Natural Averaging May Complement Known Biological Constraints in Bi-parental Reproduction's Advantages Over Mono-parental in Conserving Species Quantitative Traits

Abstract: Commonly recognized evolutionarily relevant effects of sexual reproduction include increased diversity, accelerated adaptation, and constrained accumulation of deleterious mutations, along with a secondary effect of species genotype homogenization. Still, strong published arguments prioritize the contribution of biological mechanisms underlying bi-parental reproduction to maintaining species identity above their contribution to diversity. Here, we contribute to the latter position. In an initial mathematical analysis and simulation, we show that in an environment where copying is prone to error, quantitative polygenic traits that are shared within a parents' generation are transmitted to future generations under bi-parental reproduction with less deviation than under asexual reproduction. Furthermore, we abstract away many biological details, and show that this trait conservation is a general statistical effect, driven by the very nature of mixing of parental traits, separately from DNA repair and from the reproductive failures, barriers and disadvantages induced by biological mechanisms. Since survival of ecosystem interaction networks depends on the ability of individuals to replace the networked function of failing, dying or absent members of the same species, more faithful inheritance of common traits helps sustain species and ecosystems. This sustaining effect may have contributed to the very evolution of sexual reproduction.