---
title: Hybrid-Order Topological Superconductors
url: https://www.emergentmind.com/topics/hybrid-order-topological-superconductors
type: topic
---

# Hybrid-Order Topological Superconductors

Searching arXiv for recent and foundational papers on hybrid-order topological superconductors and related higher-order superconducting phases.
arXiv search query: "hybrid-order topological superconductor higher-order topological superconductor Majorana corner hinge modes"
Hybrid-order topological superconductors are superconducting phases in which boundary manifestations of different topological order coexist in a single system. In two dimensions, this usually denotes the simultaneous presence of first-order and second-order boundary modes, such as one-dimensional edge states together with zero-dimensional corner states. In three dimensions, the same term extends to the coexistence of strong topology and higher-order topology, exemplified by Majorana surface cones together with helical hinge modes, and, in gapless settings, to the simultaneous appearance of bulk nodes, surface Majorana arcs, and hinge channels [2604.08675, 1810.12963, 1909.07980]. The concept therefore links gapped and gapless superconductors, static and Floquet systems, and a wide range of hybrid heterostructures.

## 1. Conceptual scope and taxonomy

The literature uses the notion of hybrid order in more than one precise sense. In the square Yu–Shiba–Rusinov network studied in 2026, the phrase refers to a system that simultaneously exhibits first-order edge modes and second-order corner modes, with the boundary content controlled by spectral dissociation between edge and bulk bands rather than by spin–orbit coupling [2604.08675]. In the honeycomb altermagnet–superconductor heterostructure, the same phrase denotes the coexistence of chiral edge modes and Majorana corner modes within one lattice model, with the corner sector appearing in a region where the bulk Chern number is zero and the edges are gapped [2601.05662].

A second usage arises in three-dimensional superconductors with crystalline symmetry. In class DIII systems with four-fold rotation and inversion symmetry, a hybrid case occurs when Majorana surface cones associated with non-trivial strong topology coexist with helical hinge modes associated with higher-order topology [1810.12963]. Closely related gapless generalizations appear in higher-order topological Dirac superconductors and higher-order Weyl superconductors, where the hybrid character is expressed as the simultaneous coexistence of bulk Dirac or Weyl nodes, two-dimensional Majorana Fermi arcs, and one-dimensional hinge Majorana modes [1909.07980].

A third usage is explicitly dynamical. Wu and An introduced a Floquet engineering scheme in an odd-parity superconductor system in which periodic driving generates coexisting gapless chiral edge states and gapped Majorana corner states, either in two different quasienergy gaps or in one single quasienergy gap [2210.12439]. In that setting, hybrid order is not merely a static superposition of boundary states, but a quasienergy-resolved phenomenon.

## 2. Symmetry content and bulk diagnostics

The symmetry class depends on the platform. Two-dimensional magnet–superconductor hybrids, altermagnet heterostructures, and the YSR network are formulated in class D, where particle–hole symmetry is present while time-reversal is broken [2210.15582, 2601.05662, 2604.08675]. Three-dimensional hybrid higher-order superconductors with helical hinges belong to class DIII and additionally require crystalline symmetries such as \(C_4\), \(C_6\), inversion, or their combinations with time-reversal [1810.12963, 1909.07980]. The rotational and inversion constraints are not auxiliary: in the three-dimensional HOTDSC of Wang et al., rotational, spatial inversion, and time-reversal symmetries together protect the coexistence of bulk Dirac nodes and hinge Majorana modes [1909.07980].

Because the boundary structure mixes different codimensions, a single invariant is generally insufficient. First-order sectors are commonly diagnosed by a Chern number,
\[
C=\frac{1}{2\pi i}\int_{\rm BZ} d^2k\;
\mathrm{Tr}\Bigl[P_k[\partial_{k_x}P_k,\partial_{k_y}P_k]\Bigr],
\]
which identifies chiral Majorana edge phases in class D [2210.15582]. Weak first-order topology in the spin-polarized, spin–orbit–free YSR network is instead characterized by Pfaffian-based \(\mathbb Z_2\) indicators,
\[
(-1)^{v_{x,\pi}}=s_{(\pi/\ell,0)}\,s_{(\pi/\ell,\pi/\ell)},\qquad
(-1)^{v_{y,\pi}}=s_{(0,\pi/\ell)}\,s_{(\pi/\ell,\pi/\ell)},
\]
with \(v_{x,\pi}=1\) or \(v_{y,\pi}=1\) implying protected Majorana edge pairs on the corresponding edges [2604.08675].

Second-order sectors are diagnosed by bulk quantities that encode corner or hinge responses. In the magnet/\(d\)-wave-superconductor/QSHI heterostructure, the higher-order bulk topology is captured by the quadrupolar winding number
\[
Q=\frac{1}{2\pi i}\oint_C d^2k\,
\mathrm{Tr}[q^{-1}(k)\partial_k q(k)],
\]
with \(Q=1\) corresponding to four Majorana corner modes and \(Q=2\) to eight corner modes [2505.05222]. In the staggered-flux antiferromagnetic model of Xiao et al., a quadrupole moment \(Q_{xy}\in\{0,\tfrac12\}\) identifies the two-dimensional second-order phase [2510.14216]. In the class-DIII hybrid higher-order case, the strong invariant
\[
N=\frac12\sum_s \mathrm{sgn}(\delta_s)\,C_s
\]
is supplemented by \(k_z\)-resolved higher-order indicators \(\nu_n^{(i)}\), permitting a decomposition in which a surface cone can appear at one \(k_z\) slice while hinge modes occur at another [1810.12963].

Floquet systems require yet another layer of diagnostics. Wu and An use a dynamical winding invariant \(\mathcal V_{\alpha/T}\) for chiral edge structure and a winding \(\mathcal W_{\alpha/T}\) for corner structure, with bulk–boundary correspondence stated as: the number of chiral-edge pairs is \(|\mathcal V_{\alpha/T}|\), while the number of corner-pairs is \(2(|\mathcal W_{\alpha/T}|-|\mathcal V_{\alpha/T}|)\) at quasienergy gap \(\alpha/T\) [2210.12439].

## 3. Microscopic routes to hybrid order

Hybrid-order superconductivity is realized through several distinct microscopic design principles.

| Platform | Microscopic ingredients | Boundary content |
|---|---|---|
| YSR square network [2604.08675] | \(s\)-wave pairing, spin-polarized adatoms, no spin–orbit coupling | Weak edge modes and bulk-dissociated corner modes |
| Honeycomb altermagnet heterostructure [2601.05662] | Altermagnetic exchange, Rashba SOC, \(s\)-wave pairing | Chiral edge modes and Majorana corner modes |
| Odd-parity Floquet superconductor [2210.12439] | Inversion-odd pairing plus periodic \(\delta\)-kick | Chiral edge states and corner states in Floquet gaps |
| TI/SC multilayer [2307.13312] | TI layers, induced \(s\)-wave pairing, in-plane Zeeman field | Surface Majorana cones or drumheads with hinge arcs |
| Class-DIII \(C_4\)-symmetric SC [1810.12963] | Even-parity, \(C_4\)-odd pairing on a TI | Majorana surface cone with helical hinge modes |
| HOTDSC / higher-order Weyl SC [1909.07980] | Odd-parity pairing on a Dirac semimetal | Bulk nodes, surface arcs, and hinge Majorana modes |

In adatom-based two-dimensional systems, geometry itself can become a control knob. The YSR network produces a weak topological superconducting phase from overlapping Yu–Shiba–Rusinov states on a square superlattice with spacing \(\ell\gg a\), and by tuning the Fermi energy \(E_F\) it can enter a bulk-dissociated phase in which edge bands detach from the bulk and corner modes emerge below an edge mass gap [2604.08675]. In triangular-lattice magnet–superconductor hybrids, Rashba coupling, \(s\)-wave pairing, and ferromagnetic adatoms generate higher-order phases through the competition between single-chain and double-chain building blocks; this competition is specific to the triangular geometry and is absent for square lattices [2312.03825].

Magnetic texture provides another route. In the magnet/\(d\)-wave-superconductor/QSHI platform, a noncollinear spin texture produces an emergent in-plane Zeeman field and texture-induced spin–orbit terms. The effective Hamiltonian contains the \(\Gamma_3\) Zeeman term together with \(\Gamma_7\), \(\Gamma_8\), and \(\Gamma_9\) texture-induced spin–orbit couplings linear in \(g\cdot k\) and \(g\), enabling tunable Majorana corner multiplicity [2505.05222]. Although that system is formulated as a second-order topological superconductor rather than a hybrid-order one, it clarifies how multiple corner sectors can be controlled within a single hybrid structure.

Crystalline Dirac and Weyl systems realize hybrid order through unconventional pairing. The HOTDSC model employs odd-parity, time-reversal-invariant \(p_z\)- and \(d_{x^2-y^2}+i d_{xy}\)-type pairings on a three-dimensional Dirac semimetal, producing gapped side surfaces with six hinge directions where the pairing gap vanishes [1909.07980]. A related but distinct mechanism appears in a type-II time-reversal-symmetric Weyl semimetal, where self-consistent calculations yield a hybrid pairing of singlet \(s\)-wave and triplet \(p\)-wave and a second-order topological superconducting state with hinge modes; here the term “hybrid” refers to the pairing channel, not to the coexistence of different topological orders [2511.08973].

## 4. Boundary theory and spectral phenomenology

The boundary theory of hybrid-order superconductors is usually formulated in terms of mass inversions on lower-dimensional boundary Hamiltonians. In the magnet/\(d\)-wave-superconductor/QSHI heterostructure, the low-energy edge Hamiltonian has the form
\[
H_{\rm edge}^j=A_j\,\tau_x s_0 + B_j\,\tau_z s_0 + C_j\,\tau_z s_z + D_j\,\tau_x s_z + E_j\,\tau_0 s_x,
\]
and for \(g_x=g_y=g\), \(\lambda_x=\lambda_y=\lambda\), \(k_\parallel=0\), the energies on edges II and IV are
\[
E_{II,IV}=\pm J\pm\frac{\sqrt{\Delta_0^2 m'^2+\lambda^2 g^2 t^2}}{t}.
\]
Gap closing at \(J=\pm[\Delta_0^2m'^2+\lambda^2 g^2 t^2]^{1/2}/t\) produces a sign change of the Dirac mass between adjacent edges, and the Jackiw–Rebbi mechanism localizes Majorana corner modes at the corners [2505.05222].

In the YSR network, hybrid order is tied to spectral dissociation. Phase I is a weak topological superconductor with \(\Delta_b>0\) and \(\delta_{\rm SEB}=0\), so edge bands merge into the bulk. At a critical \(E_F^*\), the bulk gap closes along a nodal line. Beyond that point, \(\Delta_b\) reopens and \(\delta_{\rm SEB}>0\), so the edge bands become spectrally detached from the bulk; in phases III and IV, four bound states then appear below the edge mass gap \(\delta^*\), exponentially localized at the corners [2604.08675]. This boundary phenomenology differs from conventional higher-order Majorana physics: the positive-energy corner eigenvalues \(E_0(L)\) converge rapidly to an \(L\)-independent plateau, rather than showing the exponentially small splitting of true Majorana corner modes.

Three-dimensional hybrid higher-order superconductors add momentum-selective separation between different boundary sectors. In the class-DIII \(C_4\)-symmetric model, numerical diagonalization yields a linearly dispersing Majorana surface cone at \(k_z=0\) and helical hinge states at \(k_z=\pi\); translation invariance along \(z\) then forbids hybridization because the modes are pinned to different momenta [1810.12963]. In the HOTDSC, the projected side-surface pairing gap is
\[
E_{\rm gap}(\theta)=4|\Delta_2\sin 3\theta|,
\]
which vanishes at \(\theta_n=n\pi/3\), producing six one-dimensional Majorana hinge channels [1909.07980]. In the second-order Dirac superconductor phase of the TI/SC multilayer studied by Nakai and Nomura, an in-plane Zeeman field splits a surface Majorana Dirac cone into two zero-energy Majorana points, while a sign change of projected masses on adjoining surfaces generates hinge arcs connecting them [2307.13312].

## 5. Representative realizations and control parameters

The principal control parameters differ across platforms but recur in a recognizable pattern: exchange strength, chemical potential, magnetic texture, crystalline orientation, and periodic driving.

In the magnet/\(d\)-wave-superconductor/QSHI heterostructure, the key knobs are the exchange strength \(J\), the magnetic-texture pitch \(g\), and the intrinsic QSHI spin–orbit coupling \(\lambda\); candidate components include cuprate superconductors, FeSe-derived iron-pnictides, and two-dimensional topological insulators such as HgTe or WTe\(_2\), with Mn, Cr, or Fe adatoms proposed for the magnetic layer [2505.05222]. In the YSR metamaterial, tuning \(E_F\) drives the sequence from a weak TSC to a bulk-dissociated TSC, and proposed realizations include a bottom-up nanotube network on a two-dimensional superconductor and moiré networks in magic-angle bilayer graphene decorated by magnetic impurities [2604.08675].

In the honeycomb altermagnet–superconductor heterostructure, representative calculations use \(t_1=t_3=1\), \(t_2=0.8\), \(\lambda=0.3\), \(\Delta=0.3\), and scan \(\mu\in[-1,1]\), \(J\in[0,1]\), revealing trivial, counter-propagating edge, higher-order, and chiral first-order phases [2601.05662]. In stacked magnetic structures on square or triangular lattices, atomic manipulation of adatom rows or chain terminations changes the effective edge topology and can toggle corner sectors on and off [2210.15582, 2312.03825].

Cuprate-based hybrid structures provide a complementary route to topological superconductivity with unconventional induced pairing. Takei et al. showed that a ballistic planar junction between a high-\(T_c\) cuprate and a metallic ferromagnet can induce chiral \(p_x+ip_y\) pairing on a (100) facet and chiral \(f\)-wave pairing on a (001) facet, while a one-dimensional half-metallic nanowire on a (001) facet realizes a spin-polarized \(p\)-wave wire when the wire axis is aligned with the \(a\)-axis [1206.3226]. These results do not by themselves define a hybrid-order phase, but they identify microscopic ingredients—orientation-sensitive unconventional pairing and hybrid heterostructure design—that reappear in later higher-order and hybrid-order proposals.

Floquet control enlarges the accessible phase space. In the odd-parity model of Wu and An, the driving amplitude \(m\) and frequency \(T^{-1}\) tune the zero and \(\pi\) quasienergy gaps independently, permitting trivial, Chern-superconducting, second-order, and hybrid-order regimes within the same driven system [2210.12439].

## 6. Interpretational issues, disorder, and related distinctions

Several distinctions are essential for interpreting this field correctly. First, hybrid-order topology is not synonymous with higher-order topology. A two-dimensional second-order topological superconductor with corner Majorana modes but no edge sector—such as the tunable magnet/\(d\)-wave-superconductor/QSHI system—belongs to the broader HOTSC family but is not hybrid-order in the strict sense used for coexisting edge and corner topology [2505.05222]. Likewise, a superconducting state with mixed \(s\)- and \(p\)-wave order parameters can be described as having hybrid pairing without being hybrid-order [2511.08973].

Second, zero-energy or near-zero-energy corner signatures are not always decisive evidence for Majorana corner modes. In the honeycomb altermagnet model, vacancies are benign for chiral edge transport but can generate additional low-energy bound states near impurities; the edge modes remain robust even with \(5\)–\(10\%\) random vacancies, whereas corner modes survive only small disorder, \(\lesssim 1\%\), and vacancy-induced states may mimic corner Majorana signals [2601.05662]. In the YSR bulk-dissociated phase, the corner states are localized and in-gap, but their finite-energy saturation with increasing system size distinguishes them from exponentially split Majorana corner zero modes [2604.08675].

Third, hybrid-order phenomena may be static or intrinsically driven. In the odd-parity system analyzed by Wu and An, previous studies found that first- and second-order topologies cannot coexist in one static system due to symmetry constraints, whereas periodic driving generates coexisting chiral edge modes and corner states, including a single-gap hybrid phase [2210.12439]. This suggests that “hybrid order” is partly model-dependent: in some symmetry classes it is naturally static, in others it requires quasienergy engineering.

Finally, gapless and gapped realizations should not be conflated. The HOTDSC and the higher-order Weyl superconductor are gapless topological states whose hybrid character involves the coexistence of bulk nodes, surface Majorana Fermi arcs, and hinge modes [1909.07980]. By contrast, the YSR network and honeycomb altermagnet heterostructure are primarily discussed as two-dimensional systems with gapped bulks and mixed edge-corner boundary structure [2604.08675, 2601.05662]. A plausible implication is that hybrid order is best regarded not as a single universal phase class, but as a family of bulk–boundary correspondences in which more than one boundary codimension remains topologically active at once.

Source: https://www.emergentmind.com/topics/hybrid-order-topological-superconductors