---
title: Partially Pinned Solids Overview
url: https://www.emergentmind.com/topics/partially-pinned-solid
type: topic
---

# Partially Pinned Solids Overview

“Partially pinned solid” is a field-dependent term for a state in which pinning constrains only part of the relevant degrees of freedom, leaving a complementary sector mobile, deformable, or dynamically reconfigurable. In atomistic glasses it usually denotes an amorphous solid with a fraction \(c\) of particles immobilized during nonaffine relaxation; in driven dusty plasmas it denotes the disordered plastic-flow regime between fully pinned and fully moving states; in semi-solid membrane models it denotes coexistence of finite shear rigidity and finite lateral diffusivity; in droplet evaporation it denotes a sessile droplet with a mobile contact line; and in dislocation and Wigner-solid problems it denotes solids where only part of the defect or electronic structure is pinned by obstacles or disorder [1903.03020] [2207.11342] [2404.12211] [2511.06691] [1002.0422] [2402.05456].

## 1. Definitions and scope

Across the literature, the phrase does not identify a single microscopic object. It instead labels a family of constrained many-body states in which pinning introduces an additional quenched length, force, or time scale while preserving some mobile response. The corresponding control parameters vary by system: the pinned-particle fraction \(c\) in amorphous solids, the mismatch ratio \(\rho=w/b\) and substrate depth \(U_0\) in driven dusty plasmas, the solid-node area fraction \(\Phi\) in semi-solid membranes, the pinning fraction \(x\) in partly pinned fluids, and defect density or carrier density in dislocation and Wigner-solid problems [1903.03020] [2207.11342] [2404.12211] [1006.4821] [2402.05456].

| Domain | Meaning of “partially pinned” | Main control variable(s) |
|---|---|---|
| Amorphous solids | Random fraction of particles pinned during relaxation | \(c\), \(\gamma\), \(\rho\) |
| Dusty plasma | Mixed plastic-flow state with pinned and flowing particles | \(U_0\), \(\rho=w/b\), \(F_d\) |
| Semi-solid membrane | \( \mu>0 \) and \( D>0 \) coexist | \(\Phi\), \(K\) |
| Sessile droplets | Contact line recedes during evaporation | \(R(t)\), \(\theta(t)\), \(L/d\) |
| Partly pinned fluids | Frozen subset of an equilibrium parent fluid | \(x\) |
| Dislocations / Wigner solids | Pinned defect or electronic substructures coexist with mobile ones | \(\tau_\Gamma/\tau_p\), carrier density |

A recurrent distinction is between complete pinning, where the relevant coordinate is fixed for most of the process, and partial pinning, where only a subset is immobilized or where pinning competes with mobility. In several settings this competition yields mixed states: localized and extended plasticity in glasses, trapped wells and flowing channels in dusty plasmas, solid-like and fluid-like modes in membranes, or pinned crystalline domains embedded in a liquid background in Wigner systems. This suggests a unifying operational definition: partial pinning is a constrained state in which quenched anchors modify collective organization without completely eliminating motion.

## 2. Amorphous solids under shear and tension

In model glasses, a partially pinned solid is constructed by randomly selecting a fraction \(c\) of particles and allowing them to undergo the imposed affine deformation while keeping them fixed during the subsequent energy minimization. This protocol was studied in two-dimensional and three-dimensional Kob–Andersen binary Lennard-Jones glasses under athermal quasistatic loading, with typical strain increments \(\delta\gamma=5\times10^{-5}\) or \(1\times10^{-5}\), and with pinned particles chosen so that close contacts are avoided under affine shear [1903.03020] [1808.09723].

The yielding problem was recast as a disorder-influenced spinodal for an overlap-based order parameter. For replicas \(a,b\), the local overlap is
\[
u_i^{ab}\equiv \theta(\ell-|r_i^a-r_i^b|),
\qquad
Q_{ab}\equiv \frac{1}{N}\sum_{i=1}^N \theta(\ell-|r_i^a-r_i^b|),
\]
with \(\ell=0.35\). The relevant correlator is
\[
G_L(r)\equiv 2G_R(r)-\Gamma_2(r),
\]
and near yielding it is assumed to take the critical form
\[
G_L(r)\sim \frac{e^{-r/\xi}}{r^{d-2+\eta}}.
\]
Its susceptibility obeys
\[
\chi_L\propto \int_0^L dr\, r^{1-\eta}e^{-r/\xi}.
\]
Without pinning, the correlation length grows up to the system size, so \(\chi_{\rm peak}\propto L^{2-\eta}\). With pinning, the growth of \(\xi\) is cut off by the mean pinned-particle spacing
\[
\ell_p\sim (c\rho)^{-1/d},
\qquad
\xi\lesssim \ell_p,
\]
and the peak susceptibility saturates rather than diverging:
\[
\chi_{\rm peak}=A(c)-e^{-L/\ell_p}\ell_p^{2-\eta}L^{1-\eta}+O(\ell_p/L).
\]
This is the central argument that particle pinning suppresses the critical spinodal associated with shear-banding instability [1903.03020].

At the macroscopic level, random pinning stiffens the glass, shifts the yield strain to larger values, reduces configurational fluctuations, and replaces system-spanning avalanches with localized rearrangements. In steady flow, the unpinned system recovers the benchmark scaling \(\langle\Delta\sigma\rangle\sim N^{-2/3}\), whereas increasing \(c\) drives the exponent \(\beta\) toward \(\approx -1.0\) in \(2d\) and to somewhat below \(-0.8\) in \(3d\), consistent with a crossover from sub-extensive avalanches to nearly intensive events. Around \(c\approx 0.10\) in \(2d\), the large-\(S\) hump in the cluster-size distribution disappears, finite-size dependence becomes negligible, and local-overlap maps show homogeneous proliferation of localized relaxation without shear bands [1808.09723].

The same logic extends to cavitation-driven fracture under athermal quasistatic expansion. There, pinning fractions \(c=0.01\)–\(0.05\) increase the sustainable hydrostatic tension, shift cavitation to lower density, flatten susceptibility peaks, and transform a dominant cavity into many small cavities. The lowest nonzero Hessian eigenvalue still vanishes with saddle-node form,
\[
\lambda_{\min}\sim \sqrt{\frac{\rho-\rho_c}{\rho_c}},
\]
but the associated plastic eigenmode becomes screened:
\[
e(r)\sim \frac{e^{-r/\xi}}{r^\eta}
\quad\text{or}\quad
e(r)\sim e^{-r/\xi},
\]
with \(\xi_{\rm fit}\) tracking the inclusion spacing \(\xi_{\rm pin}\approx \sqrt{1/(c\rho)}\). The resulting intrinsic plasticity length removes strong system-size effects and homogenizes damage [2306.05348].

Under oscillatory AQS shear, random pinning also changes the glass-forming character. In the three-dimensional Kob–Andersen model, the kinetic fragility \(K_{VFT}\) decreases from \(\approx 0.258\) at \(\rho_{\rm pin}=0\) to \(\approx 0.036\) at \(\rho_{\rm pin}=0.20\); in two dimensions it decreases from \(\approx 0.074\) to \(\approx 0.025\) at \(\rho_{\rm pin}=0.10\). The yielding amplitude rises from \(\gamma_c\approx 0.075\) in poorly annealed unpinned \(3d\) samples to \(\gamma_y\approx 0.15\) at \(\rho_{\rm pin}=0.20\), while large-\(N\) visualizations show that shear bands present in unpinned systems disappear in pinned ones. The transient cycle count to steady state diverges near yield and scales as \(\tau\propto N_{\rm transient}^{\beta}\), with \(\beta\approx 0.70\) in \(3d\) and \(\beta\approx 0.45\) in \(2d\) [2411.03874].

## 3. Driven periodic media and depinning

In periodically modulated driven media, “partially pinned solid” can refer either to an intermediate dynamical state or to a symmetry-broken ordered phase. For a two-dimensional Yukawa dusty plasma driven across a triangular substrate, the partially pinned state is the disordered plastic-flow regime between the fully pinned and moving ordered limits. The dynamics obey the underdamped Langevin equation
\[
m\ddot{\mathbf r}_i
=
-\sum_{j\neq i}\nabla_i V_{\rm int}(|\mathbf r_i-\mathbf r_j|)
-\nabla_i V_{\rm sub}(\mathbf r_i)
-\nu m\dot{\mathbf r}_i
+\boldsymbol\xi_i(t)
+\mathbf F_d,
\]
with Yukawa interparticle interactions and a triangular periodic substrate of depth \(U_0\). The state is identified by intermediate mobility
\[
\mu=\frac{\nu m V_x}{F_d},
\]
nonzero but sublinear transport, reduced sixfold coordination \(P_6\), and a broadened \(g(x,y)\). Using the criterion \(\mu<0.1\) for pinning, the underdense system at \(\rho=0.89\) has an Aubry threshold \(U_c\approx 0.007\,E_0\): for \(U_0<U_c\), \(F_{\rm crit}=0\) and superlubricity holds; for \(U_0>U_c\), a pinned \(\rightarrow\) plastic \(\rightarrow\) moving-ordered sequence appears. At \(U_0=0.01\,E_0\), \(\mu\approx 0\) at small drive, rises sharply to \(\mu\approx 0.3\) at \(F_d\approx 0.0009\,F_0\), and approaches \(1\) for \(F_d\gtrsim 0.01\,F_0\) [2207.11342].

A different usage appears in a vortex lattice on a square pinning array at filling ratio \(1\). There the partially pinned solid is an equilibrium low-temperature crystal that breaks the substrate’s fourfold symmetry: vortices sit off-center within each pin square so that only one of the substrate reciprocal vectors is retained. Its defining structural signature is the absence of the pure \(y\)-component Bragg peak \(G_y=(2\pi/d)\hat y\), while \(G_1=(2\pi/d)\hat x\) and \(G_2=(\pi/d)\hat x+(2\pi/d)\hat y\) remain present. This state exhibits strong transport anisotropy, with depinning thresholds \(F_c^e\simeq 0.86\,F_b\) along the easy direction, \(F_c^d\simeq 1.1\,F_b\) along the diagonal, and \(F_c^\perp\simeq 31\,F_b\) perpendicular to the easy direction. For drives well above threshold, the average velocity shows a minimum near melting, at \(T_c\simeq 0.7\,T_0\) for easy-axis drive and \(T_c\simeq 0.14\,T_0\) for diagonal drive, an analogue of the peak effect [2008.06018].

These two usages are related but not identical. In the dusty-plasma problem, partial pinning is a heterogeneous transport regime with trapped and mobile particles. In the vortex problem, it is a symmetry-broken solid phase whose anisotropic motion emerges from the missing reciprocal vector. The shared feature is that pinning does not simply arrest all motion; it selectively reorganizes collective pathways.

## 4. Soft-matter, statistical-mechanical, and interfacial realizations

A semi-solid membrane provides a distinct realization of partial pinning. The membrane is modeled as a fluctuating randomly triangulated mesh with solid nodes of fixed connectivity and fluid nodes that can undergo bond flips. All solid nodes are then pinned to their initial in-plane positions by
\[
E_p=\sum_{i\in s}\frac{K}{2}|X_i-X_i^0|^2,
\]
with \(K=200\). Transport is characterized by the mean-squared displacement \(\langle \Delta r^2(t)\rangle\), which evolves from diffusion to subdiffusion and then localization as the solid-node area fraction \(\Phi\) increases; the localization threshold is \(\Phi_c\approx 0.22\)–\(0.23\). Pinning shifts the onset of rigidity to much lower \(\Phi\): \(\mu(\Phi)>0\) already for \(\Phi\gtrsim 0.04\), while the long-time diffusivity \(D(\Phi)\) is unchanged within error bars. The resulting coexistence window \(0.04<\Phi<0.20\) defines a partially pinned solid with non-zero shear modulus and non-zero lateral diffusivity. By contrast, the bending modulus extracted from
\[
S(q)=\langle |h_q|^2\rangle=\frac{A k_B T}{\kappa q^4+\sigma q^2}
\]
remains unchanged [2404.12211].

In jammed particulate matter, pins act as fixed force centers that scaffold contact networks. For bidisperse frictionless soft discs with harmonic repulsion, the low-density shift of the jamming threshold is universal:
\[
\phi_c(0)-\phi_c(\alpha)=m\alpha,
\]
with slope \(m\approx 0.11\) from random pins, while standard near-jamming scalings remain intact:
\[
p\sim \Delta\phi,\qquad
\Delta Z\sim p^{1/2},\qquad
B\sim p^0,\qquad
G\sim \sqrt p.
\]
At higher pin density, bond-orientational order appears, force distributions broaden toward heavier tails, and square pin lattices develop cubic elastic anisotropy through a Zener ratio \(a_r=G_1/G_2\) that tracks the growth of \(m_4\) [2205.14787].

In homogeneous partly pinned fluids, the matrix is created by freezing a random fraction \(x\) of an equilibrium parent fluid or one component of an equilibrium binary mixture. Because the matrix is prepared in equilibrium with the adsorbed fluid, a complementarity identity holds:
\[
\overline{\langle A(\mathbf x;\mathbf m,\mathbf f)\rangle}
=
\langle A(\mathbf x;\mathbf m,\mathbf f)\rangle_{\rm bulk}.
\]
For disconnected averages,
\[
\overline{\langle A\rangle\langle B\rangle}
=
\overline{\langle A(\mathbf m,\mathbf f)\,B(\mathbf m,\mathbf t)\rangle}',
\]
so fluid-template correlations replace difficult quenched products. In random pinning,
\[
g_{mm}(r)=g_{mf}(r)=g_{ff}(r)=g(r)
\]
exactly, and the small-\(x\) disconnected correlations obey
\[
h_{\rm dis}(r)=x\rho\,(h\otimes h)(r)+O((x\rho)^2).
\]
The corresponding homogeneous lattice gas maps directly onto a random-field Ising model with a strongly asymmetric bimodal field [1006.4821] [1405.2715].

An interfacial usage appears in sessile droplet evaporation. There, partial pinning means that the contact line is mobile: on PTFE, pure-water droplets show an initial constant-contact-radius stage up to roughly \(t/t_e\approx 0.2\), then a constant-contact-angle stage, and finally a mixed mode in which both \(R\) and \(\theta\) decrease. In multi-droplet arrays with spacing ratio \(L/d=1.2\), central-droplet lifetime increases from \(1900\pm 28\) s for an isolated partially pinned droplet to \(3600\pm 120\) s in a five-droplet configuration, a relative increase of \(89\%\). The coupled diffusion-cooling model uses
\[
\dot M_{\rm iso}
=
\pi R D_v M_w\,[C_s(T_d)-H C_s(T_\infty)]\,g(\theta)
\]
together with a suppression matrix
\[
\psi_{ij}
=
\begin{cases}
1,& i=j,\\[4pt]
\dfrac{2}{\pi}\arcsin\!\left(\dfrac{R_i}{D_{ij}}\right),& i\neq j,
\end{cases}
\]
and predicts central-droplet lifetimes with maximum deviation \(\approx 12\%\) by Method 1 and \(\approx 7\%\) by Method 2 [2511.06691].

## 5. Crystalline defects, partial pinning of dislocations, and elastic-wave transport

In crystalline plasticity, a partially pinned solid is one in which some dislocations are pinned at obstacles while others remain mobile. A pinned segment between obstacles behaves as a damped string under static shear load. The governing equation is
\[
M\frac{\partial^2 y}{\partial t^2}
+
B\frac{\partial y}{\partial t}
-
T\frac{\partial^2 y}{\partial x^2}
=
\tau b.
\]
Molecular-dynamics simulations for an edge dislocation in b.c.c. molybdenum pinned by a nanovoid showed free inertial oscillations after pinning, rather than forced oscillations. The extracted effective mass per unit length is
\[
M_{\rm eff}=3.6\times 10^{-16}\ {\rm kg/m},
\]
and the dominant oscillation frequency decreases from \(117.2\) GHz at \(l=6.9\) nm to \(62.5\) GHz at \(l=16.9\) nm. The anomalous frequency-length relation is resolved by replacing rigid ends with flexible boundary conditions,
\[
2Tp\tan\!\left(\frac{pl}{2}\right)=k,
\]
with fitted stiffness \(k\approx 15.4\ {\rm N/m}\) [1002.0422].

For extended dislocations split into two partials, partial pinning requires comparing the pinning stress of each partial with the stress scale associated with the stacking fault. The equilibrium separation is
\[
d_0=\frac{C_\Gamma \mu b_p^2}{\Gamma_{\rm SF}},
\]
and the associated coupling stress is
\[
\tau_\Gamma=\frac{2\Gamma_{\rm SF}}{b}
=
\frac{C_\Gamma \mu b_p}{d_0}.
\]
The elastic-manifold pinning stress of a partial is
\[
\tau_p=\tau_c=C_\tau(\theta)\,\langle \tau^2\rangle^{2/3}\mu^{1/3}.
\]
If \(\tau_\Gamma/\tau_p\lesssim 1\), the two partials pin largely independently and the stacking-fault width evolves as
\[
\frac{d(\tau)}{d_0}
=
\frac{1}{1+(\tau_c-\tau)/\tau_\Gamma}.
\]
If \(\tau_\Gamma/\tau_p\gg 1\), the extended dislocation is pinned and depins coherently as a whole. In equiatomic FeNiCr, atomistic analysis gives \(\tau_c\approx 480\) MPa, while constrained pinning yields a Larkin length \(L_p\approx 20\) nm and can increase the effective pinning stress by about a factor of five at \(L\approx 1\) nm [2110.12507].

Pinned dislocations also control wave transport. In a continuum with a random distribution of pinned edge-dislocation segments, each segment acts as a dynamical scatterer with fundamental frequency
\[
\omega_F=\frac{\pi}{L}\sqrt{\frac{\Gamma}{m}}.
\]
The single-segment Born series is geometric, so the all-orders T-matrix takes the closed form \(T=T^{(1)}/(1+\mathcal A I)\), and in the independent scattering approximation the coherent self-energy is \(\Sigma=n\langle T\rangle\). At low frequency the divergent real part is renormalizable to zero; at higher frequency a cutoff \(\Lambda=d\omega_1\) tied to the segment length is required [1505.07721]. At the level of intensity transport, the Bethe–Salpeter equation and Ward–Takahashi identity yield a diffusion pole
\[
\Phi(\mathbf q,\Omega)\propto \frac{1}{-i\Omega+Dq^2},
\]
with a diffusion constant that depends on the bare \(c_L,c_T\), the renormalized coherent velocities and attenuation lengths, the segment density \(n\), and the resonance structure of the string. The low-density limit recovers equipartition,
\[
\frac{\mathcal E_T}{\mathcal E_L}=2\gamma^3,
\qquad
\gamma=\frac{c_L}{c_T},
\]
but equipartition does not generally survive when resonant dislocation dynamics is important [2204.05140].

## 6. Quantum and electronic solids

In lowest-Landau-level electron systems near \(\nu=1/3\) and \(\nu=1\), partial pinning refers to weak-disorder-induced mixing of nearby many-body states with different total angular momentum. In the rotating-and-vibrating electron-molecule formulation,
\[
\Phi_L^{\rm RVEM}
=
\Phi_{\mathcal L}^{\rm REM}(n_1,\ldots,n_r)\,Q[\Lambda]\,|0\rangle,
\qquad
L=\mathcal L+\Lambda,
\]
with allowed magic angular momenta
\[
L_m=L_0+\sum_q n_q k_q,
\qquad
L_0=\frac{N(N-1)}{2}.
\]
Weak pinning mixes symmetry-conserving eigenstates,
\[
|\Psi_{\rm pin}\rangle
=
\alpha |\Psi_{L_1}\rangle + \beta e^{i\theta} |\Psi_{L_2}\rangle,
\]
so that the density acquires an interference term and develops molecular-crystallite peaks. For \(N=6\), the superposition \((|L=45\rangle+|L=50\rangle)/\sqrt2\) produces a \([1,5]\) crystallite, while \((|L=45\rangle+|L=51\rangle)/\sqrt2\) produces a \([0,6]\) crystallite. At exact \(\nu=1/3\), the gap to neighboring states is larger and suppresses pinning; away from exact filling, weak disorder can overcome the reduced gap and stabilize pinned Wigner crystallites [1111.0019].

A direct experimental realization of a partially pinned Wigner solid was reported in bilayer MoSe\(_2\) at \(T=5.4\) K using non-invasive STM imaging. At low hole density, the system forms a triangular Wigner solid fragmented into nanocrystalline domains pinned by charged defects. A Voronoi analysis of \(237\) holes found \(151\) hexagonal, \(44\) pentagonal, and \(41\) heptagonal cells, with pentagon-heptagon pairs forming defect lines. As the density increases, holes are added in discrete local densification steps, and above
\[
p\approx 5.7\times 10^{12}\ {\rm cm}^{-2}
\]
the solid begins to melt locally, producing a mixed state of pinned solid domains and liquid bubbles. By
\[
p\approx 7.0\times 10^{12}\ {\rm cm}^{-2},
\]
the liquid regions form an apparent percolation network, while the average local densities in liquid and solid regions agree within \(2\%\) experimental uncertainty. The data are therefore consistent with a disorder-pinned microemulsion rather than simple long-range density inhomogeneity [2402.05456].

Taken together, these usages show that partial pinning is best understood not as a unique phase but as a constrained-state concept. The pinned sector may be particles, contact lines, membrane nodes, defects, dislocation segments, or electronic domains; the mobile sector may remain diffusive, plastic, liquid-like, or weakly crystalline. What pinning adds, in every case represented here, is an externally imposed scale—\(\ell_p\), \(L_p\), \(d_0\), \(U_c\), \(F_{\rm crit}\), or a coexistence window in density or strain—that limits collective organization, reshapes transport and failure, and often replaces system-spanning rearrangements by localized or mixed-state dynamics.

Source: https://www.emergentmind.com/topics/partially-pinned-solid