-Q_c|^{1/2}.
\]
This makes the extremal transition second order in the entropy representation [2203.14388].

At finite temperature, topological AdS black holes also scalarize. In the extended-phase-space study with spherical, planar, and hyperbolic horizons, scalarization is a universal low-temperature phenomenon for all three topologies. The spherical case is distinguished by a scalarization domain that theoretically extends to much higher temperatures under low pressure and by a richer branch structure even when \(\lambda=0\). Increasing pressure drives the condensate behavior through first-order-style and cave-of-wind regimes and toward a supercritical regime [2511.18074].

The planar EMS case provides a complementary finite-temperature example. There, the scalarized solutions occupy a bounded domain in the \((\alpha,q)\) plane, bounded by the bifurcation line, the critical line, and the extremal line. Scalarized and scalar-free planar RN-AdS black holes coexist between the bifurcation line and the extremal line, and the domain grows as \(\alpha\) increases [2302.04654].

Extremality can also obstruct regular hair. In the \(\phi^2(\alpha\mathcal R+\gamma\mathcal G)\) scalar-tensor model, extremal black holes with \(AdS_2\times S^2\) near-horizon geometry cannot support regular scalar fields on the horizon; analytically, the near-horizon scalar derivative diverges, and numerically the backreacted scalarized branches terminate before \(T=0\). This obstruction is model dependent rather than universal, since the zero-temperature extremal Stueckelberg-Higgs model does admit scalarization under the conditions above [1911.01950, 2203.14388].

AdS asymptotics also reshape the branch counting familiar from asymptotically flat scalarization. In charged EMsGB AdS black holes, the BF-safe window supports only the single fundamental branch \(n=0\) for GB\(^+\) scalarization, while the next excited branch appears only beyond the BF-safe regime; GB\(^-\) scalarization likewise yields a single branch. This directly contradicts the infinite-branch expectation carried over from asymptotically flat cases [2606.08507].

## 6. Thermodynamics, phase structure, and limiting cases

Thermodynamics is one of the principal diagnostics of scalarized AdS black holes. In the scalar-tensor model with \(\phi^2(\alpha\mathcal R+\gamma\mathcal G)\), fixing \(\phi_-=0\) and including backreaction yields a holographic phase transition in which
\[
(\phi_+)^{1/\lambda_+}\sim \sqrt{1-T/T_c},
\]
and nontrivial condensates exist for \(\mu\ge \mu_c\). The condensate increases as temperature decreases, and the bulk scalarization is interpreted as the dual of a second-order phase transition with a real order parameter [1911.01950].

For scalarized planar EMS black holes, the dynamical and thermodynamic analyses align. The quasinormal-mode calculation finds no evidence of unstable modes on the scalarized branch in the parameter range studied, while both the grand canonical and canonical ensembles favor the scalarized black hole below the transition temperature \(T_B\). The transition is second order: the free energy is continuous, the heat capacity is discontinuous at \(T=T_B\), and the horizon scalar turns on continuously from zero. The paper explicitly compares this pattern to a conductor-superconductor transition [2302.04654].

The spherical EMS system exhibits a richer canonical phase structure. In the microcanonical ensemble, scalarized black holes are always entropically preferred over RNAdS when both exist. In the canonical ensemble, however, sufficiently large charge produces a reentrant sequence
\[
\text{RNAdS BH}\;\to\;\text{scalarized BH}\;\to\;\text{RNAdS BH},
\]
composed of a zeroth-order transition followed by a second-order one. This places scalarized AdS black holes within the broader AdS phase-transition taxonomy rather than isolating them as a single universal pattern [2102.04015].

In extremal scalarization, entropy rather than free energy is the natural thermodynamic potential. The Stueckelberg-Higgs model shows a continuous entropy and first derivative across the transition, with a discontinuity in \(S''(Q)\), again indicating second order. In global AdS\(_5\), small hairy black holes have higher entropy than the corresponding RNAdS black holes of the same mass and charge whenever both exist, and the microcanonical diagram displays a second-order transition between RNAdS and hairy phases. The lower edge of the hairy band is a regular soliton interpreted as a nonlinear Bose condensate [2203.14388, 1003.3232].

Curvature-induced scalarization in EMsGB AdS gravity leads to the same qualitative conclusion. With fixed charge, the Gibbs free energy
\[
G=\mathcal{M}-TS
\]
of the scalarized branch lies below that of RN-AdS, and the transition is second order because the branch emerges smoothly from the bald solution without a swallowtail or discontinuous jump in \(G\). By contrast, the frozen-scalar Schwarzschild–AdS solutions in \(\mathcal N=2\) gauged supergravity remain uncharged and non-supersymmetric unless they degenerate to the AdS vacuum; they exemplify a no-hair or frozen-scalar outcome, and the construction explicitly remarks that genuinely charged AdS black holes would require relaxing the covariantly constant condition and allowing nonconstant fields [2606.08507, 1108.1113].

Taken together, these results show that “scalarized AdS black holes” are not a single model but a class of hairy AdS solutions organized by instability mechanism, asymptotic BF constraints, horizon topology, and ensemble dependence. The common structure is the emergence of a nontrivial scalar branch from a bald AdS background; the main exceptions are precisely those cases in which the scalar sector is present but dynamically frozen.

Source: https://www.emergentmind.com/topics/scalarized-ads-black-holes